Got Free Shipping? (US) Got Free Shipping? (US) » Collectibles » Holiday & Seasonal »  Paper Magic Brand Holiday Seasonal
NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*

Image Size:

Right now on eBay
Vintage Paper Magic Group Halloween Spooky Shadows Revolving Projection Light
Buy: $45.00
Paper Magic 1999 Light Up Disney Winnie The Pooh Blow Mold JackOLantern Pumpkin
Buy: $49.45
Twinkle Happy Halloween DOOR COVER Ghosts Pumpkins Lights Vintage 2001
Buy: $14.99
VTG 1998 Halloween Skull Hat Totem Stacked Foam Totem Lighted Paper Magic Group
Buy: $34.99
VTG 1998 The Paper Magic Group Halloween Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Plug-In Lighted
Buy: $19.00
5' Green Alien Hanging Halloween Prop The Paper Magic Group 1999 Five Feet Rare
Buy: $100.00
STAR WARS Movie Valentines Cards Box of 16 Kids With Pencils BRAND NEW Official
Buy: $8.29
Vtg 90's Cryptic Kook Wall Plaque The Paper Magic Group Halloween Blowmold Man
Buy: $40.15
Bluey Dog 16 Valentines Day Cards, 16 Fuzzy Stickers 2 (Designs)
Buy: $12.99
Vtg Die Cut Halloween Lot Wall Decorations Black Cats Pumpkins Witches Ghost
Buy: $110.00
HALLOWEEN 36” Wall Decor Paper Magic Group 2 Pcs
$1.00 (0 bids)
Minecraft 16 Valentines Day Cards and 16 Pencils Classroom Exchange New
Buy: $12.99
Paper Magic Vintage 35" Blow Mold Spooky Halloween Tree Stomp Light J-O-L Works!
Buy: $120.00
18 NIB CHRISTMAS HOLIDAY CARDS CELEBRATE THE HOLIDAY SEASON RECYCLED PENGUIN
Buy: $21.99
Vintage Paper Magic Group GRIM REAPER SKELETON Halloween Blow Mold 10" NO LIGHT
Buy: $69.95
VTG 1995/97 Halloween Pumpkin Jack O Lantern 2 Piece Blow Mold Fillers (12) Mini
Buy: $12.50
32 Insect Valentines Day Cards with Tattoo's 🔥FREE SHIPPING🔥
Buy: $5.59
VTG HALLOWEEN GRIM REAPER 9" BLOW MOLD PLASTIC DECORATION 1996 PAPER MAGIC GROUP
Buy: $40.00
Vintage 1996 The PAPER MAGIC GROUP BLOWMOLD Wizard HALLOWEEN DECORATION
Buy: $29.99
Stacked Jack O Lantern Tower Light HALLOWEEN PUMPKIN Used
Buy: $24.00
Paper Magic Christmas Cards Good to be a Child OOP Unused 14 Cards / Envelopes
Buy: $14.95
Vintage 1998 Paper Magic Group Lighted Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Foam 9"
Buy: $30.00
HTF VTG 1996 THE PAPER MAGIC GROUP BLOWMOLD WITCH SKULLS HALLOWEEN DECORATION
Buy: $84.99
Vintage Halloween Stacking Skulls Totem Tower Paper Magic Group 1998 *No Light
Buy: $24.99
Frankenstein Monster Paper Magic Group 21" Halloween Hanging Decor Worn As Is
Buy: $69.99
Vintage paper magic group Gargoyle Halloween Decoration wall decor Rare !
