NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage Stuffed Animal Mouse 15” Smiling By Animal Fair Inc. 1977
Buy: $20.00
Vintage Twinkle Bears Plush Blue Stuffed Animal 1995 Toy Fantasy Ltd. Heart
Buy: $59.95
Douglas Cuddle Toys Extremely Rare Black Long-haired Cat Angus Cuddle Toys 2016
Buy: $379.99
VINTAGE RUSHTON STAR CREATION RUBBER FACE WHITE KITTY CAT STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH
Buy: $1600.00
Vintage 1992 Barney The Purple Dinosaur Plush
Buy: $22.99
Vintage Kenner Yum Yums Collection Pink Cheery Cherry Snowcone Poodle Plush 1989
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Jerry Elsner Rabbit Fur Cat Kitten Orange Tabby Blue Eyes READ
Buy: $35.00
Vintage MUNCHIN Bunny Rubber Face Anthropomorphic Rabbit Plush Carrot Pink Russ
Buy: $9.99
Vintage Kenner Hallmark  13" Yum Yums  1989 LOT
Buy: $500.00
Jim Henson Baby Fozzie Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 8" Green Scarf EUC Vintage
Buy: $9.95
VINTAGE RUSHTON STAR CREATION RUBBER FACE PUPPY DOG W/ WORM STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH
Buy: $2000.00
Vintage 80's Chubbles Plush Blue Cloak Nose Lights Up Makes Noise
Buy: $24.95
Rushton Star Creation Vintage Plush Duck Goose Swan 15" Tall
Buy: $94.99
Vtg Rare Pillow People 24" Window Rattler 1985 DJ Tanner Full House Plush READ
Buy: $269.99
Vintage Plush Toy 1984 Gremlins Applause Gizmo
Buy: $54.99
Vtg. Realistic Limited Ed.Bob Cat Lynx Stuffed Animal Plush Handcrafted Italy
Buy: $297.50
POP! Rehoming 1985 Vintage Plush *Pretty Bit* Popple Stuffed Animal--Clean/Cute!
Buy: $60.00
Vintage 1992 The Lyons Group Baby Bop Plush - 14 in - Korea
Buy: $12.99
JAKKS Pacific Doodle Bear Girl Ballerina Tye-dye 2005 16” Plush
Buy: $12.99
Vintage Kitty Kitty Kittens Plush Siamese Cat Tan & Black Green Eyes Tyco 1992
Buy: $49.95
Vintage 1986 TARA TOYS Kennel Kuddlees In Original Box!! T4
Buy: $13.18
Vintage 1985 Pre Applause Dustyn Schear Cat 8" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $18.00
Vintage 1982 Poochie Plush Dog Pink White Mattel Stuffed Animal Puppy
Buy: $24.95
1986 Popples Puffball White 12" Plush 1986 - Yellow Hair, Blue, Pink, Orange
Buy: $25.00
Vintage Rushton Star Creation Rubber Face Bear Plush Doll Standing Smiling
Buy: $409.99
Vintage 1999 Playskool / Hasbro Dragon Tales Babysitting Cassie  New Unopened
Buy: $47.99
Vintage Revenge On The Boss 1989 Tear Apart Stress Doll Plush Brand New In Box
Buy: $14.97
Island of Misfit Toys Frosty the Snowman Plush 1999 CVS With Tags
Buy: $25.00
Chubbles Vintage 1985 Light Activated Plush Toy-unTESTED
Buy: $15.00
Handmade Meerkat Mohair & Stuffed w/ Excelsior Fully Articulated Animal
Buy: $216.75
Vintage Pillow People Mini Sweet Dreams 1985 Plush Blonde Girl 8"
Buy: $29.00
Vintage Realistic Life Like Lynx Bob Cat Stuffed Animal Plush Handcrafted Italy
Buy: $297.50
Vintage 1980 American Greetings Super Pickle Plush Stuffed Toy Amtoy
Buy: $34.99
Vintage Kewpie  Red Plush Doll Vinyl Face Knickerbocker Tag 10"
Buy: $17.99
FLASH SALE🌟MINT HENRY THE DOG 18" PLUSH ANiMAL FAiR TOY 1971 NO. 55317
$35.98 (0 bids)
Vintage Teletubbies Tinky Winky Purple Plush 13" Playskool 1998
Buy: $17.99
Vintage Furrever Friends Blushytail NIB 1986 Kitty Cat Plush Kenner SCARCE!
