NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $15.50
Jigsaw Puzzle 1500 Pieces 24x33 On The Dock by Serendipity W/Poster Included New
Buy: $15.50
Buy: $20.00
Serendipity 1000 pc Puzzle, "Santa's Helpers" - New, Sealed
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $24.99
Serendipity Special Edition Jesus For Whom He Forgave Most 1000 Piece Puzzle
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $15.00
Enchanted Company Jigsaw Puzzle Serendipity Fantasy Dragon Kids Family 399 Piece
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $14.99
NEW Norman Rockwell 500 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle_JFK 'A Time For Greatness' Storage Tin
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $24.00
Serendipity My Redeemer Lives 750 Piece Puzzle Religious Christian Jesus Sealed
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $34.99
SERENDIPITY PUZZLES Alice in Wonderland "THE TEA PARTY" 399 Pieces NEW SEALED
Buy: $34.99
Buy: $18.49
NEW SEALED SERENDIPITY 399 Pc Family Puzzle "ICE BABIES" by KIRSTEN GUERIN
Buy: $18.49
Buy: $6.99
New in Box Serendipity Architect's Riddle 1000 Piece Puzzle 17.25" x 26.5"
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $20.99
2005 SERENDIPITY PUZZLE CO. 225 PIECE JIGSAW PUZZLE - CELEBRATION - MANGER - NEW
Buy: $20.99
Buy: $15.99
CHOOSE ME! 800 Piece Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle NEW/SEALED Shar Pei cute Dog puppy
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $7.49
Kerne Erickson Summerland Brand Strawberries by Serendipity New & Sealed USA
Buy: $7.49
Buy: $24.00
New Serendipity 1000 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle Joker's Wild Poker Cards Sealed 20" X 27"
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $25.00
Christmas Traditions Jigsaw 1000pc Puzzle by Serendipity 20 x 27 Holiday Theme
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $29.95
Penguins Panoramic BLACK TIE AFFAIR Puzzle NEW 500 Pieces 2007 SEALED 12" x 36"
Buy: $29.95
Buy: $17.50
Serendipity Puzzles 750 Pcs - "FULL OF HOT AIR" Balloons - Gale Pitt / Complete
Buy: $17.50
Buy: $24.64
Merry Christmas Grandma Factory Norman Rockwell 500 pc Jigsaw Puzzle Sealed Tin
Buy: $24.64
Buy: $24.99
CUTE AS A KITTEN PUZZLE BY SERENDIPITY 150 PIECES JUMBO GRIP 3X THE SIZE SEALED
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $34.99
Winter Snow Barn Red 1500 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle NEW Xmas 24 X 33 in Prty Mail Ship
Buy: $34.99
Buy: $15.88
NEW Serendipity Puzzle 1000 Pieces Made In USA Sealed Generals Of The Forest
Buy: $15.88
Buy: $23.74
Choose Me! Puppy Dogs 800 Piece Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle New, Sealed Shar Pei Beagle
Buy: $23.74
Buy: $14.00
Serendipity 1000 pc JIGSAW PUZZLE Reflections horses Chris Cummings SEALED 2003
Buy: $14.00
Buy: $15.99
Norman Rockwell Muscleman 500 Piece Puzzle - NEW Sealed Tin
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $29.95
Moon Song 800 Piece Puzzle Serendipity Puzzle Co Wolves Howling
Buy: $29.95
Buy: $6.99
Norman Rockwell 4x500 Pieces 1765 Jigsaw Puzzles with JFK, Soldiers, Child, Flag
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $11.39
''SNOW IN THE PARK'' TOM BROWNING 550 PIECE PUZZLE-NEW-SEALED Free US Shipping
Buy: $11.39
Buy: $10.00
NORMAN ROCKWELL COLLECTION 500 PIECE PUZZLE “ARE WE DOWNHEARTED"
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $24.95
Karen Latham Alpha Puzzle by Serendipity 550 Piece Wolf Howling Sealed
Buy: $24.95
Buy: $30.00
Serendipity 550 Piece Puzzle A MOMENT OF REFLECTION Laura Regan
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $27.99
Serendipity 550 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Of "Gassing Up" # 35008 18"x24"
Buy: $27.99
Buy: $19.79
Eagles Watch Him Panoramic Jigsaw Puzzle 500pc Serendipity BRAND NEW
Buy: $19.79
Buy: $28.00
Larry Grossman Canadian Pacific RR Train Puzzle by Serendipity 750Piece Complete
Buy: $28.00
Buy: $16.20
Serendipity 550 Piece Puzzle Called Halftime In The Heartland
Buy: $16.20
Buy: $11.99
Noahs Recroom 399 Piece Puzzle Complete - Serendipity Puzzle
Buy: $11.99
Buy: $45.00
Boeing Flight 747 COCKPIT Cleared For Takeoff VINTAGE PUZZLE COMPLETE
Buy: $45.00
Buy: $30.00
Serendipity 1000 Piece Puzzle FROG BUSINESS Lori Anzalone
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $16.99
Norman Rockwell 500 Pc Puzzle JFK 'A Time For Greatness' NIB~FREE SHIPPING!
