NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $5.98
Choose Your Special Energy Playset 4x Jet Gift Double Turbo Reversal - Pokemon
Buy: $5.98
Buy: $60.00
Ultimate Horror Foil - Unique - Beta - NM - Sorcery: Contested Realm TCG
Buy: $60.00
Buy: $257.00
Gengar 94/165 R Sv2a Scarlet & Violet Masterball Halo
Buy: $257.00
Buy: $15.99
MTG Zellix, Sanity Flayer *FOIL* Commander Legends: Baldur's Gate 652 NM
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $11.39
MTG NM Solphim, Mayhem Dominus Phyrexia: All Will Be One 150/271 Regular Mythic
Buy: $11.39
Buy: $2.59
Pink Horror 136/168 Rare Surge Foil Warhammer 40K MTG Near Mint
Buy: $2.59
Buy: $1.59
MTG Sauron, the Necromancer The Lord of the Rings: 0106 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.59
Buy: $1.64
MTG Overcharged Amalgam Innistrad Crimson Vow 363 Extended Art Rare
Buy: $1.64
Buy: $15.50
MTG Sauron, the Dark Lord *SHOWCASE FOIL* The Lord of the Rings 0329 NM
Buy: $15.50
Buy: $1.39
Sinuous Vermin - Conspiracy: Take the Crown: #46, Magic: The Gathering Nm R20
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $5.00
MTG Drivnod, Carnage Dominus Phyrexia: All Will Be One
Buy: $5.00
Buy: $1.39
MTG Smeagol, Helpful Guide The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth 0231...
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $14.95
MTG Kederekt Parasite Conflux 48/145 Regular Rare
Buy: $14.95
Buy: $70.00
1x Gisela the Broken Blade Borderless FOIL Secret Lair MTG 1335 Angels
Buy: $70.00
Buy: $4.99
MTG The Gitrog Monster Shadows Over Innistrad 245/297 Regular Mythic x1
Buy: $4.99
Buy: $29.99
Magic: The Gathering Mondrak, Glory Dominus JAPANESE One 023/271 *FOIL* Mythic
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $10.00
MTG Phyrexian Obliterator Phyrexia: All Will Be One 105/271 Regular Mythic
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $29.99
Mondrak, Glory Dominus Phyrexia: All Will Be One - Japanese - NM
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $1.39
Infectious Horror - Conflux: #47, Magic: The Gathering NM R1
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
Phyrexian Revoker - Magic 2015 (M15): #225, Magic: The Gathering Nm R23
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $3.35
MTG, Cleaver Skaab, Commander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt, 049 Regular, Rare
Buy: $3.35
Buy: $1.58
Thrummingbird (288) Showcase Phyrexia: All Will Be One x4 4x ONE MTG Magic
Buy: $1.58
Buy: $9.99
MTG Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus Phyrexia: All Will Be One 195/271 Regular Mythic
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $4.99
MTG Phyrexian Negator Duel Decks: Phyrexia vs. the Coalition 1/71 Foil Mythic
Buy: $4.99
Buy: $5.50
MTG Sauron, the Necromancer *SHOWCASE FOIL* The Lord of the Rings 0310 NM
Buy: $5.50
Buy: $9.99
MTG Phyrexia All Will Be One Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus Showcase
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $5.49
The Gitrog, Ravenous Ride - FOIL - Outlaws of Thunder Junction MTG Mythic 0206
Buy: $5.49
Buy: $2.69
4x Eldrazi Horror - Horror double sided Token - NM - Battle for Baldur's Gate
Buy: $2.69
Buy: $35.00
Gisela, the Broken Blade Brisela, Voice of Nightmares - Foil
Buy: $35.00
Buy: $4.25
MTG CMD: LOTR: Tales of Middle-earth LTC Sauron, Lord of the Rings MINT (SELECT)
Buy: $4.25
Buy: $5.50
4x HORROR ENERGY 172/192 - REBEL CLASH Pokemon -Special Energy- Playset - NM
Buy: $5.50
Buy: $28.99
MTG The Dark DRK Eater of the Dead DMG - NM (SELECT)
Buy: $28.99
Buy: $2.99
4x Dauthi Horror - LP - Tempest - mtg - SPARROW MAGIC
Buy: $2.99
Buy: $2.99
MTG - Phyrexian Negator - 99’ World Champ - J.Slemr - MP - Free Shipping!