Buy: $350.00
Teletubbies LAA-LAA YELLOW 16" 1998 TALKING Playskool Plush Doll WORKING Vintage
Buy: $18.95
Vintage RUSHTON Clown Doll Star Creation Stuffed Plush Toy Rubber Face 18"
Buy: $109.99
Rushton Sad Crying Bear Rubber Face Plush Stuffed Animal Beige Brown Vintage 9"
Buy: $349.00
VINTAGE PULLSTRING "HARRY AND THE HENDERSONS PLUSH TALKER" NR
$44.99 (0 bids)
Rushton Cat Vintage Good Condition Tagged 💯 Cute
$425.00 (0 bids)
stuffed animals plush rabbit vintage
Buy: $10.00
Vintage 1992 Commonwealth 24” Clown Plush Doll
Buy: $14.00
Lot of 15 Stuffed Animals Wetmore Forest Unicorno Domo Plush Kirby Grumpy Cat
Buy: $24.99
Crash Bandicoot 11” Stuffed Plush Play-By-Play Universal 2001 Sony PlayStation
Buy: $29.99
Vintage 1989 PJ Sparkles Pink Bunny Sparklins Plush Mattel
Buy: $100.00
Flip A Zoo Persephone Unicorn / Imogen Dragon 2017 Cuddly Reversable Plush Toy
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Scooby Doo Cartoon Network Birthday Present Plush Stuffed Animal 11"
Buy: $13.95
Vintage Ajean Teddy Bear Plush With Overalls 60s  Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $15.00
Oddish Pokemon Bandai Friends 1999 Plush 5" Toy Doll Japan
Buy: $20.95
Vintage Donkey Kong Plush Nintendo of American 1982 Antics 12" Toy Rare
Buy: $49.99
NWT Vintage 1990 Burger King Marge Simpson Plush Hard Head The Simpsons 12"
Buy: $10.95
Kenner Furever Friends White Blushy Tail
Buy: $20.00
Vintage 1994 Cornelius  Plush Pig Spotted Tan Black
Buy: $14.95
Homestuck 6.5" Mini Scalemate Plush: Yellow
Buy: $29.99
Vintage 1950's Rushton Monkey Chico Stuffed Animal
Buy: $49.00
LOT RARE Squeezems CLARENCE COW Plush Fundamental Too Mooing Squeezem's SEE DESC
Buy: $79.99
Dragon Tales Cassie Plush & BABIES!  1999 Collectibles
Buy: $159.00
VINTAGE SHIRT TALES BOGEY RICK TYG HALLMARK PLUSH 1981
Buy: $18.99
VTG 1996 GANZ SOLID WHITE FUR PLUSH 12" BEAR WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $9.99
All-Star & Casey Snorks lot vintage plush dolls Applause 1983 Stuffed Animals
Buy: $24.99
Vintage Eden Sheep Lamb Plush Musical Wind Up Mary Had a Little Lamb Blue Bow
Buy: $22.95
Vintage 1990 Barney the Dinosaur - The Lyons Group Dakin - Backyard Gang - 10.5"
Buy: $89.99
Vintage Wonder Toys Dog  Plush Collectible Stuffed Animal Soft Carnival Prize
Buy: $9.99
Impulse Items Jester Elf Clown Doll Creepy Plush Stuffed Toy 22” WORN - READ
Buy: $21.60
Vintage-modern Fuzzy Flocked Animal Lot X22 Puppy’s-monkeys-dogs-goat +++
Buy: $17.00
Vtg Spike Stegosaurus Land Before Time Stuffed Animal Dinosaur Plush (1988)
Buy: $39.99
Playskool Nosy Bear Snow Nose. VTG. 1987
Buy: $25.00
NWT Sealed Vintage 1990 Burger King Marge Simpson Plush Hard Head The Simpsons