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $28.00
New "Reflections" 1000 Pc Serendipity Puzzle, 17 x 26, Horses Water Cummings
Buy: $28.00
Buy: $24.99
Spots & Stripes Safari Animals Serendipity 300 Jumbo Grip Puzzle - New
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $5.99
Meeting in the Lilacs, by Kim Norlien-1000 Pc Puzzle (Serendipity Puzzle, 2003)
Buy: $5.99
Buy: $23.00
Santa's Masterpiece 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Serendipity SEALED Christmas Gifts
Buy: $23.00
Buy: $21.99
Kevin Daniel Art - 550 Piece Cat Puzzle - On the Lookout - Sealed 2004
Buy: $21.99
Buy: $15.50
New~Norman Rockwell 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle In Storage Tin “Are We Downhearted?
Buy: $15.50
Buy: $25.00
Penguins Panoramic BLACK TIE AFFAIR Puzzle 500 Pcs 2007 12" x 36" Used, COMPLETE
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $24.00
Christmas Traditions Jigsaw 1000pc Puzzle by Serendipity 20 x 27 Holiday Theme
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $10.46
NORMAN ROCKWELL COLLECTION PUZZLE "A TIME FOR GREATNESS" New Sealed
Buy: $10.46
Buy: $19.95
Serendipity Puzzle Co. Inc. 1000 Pieces Night Song Item # 65374 New Sealed
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $49.99
Boeing Flight 747 COCKPIT Cleared For Takeoff VINTAGE PUZZLE
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $29.00
Serendipity Barrack Obama Puzzle 2009- 550 Pieces- Brand New, Sealed
Buy: $29.00
Buy: $25.00
Serendipity Shaped 1000 Pieces Puzzle FAMILY TRIO
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $24.00
Jigsaw Puzzle Santa Paradise Christmas December 26 550 Pc Excellent Complete E1
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $15.00
SANTA CLAUS WORKSHOP Masterpieces jigsaw puzzle 2003 missing pieces Tom Newsom
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $19.80
Serendipity 500 Piece Puzzle Called Snow in the Park 12" x 18"
Buy: $19.80
Buy: $24.00
Norman Rockwell No Christmas Problem Now Good Boys Girls 500 Piece NEW in Tin
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $23.00
Norman Rockwell Merry Christmas Grandma We Came in New Plymouth 500 Piece NEW
Buy: $23.00
Buy: $40.50
Serendipity Generals Of The Forest 1000 Piece Puzzle
Buy: $40.50
Buy: $13.99
JIGSAW PUZZLE SERENDIPITY "ON THE DOCK" 1500 PIECES FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $13.99
Buy: $15.89
New~Norman Rockwell 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle In Storage Tin “Are We Downhearted?
Buy: $15.89
Buy: $39.99
2003 Serendipity Unicorn Kingdom 800 piece Shaped Puzzle Brand New Sealed S5
Buy: $39.99
Buy: $17.00
Native American Night Song 1000 Piece Puzzle
Buy: $17.00
Buy: $13.10
NEW - "Come Out And Play" Jigsaw Puzzle 150 Jumbo Piece Serendipity 15013
Buy: $13.10
Buy: $34.99
NEW Sealed President Barack Obama Yes We Can 550 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle # 90010
Buy: $34.99
Buy: $28.95
NEW 2003 - 1000 Pcs Jigsaw Puzzle FAMILY TRIO Shaped Puzzle - Labrador Retriever
Buy: $28.95
Buy: $29.99
Serendipity 399 piece puzzle Christmas Eve, new unopened 17 1/4x 26 1/2
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $24.99
Frog "Tree Hugger" Lori Anzalone 550 Piece Puzzle Serendipity COMPLETE
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $19.99
BRAND NEW Eagles Watch Him Panoramic Jigsaw Puzzle 500pc Serendipity
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $24.99
WINTER BREAKFAST Family Jigsaw Puzzle : Artist KEVIN WALSH : Farm Life : 399 pcs
Buy: $24.99