Buy: $45.00
Vtg Halloween Decoration Creepy Critters and Webs The Paper Magic Group 1995 NIB
Buy: $14.99
42 Holiday Cards - All One Design Foil-Lined Self-Sealing Envelopes - PaperMagic
Buy: $13.74
New Paper Magic 24 Sports Valentine Flik'm Flyers Valentines Day Cards
Buy: $9.00
Paper Magic Halloween Blow Mold Danger Haunted House Frankenstein NOT WORKING
Buy: $30.00
Paper Magic Fiddlestix Snowmen & sleds open box 28 cards
Buy: $15.21
Holy Family Christmas cards open box 18 cards & envelopes by Paper Magic
Buy: $14.25
1996 Paper Magic Group scary SKELETON Halloween Blow Mold vintage reaper decor
Buy: $90.00
Set of 21 Christmas Cards & Envelopes Snowman Penguins Tree Holidays Snow Gifts
Buy: $12.95
Paper Magic Christmas Cards 12 Cards & Envelopes New
Buy: $13.99
Vintage Paper Magic Holiday Christmas Cards - Stockings - Set Of 15 - New
Buy: $12.99
Vintage Halloween Garland Jack O Lantern Tissue Paper Honeycomb NIP 1990s
Buy: $12.99
Vtg All Wax Candle Easter Eggs Basket Pastel Unscented 1999 By Paper Magic NEW
Buy: $21.99
24 Sports Valentines Day Cards Flik'M Flyers 🔥FREE SHIPPING🔥
Buy: $5.59
Dinosaur humor Christmas cards sealed box 20 cards "Joy of Christmas"
Buy: $15.74
Paper Magic Christmas Greeting Cards/Envelopes 55 New Old Stock Vintage USA
Buy: $38.95
Vintage Tissue Garland Paper Magic Group Christmas Candy Cane Bows
Buy: $16.99
Vintage Christmas Decoration Tissue Paper Garland Snowflakes
Buy: $16.99
1997 The Paper Magic Group Lighted Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Foam 17'' TA
Buy: $63.74
32 Olivia Classroom Exchange Valentine Day Cards with Stickers
Buy: $9.74
9" Lighted Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin 1998 Paper Magic Group Blow
Buy: $18.95
Vintage Halloween Window Decal Decor Restix Ghost Bats Paper Magic Group
Buy: $11.12
Halloween Pumpkin Blow Mold Light Up Eyes Wall Hanging Paper Magic Group 1997
Buy: $60.00
Paw Patrol 16 Mini Valentines Day Cards & Envelopes, 16 Jumbo Stickers
Buy: $12.99
Vintage Paper Magic Holiday Christmas Cards - Snowman - Set Of 18 - New
Buy: $14.99
Mr Glow N Pumpkin Twinkle Halloween Flashing Eyes Hanging Decoration Vintage NOS
Buy: $22.22
Vintage 1999 The Paper Magic Group Blow Mold Ghost Head Rare With Hands
Buy: $60.00
Holy Family Christmas Cards by Paper Magic 16 cards
Buy: $17.31
Vintage Halloween Foam Mold Light Up 3 Stack Pumpkin Jack-a-Lantern 1998 10"
Buy: $26.99
REALLY CUTE Valentines Stickers LLAMA DOG PORCUPINE GLASSES Fun Goof (2) 32
Buy: $9.99
VTG 1999 The Paper Magic Group Halloween Pumpkin Jack O’Lantern Trio Light-Up
Buy: $26.39
Vintage Rubber Latex Rubber Magic Group Witch Roughly 22" Halloween Unknown Year
Buy: $50.00
11 Vintage Paper Magic Group Halloween Presto Stick Window Decals Pumpkins USA
Buy: $10.87
VTG Paper Magic Group 22" Frankenstein Halloween Decor Latex Prop Hanging
Buy: $72.00
Disney WINNIE THE POOH Paper Magic Company Christmas Holiday Greeting Cards
Buy: $14.99
1998 Paper Magic Group Halloween Howling Werewolf Plastic Jack O Lantern
Buy: $25.50
Paw Patrol 32 Valentines Day Cards Paper Magic NIB
Buy: $11.00
Fun-World Scream Ghost (1) ~ Paper Magic Pumpkin Heads (3) Halloween Bungees
Buy: $56.00
1995 Spider-Man Marvel Comics 34 Valentines Cards Paper Magic NIB
Buy: $15.99
1998 The Paper Magic Group Lighted Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Tested
Buy: $24.95
Moving Eyes Portrait Paper Magic Group 2000 Sealed
Buy: $35.00
VTG Santa Christmas Cards LEAFStamped Envelopes Beacon Hill Sloan NEW Set of 16
Buy: $29.99
32 Tie Dienos Tattoo Valentines Day Cards 8 Different Designs 3+
Buy: $9.93
Joyful Wishes little girl angels Christmas Cards by Paper Magic 16 cards
Buy: $16.26
4 Vintage Eckerd Easter Die Cuts-Paper Magic
Buy: $14.99
1997 Purple Spider w/ Lights & Sounds Hanging Halloween Decoration Paper Magic
Buy: $27.50
VTG 1998 The Paper Magic Group Lighted Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Works!