Buy: $11.95
Gonzo the Muppet Plush, 7 inches tall, 1991 Amerawell PREOWNED
Buy: $16.95
Vintage 1971 "HENRY" Plush Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal  by Animal Fair 11"
Buy: $45.00
Vtg Charleen Kinser Design Rabbit
Buy: $65.00
New Pokémon Celesteela Exclusive 18” Plush Limited Edition Poke Stuffed Animal
Buy: $40.00
Vintage Cut And Sew Cat Pillow Plushie Completed Gray Tabby Cat Lover 10”
Buy: $12.50
Vintage 1987 Baby Miss Piggy Muppet Plush Soft Toy Jim Henson 12 In
Buy: $11.99
Vintage VTG Tyco Doodle Bear Pink 1995 Stuffed Animals 90s Toy Pink NO PEN
Buy: $25.00
Kennel Kudle Puppies Vintage 80's Christmas Santa Hat 1987 NEW Stuffed Plush Toy
Buy: $25.00
Vintage TB Trading Co Rubber Face Praying Teddy Bear 14” Plush Tan With Sleephat
Buy: $15.99
Vtg. Mervyns Floppy Friends Plush White Long Fluffy Hair Cat Kitten Stuffed 22"
Buy: $10.00
Vintage Nosy Bears Bunnies Tiskett Easter 80's Nosy Bunny Purple 1989 Playskool
Buy: $27.87
Vintage Sterling Best Ever Musical Brown Bunny Rabbit 16" Made In U.S.A
Buy: $12.00
1982 Vintage Kamar E.T. Doll 9” Pleather Universal City Studio Plush! Heavy Wear
Buy: $17.99
BARNEY Stuffed Purple Dinosaur Plush 36” The Lyons Group Golden Bear RARE Big
Buy: $214.95
1978 1981 Dakin Garfield Takes the Mountain Plush Sled Winter Hat Scarf TAG
Buy: $21.95
vtg 1984 animal fair CHUBBLES plush w/ hang tag - teal tunic - tested/works AB9
Buy: $28.49
Vintage 1987 Brush A Loves Tyco White Bear Plush Toy BUBBLE LOVE Mirror Rainbows
Buy: $79.99
Vtg Rushton Pink Sleepy Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Plush Felt Eyelashes Floppy Ears
Buy: $100.00
Vintage Bantam Terrycloth Puppy Dog Pastel Blue White Plush Rattle Lovie
Buy: $12.00
NWT Sealed Vintage 1990 Burger King Bart Simpson Plush Hard Head The Simpsons
Buy: $16.95
2-GUND Sani Foam Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Panda Bears 12” 1-white 1 Black White
Buy: $39.99
Antique Plush Easter Bunny Ideal Novelty Stuffed Plush Toy Rabbit 1930's
Buy: $43.00
Steve Irwin Crocodile Hunter Plush Doll 7.5" Animal Planet Figure
Buy: $14.99
Vintage 1984 Zip The Monkey Zippy Plush Doll Fun Farm By Dakin 15” W/ Banana
Buy: $99.99
Ganz Bros Wrinkles Dog Hand Puppet Plush Vintage 1981 7020350
Buy: $18.00
Vintage 1989 Hallmark Yum Yums Pink Cheery Cherry Poodle SnoCone Plush Kenner
Buy: $35.00
Vintage Knickerbocker Plush "Grover"  Muppet 22”
Buy: $24.99
Cream Lamb Sheep w Black Feet Pink Nose Plush 14" Vintage Chosun  International
Buy: $44.99
vintage 1989 POLLY POCKET Complete BEACH PARTY Blue Seashell BLUEBIRD England
Buy: $144.95
Vintage RARE 1970's Plush Handmade Mommy Dog With Three Puppies Nursing
Buy: $189.00