Buy: $2.99
Buy: $29.95
MTG Solphim, Mayhem Dominus NM Phyrexia: All Will Be One Oil Slick Raised Foil
Buy: $29.95
Buy: $4.99
MTG Sauron, Lord of the Rings Tales of Middle-earth Commander 0004 FOIL, NM!
Buy: $4.99
Buy: $5.97
Phyrexian Negator #65 Rare Creature, LP, Urza's Destiny, MTG
Buy: $5.97
Buy: $1.38
Nihiloor Near Mint Foil Dungeons & Dragons: Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Buy: $1.38
Buy: $25.00
MTG MISPRINT Abomination of Gudul Khans of Tarkir FADED PIC/NO MANA
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $8.99
Force of Will Armament Upgrade Elektra: Horror Fo Crimson Moon's Battleground
Buy: $8.99
Buy: $9.85
Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus - MTG ~ NM ~ Magic The Gathering
Buy: $9.85
Buy: $1.39
Mycosynth Fiend - New Phyrexia: #117, Magic: The Gathering NM R6
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $3.01
Slithery Stalker - Torment: #84, Magic: The Gathering - Foil NM R15
Buy: $3.01
Buy: $2.37
Doom Weaver (034) Crimson Vow Commander VOC MTG Magic
Buy: $2.37
Buy: $1.38
Mind Flayer Near Mint Dungeons & Dragons: Adventures in the Forgotten Realms
Buy: $1.38
Buy: $1.39
Loam Dryad - Shadows over Innistrad: #216, Magic: The Gathering NM R1
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $5.45
The Gitrog, Ravenous Ride - FOIL - Outlaws of Thunder Junction - NM MTG
Buy: $5.45
Buy: $13.75
Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus NM FOIL SHOWCASE Phyrexia: All Will Be One MTG
Buy: $13.75
Buy: $9.25
MTG Sauron, the Lidless Eye *FOIL* The Lord of the Rings 288 NM Mythic
Buy: $9.25
Buy: $1.39
Mesmeric Fiend - Masters 25: #97, Magic: The Gathering NM R8
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
Nighthowler - Theros: #98, Magic: The Gathering Nm R24
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $37.85
X1 MTG Mondrak, Glory Dominus Phyrexia: All Will Be One 299 Regular Mythic
Buy: $37.85
Buy: $5.00
The Gitrog, Ravenous Ride 0206 OTJ Mythic Outlaws Of Thunder Junction MTG
Buy: $5.00
Buy: $1.24
4x Playset MTG Magic the Gathering Complete Set of 4 x4 Cards Gatecrash You Pick
Buy: $1.24
Buy: $1.35
MTG Ulvenwald Captive Ulvenwald Abomination Eldritch Moon 175/205 Near Mint NM
Buy: $1.35
Buy: $1.39
Necrogen Scudder - Magic 2015 (M15): #106, Magic: The Gathering Nm R19
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
Vorstclaw - Core Set 2020: #201, Magic: The Gathering Nm R21
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $12.99
MTG Mind Flayer, the Shadow Secret Lair Drop Series Magic the Gathering
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $1.39
Horror of the Broken Lands - Masters 25: #93, Magic: The Gathering NM R14
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $9.00
Umbris, Fear Manifest - 038 - MTG Commander: Innistrad: Crimson Vow
Buy: $9.00
Buy: $1.65
MTG 4x Tangleclaw Werewolf x4 LP Eldritch Moon
Buy: $1.65
Buy: $7.47
Phyrexian Vindicator - foil - Phyrexia: All Will Be One - MythicRare - 425
Buy: $7.47
Buy: $1.39
Intellect Devourer - Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate: #132 Nm R24
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $2.29
Mind Flayer NM FOIL SHOWCASE Adventures in the Forgotten Realms MTG FREE SHIP
Buy: $2.29
Buy: $1.39
Lashweed Lurker - The List Reprints: #EMN-9, Magic: The Gathering Nm R17
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
MTG Dunland Crebain Borderless The Lord of the Rings 0411 Regular...
