Got Free Shipping? (US) Got Free Shipping? (US) » Toys & Hobbies » Collectible Card Games »  Nightmare Horse Creature/Monster Type Collectible Card Games
NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*

Image Size:

Right now on eBay
Rapidash Pokemon Center New York 2002 Black Star Promos - 51 CGC Gem Mint 10
Buy: $55.00
Shadow Rider Calyrex V 235/184 CSR VMAX CLIMAX Japanese Pokemon PSA 7
Buy: $30.00
Ice Rider Calyrex V SR SA 073/070 s6H Silver Lance MINT Pokemon Card Japanese P
Buy: $31.90
Pokemon Card Shadow Rider Calyrex V 235/184 CSR S8b VMAX Climax Japanese
Buy: $34.00
Ice Ryder Calyrex Vmax Astral Radiance TG29/TG30 Gold Secret Rare NM/Mint
Buy: $2.75
Stallion of Ashmouth - The List Reprints: #SOI-136, Magic: The Gathering Nm R17
Buy: $1.39
Nightmare - Magic 2015 (M15): #276, Magic: The Gathering Nm R19
Buy: $1.39
Ninetales ex - 038/165 SV 151 - Double Rare Holo Pokemon TCG NM
Buy: $3.29
Pokemon TCG Shadowless Base Set Ponyta 60/102
Buy: $4.00
Ninetails Ex 151 Japanese 038/165 RR
Buy: $2.00
1X LP Nightmare Horse - DR1-EN025 - Common Dark Revelation Yugioh Unlimited
Buy: $1.69
Yugioh Nightmare Horse PGD-077 1st Edition Common Damaged X2
Buy: $4.00
MTG Calamity, Galloping Inferno *FOIL* 116 Outlaws of Thunder Junction Rare NM
Buy: $1.99
Ice Rider Calyrex VMAX Chilling Reign 046/198 Holo Ultra Rare- Pokémon TCG
Buy: $3.99
Rapidash 44/64 - Uncommon - WoTC Vintage Jungle Set Pokemon Card NM/LP
Buy: $4.99
MTG Magic The Gathering Card Stallion of Ashmouth Creature Nightmare Horse
Buy: $8.00
MTG Nightmare 30th Anniversary Edition 412/594 Regular Rare
Buy: $2.49
​Nightmare Moderately Played Fourth Edition ​​​​​
Buy: $1.38
MTG Magic The Gathering Card Plague Mare Creature Nightmare Horse Black M19
Buy: $7.97
Pokémon TCG Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX Sword & Shield - Astral Radiance TG18/TG30
Buy: $6.79
Pokemon Card Ponyta #77 PokeTrivia Burger King Promo 1999 NM
Buy: $1.99
Blitzle SWSH Black Star Promos SWSH173 Regular Promo Pokémon TCG
Buy: $1.49
PSA 9 MINT Ponyta 1st Edition Shadowless Base Set Common 60/102 Pokemon
Buy: $60.00
Carnival Hellsteed - Return to Ravnica - Rare - 147
Buy: $1.41
Dark Rapidash 44/82 Team Rocket Non-Holo Uncommon Pokemon TCG (LP)
Buy: $1.87
Shadow Rider Calyrex V 172/198 Pokemon Chilling Regin Alternate Art Ultra Rare
Buy: $30.00
Pokemon TCG Ponyta Base Set 60/102 Shadowless 1999 WOTC DMG
Buy: $1.89
Nightmare - Seventh Edition - Rare - 150
Buy: $1.75
Rapidash - 44/64 🔥 Ungraded MINT 🔥 Jungle Set Uncommon Pokemon & Free Ponyta
Buy: $14.97
Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX 075/198 Pokemon TCG Chilling Reign!! AMAZING CENTERING
Buy: $3.50
Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX HR 085/070 s6K Jet Black Spirit Pokemon Card Japanese