Buy: $29.00
Star Wars 32 Valentines Cards & 32 Tattoos With Heart Sealed Stickers
Buy: $9.99
HTF VTG 1996 THE PAPER MAGIC GROUP BLOWMOLD WIZARD CAT HALLOWEEN DECORATION
Buy: $84.99
Star Wars Box Of 16 Valentines Cards With 16 Pencils 8 Designs-R2D2 Yoda Vader..
Buy: $6.29
Vintage 1998 Pumpkin Halloween Light Up Foam Blow Mold Jack-O-Lantern Casper
Buy: $46.50
Tom Arma Christmas Tree Baby Christmas Cards lot of 14 by Paper Magic Group
Buy: $15.39
Church in Snow Christmas Cards by Paper Magic 18 cards
Buy: $17.31
MINT Vintage 1995 Scary Skulls Cranes Halloween 9 inches +Original Box 90's RARE
Buy: $29.99
Halloween Dracula Vampire 3D Window Stickers Cling
Buy: $19.99
Vintage 1993 Paper Magic Trendmasters Foam Light Up Halloween Pumpkin
Buy: $29.99
BROKEN 1999 Ghost Light Up Eyes The Paper Magic Group Halloween Wall Door Decor
Buy: $19.99
Vintage The Paper Magic Group Halloween Pumpkin With Black Cat NOT WORKING
Buy: $13.99
Vintage Paper Magic Holiday Christmas Cards - North Pole Santa - Set Of 18 - New
Buy: $17.99
Vintage 1997 The Paper Magic Group Glow In The Dark Skeleton Lawn Decoration
Buy: $20.99
VTG 1996 THE PAPER MAGIC GROUP BLOWMOLD Grim Reaper Skulls HALLOWEEN DECORATION
Buy: $84.99
Dinosaur humor Christmas cards sealed box 20 cards "Bikini"
Buy: $15.74
VTG ‘96 Halloween Skull Hitchhiking Ghost Haunted Mansion Knockoff Motion Sensor
Buy: $24.95
HTF VTG 1996 THE PAPER MAGIC GROUP BLOWMOLD GARGOYLE STAUTE HALLOWEEN DECORATION
Buy: $84.99
16cnt Kitten Cat Christmas Cards Stocking
Buy: $12.97
Paper Magic Group Twinkle VTG Happy Halloween DOOR COVER Ghosts Pumpkins Lights
Buy: $29.99
Vtg 1999 The Paper Magic Group 3 Pumpkin Jack-o-lantern Lamp trendmasters style
Buy: $25.56
New + Pack RA Home 8 Box Christmas Cards & Envelopes Penquin Sparkle Family
Buy: $12.14
DC Comics Wonder Woman 16 Valentines with Graphite Pencils by Paper Magic
Buy: $16.94
New + Pack Paper Magic 20 Box Christmas Cards & Envelopes Mr. Snowman
Buy: $12.14
Disney Princess 32 Valentines with 32 Glitter Tattoos
Buy: $15.00
New L.O.L. Surprise 32 Valentines Day Cards
Buy: $7.00
1996 Paper Magic Group Scream Movie Ghostface Wall Plaque Motion Activated
Buy: $19.98
VTG 1999 Halloween The Paper Magic Group Stacked Skull Blow Mold Light Up 9.5”
Buy: $40.49
1998 Halloween Pumpkin Scarecrow Foam Blow Mold - The Paper Magic Group, Inc.
Buy: $65.00