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.47
Horror - Angel of Sanctions Double Sided Token [Commander 2019] MTG
Buy: $1.47
Buy: $1.48
Witch Engine The List XQX MTG Magic
Buy: $1.48
Buy: $1.49
Faceless Butcher - Premium Deck Series: Graveborn: #3 - Foil NM R15
Buy: $1.49
Buy: $11.62
Solphim, Mayhem Dominus (150) Phyrexia: All Will Be One ONE MTG Magic
Buy: $11.62
Buy: $1.39
Crawling Chorus - Phyrexia: All Will Be One: #8, Magic: The Gathering Nm R21
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $14.99
MTG Kederekt Parasite Conflux Magic the Gathering
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $3.99
MTG Commander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt MIC Hordewing Skaab MINT (SELECT)
Buy: $3.99
Buy: $1.39
Foul Emissary - Eldritch Moon: #158, Magic: The Gathering NM R11
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.49
Hidden Horror - Premium Deck Series: Graveborn 2 Magic The Gathering Foil NM R15
Buy: $1.49
Buy: $1.39
Fume Spitter - Ultimate Masters: #95, Magic: The Gathering Nm R21
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.50
Devouring Sugarmaw // Have for Dinner Foil (224) Wilds of Eldraine WOE MTG Magic
Buy: $1.50
Buy: $1.49
MTG Phyrexian Revoker The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts 40 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.49
Buy: $1.39
Crypt Lurker - Core Set 2021: #93, Magic: The Gathering NM R14
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.49
Phyrexian Gargantua - Eternal Masters: #101, Magic: The Gathering - Foil NM R15
Buy: $1.49
Buy: $16.99
MTG Phyrexian Obliterator *SHOWCASE FOIL* Phyrexia: All Will Be One 308 NM
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $4.08
Greater Harvester - Darksteel: #44, Magic: The Gathering Nm R16
Buy: $4.08
Buy: $1.99
MTG Runo Stromkirk/Krothuss, Lord of the Deep Crimson Vow 246/377 Regular Rare
Buy: $1.99
Buy: $2.35
MTG 4x Gnarlwood Dryad x4 LP Eldritch Moon
Buy: $2.35
Buy: $1.39
Canker Abomination - Ultimate Masters: #212, Magic: The Gathering NM R13
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
Nether Horror - Magic 2011 (M11): #108, Magic: The Gathering Nm R19
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.50
4x Melony 146/198 x4 - Chilling Reign - Pokemon TCG - Playset - NM
Buy: $1.50
Buy: $1.47
Mindleech Mass - foil - Ravnica Remastered - Rare - 201
Buy: $1.47
Buy: $1.52
Sauron, Lord of the Rings - The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Comm...