Buy: $19.80
SGC 9.5 Shadow Rider Calyrex V Chilling Reign Alt Art #172 Mint + 🔥
Buy: $45.99
Nightmare - Revised Edition - Rare - 28
Buy: $6.41
MTG Nightmare Magic 2010 107/249 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.99
1999 Pokemon TCG Ponyta 60/120 Shadowless Fire WOTC Vintage MP FREE Shipping
Buy: $1.79
PSA 10 Gem Mint Pokémon TCG Shadow Rider Calyrex V Chilling Reign 172/198
Buy: $59.99
Ice Rider Calyrex V 45/198 Pokemon Card Ultra rare Chilling Reign NM
Buy: $2.33
Shadow Rider Calyrex V 074/198 Holo Ultra Rare Pokemon NM Fresh Pull
Buy: $4.49
Nightmare [Unlimited Edition] MTG Heavily Played
Buy: $92.68
2002 Rapidash Black Star Promo #51 Pokemon Center New York CGC 7.5 Near Mint+
Buy: $37.00
Shadow Rider Calyrex vMAX 204 NM+ Full Art Holo [SECRET RARE] SWSH EN Pokémon NP
Buy: $9.99
Blitzle 195/182 - Paradox Rift - Illustration Rare Holo Pokemon Card NM
Buy: $5.00
MTG Nightmare Welcome Deck 2017 017/030 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.75
Pokemon TCG Card Ponyta 077/165 Scarlet & Violet 151 Common NM
Buy: $1.99
MTG Nightmare Origins 282/272 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.99
CARNIVAL HELLSTEED ~ NM ~ MTG Magic the Gathering - Return to Ravnica RTR 147
Buy: $1.69
​Nightmare Near Mint Magic 2010 ​​​​​
Buy: $1.38
Ice Ryder Calyrex Vmax Astral Radiance TG29/TG30 Gold Secret Rare NM/Mint
Buy: $3.79
2002 Rapidash Black Star Promo #51 Pokemon Center New York CGC 10 Gem Mint
Buy: $50.00
Ponyta 60/102 Pokemon Card Vintage Unlimited Base Set WOTC
Buy: $1.99
Nightmare Magic 2015 Core Set M15 Light Play LP Magic the Gathering
Buy: $1.63
Pokemon TCG: Rapidash 22/195 Holo Silver Tempest
Buy: $3.89
​Carnival Hellsteed Moderately Played Foil Return to Ravnica Prerelease Promos ​
Buy: $1.38
1X NM Nightmare Horse - DR1-EN025 - Common Dark Revelation 1 DR1
Buy: $1.82
Pokemon TCG Card Blitzle 062/182 S&V Paradox Rift Common NM
Buy: $1.99
Pokemon Card Japanese VMAX CLIMAX ICE Rider Calyrex UR 278/184 S8b MINT
Buy: $10.98
Ice Rider Calyrex V SR SA 073/070 s6H Silver Lance MINT Pokemon Card Japanese
Buy: $32.80
MTG Underworld Charger Theros Beyond Death (THB) Common Magic #120/254 Unplayed
Buy: $1.49
Shadow Rider Calyrex V Chilling Reign 074/198 Holo Ultra Rare Pokémon
Buy: $1.99
MTG NIGHTMARE 17 NM-M The List Rare Welcome Deck 2017 W17
Buy: $1.20
Plague Mare *Uncommon* Magic MtG x1 Core 2019 M19
Buy: $1.69
Rapidash 1st Edition 44/64 PSA 7 1999 Jungle Graded Pokemon Card
Buy: $25.00
​Nightmare Lightly Played Magic Origins ​​​​​
Buy: $1.32
Ninetails Ex 151 Japanese 038/165 RR - NM/M
Buy: $2.99
Magic the Gathering (mtg): THB: Underworld Charger (x 4)
Buy: $2.97
