Jim Kelly Player/Athlete Sports Trading Cards | Got Free Shipping? (US)

Got Free Shipping? (US)

Got Free Shipping? (US) » Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop » Sports Trading Cards » Jim Kelly Player/Athlete Sports Trading Cards

Price Guides & Publications Sealed Trading Card Boxes Sealed Trading Card Cases Sealed Trading Card Packs Sport Trading Card NFTs Storage & Display Supplies Trading Card Box & Case Breaks Trading Card Lots Trading Card Sets Trading Card Singles Uncut Trading Card Sheets Wrappers & Empty Card Boxes

NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*

Image Size:

Best Match Newest Ending Lowest Price Highest Price

Right now on eBay

2023 jim kelly impeccable Panini Auto 07/25

JIM KELLY MINT GAMBLERS BILLS HOF ROOKIE CARD 45 RC SP 1985 TOPPS USFL

Joe Montana Jim Kelly 2022 Leaf Vibrance Dual Autograph Auto /4

2023 Leaf History Book Jim Kelly Purple Book Signing Patch Auto 08/10 Bills

2022 Panini Mosaic Football HoloFame Insert Complete Your Set You Pick NFL Card

1987 TOPPS #362 JIM KELLY PSA 9 MINT RC ROOKIE HOF

2023 Mosaic Football BASE Complete Your Set You Pick Card #1-250 PYC

1987 Topps Jim Kelly #362 RC

2023 Panini Prestige Football LIVING LEGENDS Pick Your Card FREE SHIP

$2001 Topps Archives Reserve Jim Kelly Rookie Reprint Refractor #362 Bills MINT$ Buy: $4.25

1989 TOPPS FOOTBALL YOU PICK 1-200 NMMT +FREE FAST SHIPPING!

1984 Jim Kelly USFL Custom Football Card ACEO

1996 Topps #70 Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills

'92 Precious Metal Gold & Platinum Cards: PM NFL Quarterback Series. You Choose!

2023 Leaf History Book Of Legends MARINO-MOSS-THOMAS-PAYTON-GRONKOWSKI 8/24

JOE MONTANA Error Card 1990 Pro Set #2 Jim Kelly 3521 Passing Yards Error PSA 8

2021 National Treasures Treasure Chest 1/1 24 HOF Nfl Players Material Tags BGS

2022 Panini PRIZM PANDORA PREMIUM SET Football 1-200 Base You Pick/Choose! /400

2023 Prestige Xtra Points Green #32 Jim Kelly /199

1988 Topps Set JIM KELLY #221 BUFFALO BILLS ** MINT ** HIGH GRADE **

1994 Pinnacle Football Cards - 1 -135 - Complete Your Set - U You Pick

Jim Kelly 2019 Panini Prizm #263 Buffalo Bills

1996 Topps #385 Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills

1994 PACIFIC CROWN FOOTBALL CARDS SINGLES "U PICK" #5-250 EX-NMT FREE SHIP

1987 Topps #362 Jim Kelly

1987 Topps #362 Jim Kelly Bills NFL - Near Mint - Free Ship

1987 Topps - #362 Jim Kelly (RC) - HOF NM *TEXCARDS*

2023 Panini Prestige #32 Jim Kelly Xtra Points Premium Red /399

2022 Panini Prizm Jim Kelly Black and White Checker PSA 10 Bills HOF!

1994 Skybox Jim Kelly AUTO Autograph Football Card **AUTO SMUDGE**

2018 Panini Illusions Hobby w Jim Kelly #19 Josh Allen RC Rookie Buffalo Bills P

POP 45 PSA 10 RC Jim Kelly 1987 Topps International Rookie Sticker Red Back RARE

1990 TOPPS FOOTBALL #1-220 YOU PICK NMMT + FAST SHIPPING!!

Jim Kelly Bills Topps #362 NFL Trading Card 1987

Jim Kelly Miami Hurricanes 2014 SPx #14 HOF East Brady Pennsylvania 9I

2022 Mosaic Football Base & RC's You Pick Cards 1-400 Debut, RC, Base

2023 Panini Score Showcase Blue Parallel #'d /100 Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills No.271

2022 Panini Donruss Optic Football Pick Your Card/Finish Your Set NM+

Jim Kelly leaf sports heroes auto /10 Buffalo Bills HOF QB

2009 NATIONAL TREASURES JIM KELLY GAME USED WORN FACEMASK AUTO SIGNATURE SP #/12

2006 National Treasures Game Worn Facemask Jim Kelly Auto Face Mask 9/12 Rare

2023 Prestige Football-YOU Pick/Complete Your Set #1-366 Base & RC UPDATED

Jim Kelly 2014 Upper Deck #23 Miami Hurricanes

2021 Panini Classics Timeless Tributes Orange Jim Kelly /10 Buffalo Bills #120

Jim Kelly 1987 Topps Autograph Rookie Card #362 PSA/DNA 10 (Blue)

2000 Fleer greats of the Game Football - You Pick - #1-#100 - nmmt

1988 Topps Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills #221 HOF Qb

1988 Topps Jim Kelly #221 F62

1995 PINNACLE CLUB COLLECTION #130 JIM KELLY BUFFALO BILLS

FREE SHIPPING- 1988 TOPPS JIM KELLY HALL OF FAMER- 2ND TOPPS CARD NEAR MINT!