Buy: $1.52
Buy: $1.45
Skittering Horror - Urza's Destiny - Creature - Phyrexian Horror - Common - 70
Buy: $1.45
Buy: $1.39
Necrogen Scudder - Scars of Mirrodin: #71, Magic: The Gathering Nm R19
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $9.28
Deathbringer Liege (Foil Etched) [Double Masters 2022] MTG Near Mint Foil
Buy: $9.28
Buy: $1.39
Vorstclaw - Avacyn Restored: #201, Magic: The Gathering NM R4
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.52
Starving Revenant - The Lost Caverns of Ixalan - Rare - 338
Buy: $1.52
Buy: $1.39
Dread Slag - Dissension: #109, Magic: The Gathering Nm R16
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $1.39
Geralf's Mindcrusher - Dark Ascension: #37, Magic: The Gathering NM R13
Buy: $1.39
Buy: $5.01
4x Horror Energy 172/192 x4 - Rebel Clash - Pokemon TCG - Playset - NM
Buy: $5.01
Buy: $1.67
Netherborn Phalanx - Ravnica: City of Guilds - Uncommon - 99
Buy: $1.67
Buy: $8.58
Magic the Gathering (mtg): BABP: Elder Brain (Buy-A-Box) - Rare - Foil - Promo
Buy: $8.58
Buy: $2500.00
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice - PSA 10 - GEM MINT - Serialized Foil - #165/500
Buy: $2500.00
Card Name
0-0-0 (2) Aberrant Researcher // Perfected Form (1) Abolish (1) Abomination (1) Abomination of Gudul (7) Abyssal Gatekeeper (3) Abyssal Horror (10) Abyssal Nocturnus (1) Advanced Stitchwing (9) Amazing Time Ticket (1) Ambush (6) Angel of Sanctions (2) Annihilate (4) Anoint (5) Arcbound Fiend (1) Archfiend Emperor, the First Lord of Horror (12) Arena (1) Ashnod (1) Atraxa, Praetors' Voice (15) BT-1 (2) Baldur's Gate (21) Balefire Liege (6) Banette (2) Beast // Beast (1) Bedlam Reveler (9) Betrayal (1) Blistergrub (7) Bloodcurdler (2) Boneshard Slasher (3) Brainstealer Dragon (2) Broly, The Rampaging Horror (4) Brother (17) Bruna, the Fading Light // Brisela, Voice of Nightmares (1) Bucket (1) Cabal Therapist (7) Canker Abomination (7) Carnival Hellsteed (1) Carnivore (3) Carrion (6) Cateran Brute (2) Cateran Enforcer (1) Cateran Overlord (1) Cavern Crawler (4) Chained Throatseeker (7) Chasm Skulker (5) Childhood Horror (3) Chupacabra (8) Clash (1) Cleric (1) Cloistered Youth // Unholy Fiend (1) Clue (2) Cofagrigus (2) Commandeer (Magic: The Gathering) (17) Conduit of Storms // Conduit of Emrakul (3) Conjurer (1) Consuming Aberration (10) Copy // Horror (1) Copy Token (2) Core Prowler (6) Corrosion (1) Corrupted Harvester (3) Cosmic Horror (10) Cosmic Horror Gangi'el (2) Cosmos (2) Counter Counter (1) Creakwood Liege (19) Creepy Doll (1) Cruel Witness (10) Crypt Lurker (11) Cryptborn Horror (15) Crystallization (1) Curse of Leeches // Leeching Lurker (4) Cursed Monstrosity (3) Dark Hatchling (6) Dark Lord (7) Darkrai (3) Dauthi Horror (4) Deathbringer Liege (6) Defile (19) Delraich (2) Despoiler of Souls (13) Dinrova Horror (26) Ditto (1) Docent of Perfection // Final Iteration (1) Doctor (4) Douser of Lights (8) Dragon (Magic: The Gathering) (1) Dragon // Horror (1) Dragon Ball (5) Dragons (3) Dread (1) Dread Reaper (3) Dread Slag (4) Dread Slaver (3) Dreadlight