ICE Rider Calyrex VMAX UR 278/184 s8b VMAX Climax MINT Pokemon Card Japanese
Buy: $8.80
MTG Underworld Charger Theros Beyond Death 120/254 Regular Common
Buy: $1.49
Ice Rider Calyrex VMAX TG29/TG30 Sword & Shield - Astral Radiance Pokémon TCG NM
Buy: $4.49
Yu-Gi-Oh! Dark Revelation Volume 1 Common Set List DR1 (You Select The Card)
Buy: $2.25
Nightmare - Magic Origins - Rare - 282
Buy: $1.49
Pokemon Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX 075/198 Chilling Reign NM
Buy: $2.25
Vulpix 68/102 - Common 1999 English Base Set Pokemon Card - Near Mint (NM) & LP
Buy: $6.99
Pokemon Card Japanese Shadow Rider Calyrex V SR 075/070 s6K HOLO MINT
Buy: $15.70
MTG Carnival Hellsteed x4 Return to Ravnica Rare LP Playset
Buy: $1.49
Ponyta 60/102 - Common 1999 English Base Set Pokemon Card - Near Mint (NM) & LP
Buy: $4.99
Pokémon TCG Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX Chilling Reign 075/198 Holo Ultra Rare NM
Buy: $3.00
​Stallion of Ashmouth Near Mint Mystery Booster ​​​​​
Buy: $1.38
Nightmare Magic 2015 Core Set M15 Light Play LP Magic the Gathering
Buy: $1.00
Shadow Rider Calyrex V 171/198 Full Art Chilling Reign Pokemon Card UNPLAYED
Buy: $6.00
Ice Rider Calyrex Vmax 046/198 Full Art Pokemon Chilling Reign FRESH PULL
Buy: $20.00
Shadow Rider Calyrex VMAX 075/198 Chilling Reign Ultra Rare Holo Pokémon 2021 NM
Buy: $3.99
Shadow Rider Calyrex VMax 075/198 Full Art Rare - 2021 Pokemon Chilling Reign
Buy: $4.99
Pokemon Card | Scarlet & Violet - Paradox Rift: Blitzle 062/182 - Reverse Holo
Buy: $2.49
Pokemon TCG: Rapidash 22/195 Holo Silver Tempest
Buy: $3.00
MTG Underworld Charger Theros Beyond Death 120/254 Regular Common
Buy: $1.49
MTG Stallion of Ashmouth Shadows over Innistrad (SOI) Common #136/297 Unplayed
Buy: $1.49
​Nightmare Near Mint The List ​​​​​
Buy: $1.38
​Nightmare Near Mint Welcome Deck 2017 ​​​​​
Buy: $1.38
1999 Pokemon TCG Ponyta 60/120 Shadowless Fire
Buy: $1.65
​Carnival Hellsteed Moderately Played Foil Return to Ravnica ​​​​​
Buy: $1.32
Ice Rider Calyrex V 45/198 Pokemon Card Ultra rare Chilling Reign NM
Buy: $2.50
Pokémon TCG Ice Rider Calyrex VMAX Sword & Shield - Astral Radiance TG29/TG30 NM
Buy: $4.45
Pokemon TCG Card Rapidash 078/165 Scarlet & Violet 151 Uncommon NM
Buy: $1.99
​Nightmare Lightly Played Magic 2015 ​​​​​
Buy: $1.32
MTG Nightmare – 9th Edition Card # 150 Magic The Gathering
Buy: $2.46
Nightmare *Rare* Magic MtG x1 M10 SP
Buy: $1.89
Plague Mare (114) Core Set 2019 x4 4x M19 MTG Playset Magic
Buy: $1.50
Horsea 58/97 2003 EX Dragon Common Pokémon TCG Near Mint or Better
Buy: $1.99
MTG Magic The Gathering Card Underworld Charger Creature Nightmare Horse Black
Buy: $7.99
Pokemon Card Japanese Ice Rider Calyrex V SR SA 073/070 s6H HOLO MINT
Buy: $62.70