1995 Pacific Gems of the Crown Jim Kelly Football Card Buffalo Bills #GC-1 HOF

2021 Panini Mosaic Football Base You Pick Card Complete Your Set #1-200 PYC

2020 Panini Chronicles Football Complete Your Set You Pick NFL Card #1-100 PYC

2012 Upper Deck Goodwin Champions Pick Your Card NM-MT

2022 Panini Mosaic Football Base Complete Your Set You Pick NFL Card #1-250 PYC

1991 Pro Set Platinum Jim Kelly #293 Hockey Buffalo Sabres CC

2005 Upper Deck Legends Football Card #40 Jim Kelly

1988 Topps #221 Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills

Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills 1993 Upper Deck #65 Miami Hurricanes 1M

1992 Stadium Club Jim Kelly card #640 Buffalo Bills

JIM KELLY 2011 UD Exquisite Dimensions Shadowbox Auto Signature SP

2021 Panini Classics Classic Combos Purple /25 Jim Kelly Andre Reed #CC-JA HOF

2001 Topps Archives Reserve Jim Kelly Rookie Reprint #85 Bills PWE

Jim Kelly Thurman Thomas 2015 Panini Playbook Auto Booklet #37 048/199 PSA/DNA

Jim Kelly 2023 Mosaic Football RED & YELLOW FUSION Prizm /80 BUFFALO BILLS

Jim Kelly 1991 Pro Set Football 1990 Passing Leader #8 NFL Buffalo Bills QB

2023 Mosaic Football - Base Vets - Complete Your Set

1991 Pro Line Portraits #1 Jim Kelly signed card Buffalo Bills PSA/DNA auto

Jim Kelly, "Buffalo Bills", 1990 Pro Set Football Card #40

2019 Panini Select JIM KELLY SILVER PRIZM #184 BILLS

1993 Bowman Football Jim Kelly Gold Foil #330 HOF Buffalo Bills

1993 Topps Stadium Club Jim Kelly #75 Division Winner SP Football Card Bills

HOF JIM KELLY 2022 PANINI PRESTIGE #38 BILLS / FREE SHIP

JIM KELLY 1995 FLEER METAL #17 BILLS HOF

1989 SCORE FOOTBALL YOU PICK #201 - #330 NMMT *** FREE SHIPPING ***

2019 Panini Prizm Football Complete Your Set You Pick/Choose 201-400 w/ Rookies

2022 Panini Legacy Generations Jim Kelly Josh Allen #G-2 Buffalo Bills

2022 Panini Prizm NFL Football Base Complete Your Set You Pick Card #1-150 PYC

2016 Panini Absolute Jim Kelly & Thurman Thomas Game Used Dual Jersey /25 Bills

1989 Pro Set #22 JIM KELLY Buffalo Bills HOF QB!

JOSH ALLEN JIM KELLY #g-2 2022 PANINI LEGACY BILLS GENERATIONS

1993 Pinnacle Score Football (#181-360) - Complete Your Set - All Cards $1.20

2002 Donruss Elite Michael Vick card #59

2022 Panini Legacy #111 Jim Kelly

1987 Topps #362 Jim Kelly RC

1989 Topps 46 Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills

Jim Kelly 1996 Collector's Choice Football #M3 Buffalo Bills

1996 Crown Royale Football Card #10 Jim Kelly

1995 Sportflix Football Card #161 Jim Kelly GW

2022 Panini Prestige Football You Pick Card Complete Your Set #1-150 PYC BASE

2021 Illusions Tim Tebow Card #10

2022 Panini Contenders #LGD-JKE Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills Legendary

2012 Fleer Retro Metal #M9 Jim Kelly

2022 Select Draft Picks Prizms Purple #61 Jim Kelly /75

1995 Topps Finest JIM KELLY #273 w/coating Buffalo Bills HOF

1996 Playoff Contenders Leather Football *COMPLETE YOUR SET* Pick From List

1986 Jim Kelly USFL Custom Football Card ACEO

Rare Joe Montana #2 Error Card 1989 Pro Set (Jim Kelly 3521 Yards Error)

1984 TOPPS USFL JIM KELLY #36 ROOKIE RC CARD GRADED 8.5 BGS NM-MT+ MINT EDGES

*When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

web analytics