Monstrosity (8) Dreadwurm (12) Drinker of Sorrow (3) Drivnod, Carnage Dominus (18) Dross Harvester (13) Dross Hopper (3) Duel (1) Duplicity (5) Dusclops (2) Dusknoir (6) Eater of the Dead (2) Edge (1) Emrakul's Evangel (2) Enslaved Horror (2) Entangle (4) Etherium Abomination (4) Evil Eye of Orms-by-Gore (1) Eviscerator (3) Face of Fear (4) Faceless Butcher (14) Faceless Devourer (3) Fascist Art Director (3) Fasting (1) Fetid Horror (7) First-Sphere Gargantua (8) Flesh Reaver (6) Flood (1) Foil (2) Forgotten Creation (7) Foul Emissary (4) Frightcrawler (3) Froghemoth (20) Froslass (2) Fume Spitter (10) Gastly (3) Gather the Pack (10) Gavony Unhallowed (2) Gengar (4) Geralf's Masterpiece (2) Geralf's Mindcrusher (7) Gisela, the Broken Blade // Brisela, Voice of Nightmares (5) Gleancrawler (4) Gliscor (1) Glissa's Courier (9) Gloom Sower (11) Glory (20) Gluttonous Slug (8) Gnarlwood Dryad (3) Gollum, Patient Plotter (38) Graf Rats // Chittering Host (1) Grakmaw, Skyclave Ravager (11) Gravegouger (1) Graven Abomination (6) Grazilaxx, Illithid Scholar (20) Greater Harvester (5) Greel, Mind Raker (1) Grief Tyrant (2) Grim Strider (8) Guiltfeeder (6) Hatenna (1) Hattrem (1) Haunter (2) Havengul Skaab (7) Hell's Caretaker (4) Hidden Horror (8) Hooded Horror (2) Hordewing Skaab (3) Horror (64) Horror of Horrors (1) Horror of the Broken Lands (15) Horror of the Dim (13) Hostile Hostel // Creeping Inn (3) Hostility (3) Hour of Devastation (3) Hullbreaker Horror (13) Hunted Horror (5) Hypnox (1) Ichorid (6) Infectious Horror (12) Ingenious Skaab (10) Intellect Devourer (15) Into the Story (1) It That Gets Left Hanging (3) K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth (4) Kederekt Creeper (6) Kederekt Parasite (9) Kessig Dire Swine (7) Kessig Prowler // Sinuous Predator (1) Klara (1) Krovikan Horror (8) Laboratory Brute (7) Laboratory Drudge (12) Lamplighter of Selhoff (7) Laquatus's Champion (1) Lashweed Lurker (5) Launch (1) Leeches (9) Liliana (2) Loam Dryad (10) Lone Rider // It That Rides as One (1) Lord of the Red (2) Lucario (1) Ludevic's Test Subject // Ludevic's Abomination (2) Ludicolo (1) Lurking Chupacabra (6) Mage Hunter (10) Magic Storm (1) Makeshift Mauler (10) Manectric (1) Marshadow (1) Melony (3) Mercurial Spelldancer (1) Mesmeric Fiend (9) Mesprit (1) Midnight Scavengers // Chittering Host (2) Mind Flayer (26) Mind Flayer, the Shadow (3) Mindleech Mass (21) Mindslicer (21) Mindwrack Liege (5) Minion of the Mighty (1) Mirror Mirror (3) Mismagius (1) Misshapen Fiend (2) Mistake (14) Moor Fiend (2) Morinfen (1) Morkrut Necropod (8) Muk (3) Murkfiend Liege (3) Mycosynth Fiend (5) NEXT (1) Necrogen Scudder (14) Nemesis of Reason (9) Nether Horror (10) Netherborn Phalanx (2) Nickit (1) Nighthowler (26) Nightmare Horror (1) Nihilith (6) Number C104: Umbral Horror Masquerade (1) Obosh, the Preypiercer (17) Old Stickfingers (9) Orcustrated Return (1) Overcharged Amalgam (6) Patchwork Crawler (13) Path to the Peak (5) Phantasmagorian (5) Phyrexian (31) Phyrexian Gargantua (16) Phyrexian Mite (7) Phyrexian Mite Token (2) Phyrexian Negator (15) Phyrexian Obliterator (7) Phyrexian Rager (51) Phyrexian Revoker (20) Phyrexian Swarmlord (5) Phyrexian Vatmother (4) Phyrexian Vindicator (7) Pikachu (30) Pith Driller (4) Plague Spitter (3) Plague Stinger (4) Planar Chaos (6) Plant (9) Polteageist (1) Possessed Aven (2) Possessed Barbarian (1) Possessed Centaur (3) Possessed Nomad (2) Priest of Fell Rites (1) Primeval Shambler (1) Psychic Energy (24) Psychic Symbiont (9) Psychosis Crawler (25) Putrefax (11) Rathi Fiend (1) Rathi Intimidator (2) Ravenous Chupacabra (10) Reaper of Sheoldred (4) Rebel (1) Rebellion (1) Rebirth (1) Refreshing Rain (1) Return (1) Revenant (14) Reversal (2) Ridged Kusite (13) Roiling Horror (3) Rotom (1) Rugged Prairie (1) Rusted Slasher (4) SP Energy (1) Sarcomancy (2) Sauron, the Lidless Eye (3) Sauron, the Necromancer (24) Scavenge (2) Scholar (1) Scourge Wolf (4) Screaming Swarm (11) Scrounger of Souls (5) Sewer Nemesis (4) Shadowed (1) Shambling Remains (4) Shambling Swarm (4) Shedinja (1) Shield & Sword (3) Shrill Howler // Howling Chorus (3) Sinistea (1) Sinuous Vermin (1) Skaab Ruinator (2) Skin Invasion // Skin Shedder (2) Skittering Horror (6) Skittering Monstrosity (9) Skulking Fugitive (2) Skyclave Shadowcat (6) Slithery Stalker (2) Sludge Strider (1) Slum Reaper (15) Solphim, Mayhem Dominus (9) Soul Scourge (6) Spawn of Rix Maadi (12) Spellskite (3) Spined Fluke (2) Spooky (1) Squirming Mass (5) Starly (1) Stitched Mangler (8) Stitchwing Skaab (7) Storm (9) Stromkirk Condemned (5) Stromkirk Occultist (7) Suicune (1) Tangle Angler (7) Tangleclaw Werewolf // Fibrous Entangler (4) The Abyss (10) The Blackstaff of Waterdeep (1) The Brothers' War (15) The Gate (12) The Gitrog Monster (10) The Harvester (1) The Mask (1) The Selection (7) The Wretched (5) Theater of Horrors (5) Thing in The Ice (4) Thing in the Ice // Awoken Horror (3) Thought Gorger (3) Thrummingbird (26) Time Spiral (4) Timmerian Fiends (2) Tomb of Horrors Adventurer (4) Toxrill, the Corrosive (7) Ulvenwald Captive // Ulvenwald Abomination (5) Umbris, Fear Manifest (6) Undergrowth Scavenger (4) Urborg Mindsucker (6) Urborg Shambler (3) Urborg Stalker (1) Vermiculos (2) Vildin-Pack Outcast // Dronepack Kindred (6) Vile Manifestation (5) Void Beckoner (6) Void Maw (1) Voldaren Pariah // Abolisher of Bloodlines (1) Vorstclaw (15) Wandering Mind (8) Wasp of the Bitter End (1) Wayward Angel (4) Weirded Vampire (7) Wharf Infiltrator (2) Witch Engine (4) Woe Strider (11) Woodwraith Corrupter (3) Wretched Throng (11) X (18) Yarok's Fenlurker (5) Yarok, the Desecrated (3) Zellix, Sanity Flayer (2) Zombie // Zombie (1)
Got Free Shipping? (US)
» Toys & Hobbies
» Collectible Card Games
» Horror Creature/Monster Type Collectible Card Games
![Horror - Angel of Sanctions Double Sided Token [Commander 2019] MTG](https://i.ebayimg.com/thumbs/images/g/FVkAAOSwG15lBg2o/s-l225.jpg)
![Deathbringer Liege (Foil Etched) [Double Masters 2022] MTG Near Mint Foil](https://i.ebayimg.com/thumbs/images/g/OhIAAOSwuMhizd8u/s-l225.jpg)
