NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Honus Wagner Vintage Baseball Card PSA 5 Fleer Famous Feats 1972 Gift CRACK CASE
Buy: $369.00
1955 Redman Tobacco, AL-22 Hank Bauer,  MLB HoF- New York Yankees - SGC 5
Buy: $119.00
MICKEY MANTLE PSA 5 New York Yankees 1989 Bowman Insert Man Cave Collector Card
Buy: $159.00
1955 Topps Don Hoak #40 PSA 5.0 26305900
Buy: $49.99
1929 R316 Kashin Pub. Baseball FRED "FREDDIE" LINDSTROM Giants  (HOF) --- PSA 5
Buy: $149.95
1947-66 Exhibits Duke Snider  B on cap - PSA EX 5 Brooklyn Dodgers VSCARDS
Buy: $99.00
PSA 5 EX 1940-70 BOXING NEWS POSTCARD #8 JESS WILLARD 1915-19 GRADED RARE *TPHLC
Buy: $53.97
SGC 5 SANDY KOUFAX 1960's McCARTHY POSTCARD GLOVE GROUND GRADED EX VINTAGE TPHLC
Buy: $160.50
PSA 5 GOLD HAND CUT PANEL NOLAN RYAN CAL RIPKEN 1992 TOPPS GRADED EX TOUGH TPHLC
Buy: $83.97
1947-66 Exhibits Willie Mays Portrait - PSA EX 5 - GIANTS - Looks Nicer VSCARDS
Buy: $299.00
1981 Oilers Red Rooster #11 Mark Messier HOF Hockey Card PSA 5 EXCELLENT
Buy: $39.99
Ellis Burks 1989 Topps Heads Up Test Issue #12 PSA 5 - POP ONLY 4, ONLY 3 HIGHER
Buy: $799.99
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #27 MARCEL PRONOVOST HOF SGC 60/5 EX RED WINGS
Buy: $49.99
1950 Ed-U-Cards W536-2 LONE RANGER "Thieve's Money" Panel SP! 106/107/108 PSA 5
Buy: $144.00
Nolan Ryan 1984 Topps Super # 28 PSA 5 EX
Buy: $59.95
Mickey Mantle Antique PSA 5 Topps Giant Vintage Collector Card Baseball 1964 MLB
Buy: $569.00
1954 Bowman Baseball #19 Bobby Shantz, Philadelphia Athletics — PSA EX 5
Buy: $35.00
1952 Topps Baseball #206 — Joe Ostrowski, New York Yankees — PSA EX 5
Buy: $55.00
1954 Topps MONTE IRVIN #3 New York Giants HOF EX PSA 5 SP Bright Color
Buy: $159.95
1953 Topps Jackie Robinson #1 PSA 5 EX Card Graded Excellent Condition
Buy: $2900.00
Mickey Mantle 1953 Bowman Baseball Color #59 PSA 5 EX New York Yankees HOF
Buy: $6999.90
1965 Topps Football Lance Alworth Card #155 PSA 5 EX NFL HOF
Buy: $120.00
1947-66 Exhibits Elston Howard - PSA EX 5 - New York Yankees - VSCARDS
Buy: $59.00
1947-66 Exhibits Tony Kubek Dark Back - PSA EX 5 - New York Yankees - VSCARDS
Buy: $99.00
SGC 5 JOHNNY BENCH HOF SMILING 1970's McCARTHY POSTCARD GRADED EX VINTAGE *TPHLC
Buy: $173.97
1956 Topps CARLOS PAULA #4 White Back Nationals PSA 5 EX SP Nice Color
Buy: $39.95
WILLIE MAYS 1954 RED MAN TOBACCO HAND CUT - WITHOUT TAB PSA 5 (EX) CARD GIANTS
Buy: $795.00
1981 Wrestling Super Stars Andre The Giant WWF/NWA/AWA PSA Graded 5 EX Hand Cut
Buy: $679.99
1955 Topps Double Header #103-104 PSA 5 EX Hank Sauer/ Pascual
Buy: $119.95
1966 Topps Comic Book Foldees #12 Babe Ruth/ Wonder Woman SGC 5 Yankees
Buy: $499.99
1955 Bowman #202 Mickey Mantle - PSA EX 5 - New York Yankees - SHARP - Free Ship
Buy: $2650.00
1971 Topps Greatest Moments SAM MCDOWELL Signed Baseball Card PSA 5 PSA/DNA 10
Buy: $428.00
PSA 5 EX CEPEDA MAZ MAZEROSKI 1968 TOPPS ACTION A/S STICKER ORLANDO GRADED TPHLC
Buy: $195.00
1947-66 Exhibits Don Newcombe - Dodgers on Jacket PSA EX 5 - Brooklyn - VSCARDS
Buy: $49.00
1954 Topps Ed Bailey #184 - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $39.99
1956 Topps #235 Don Newcombe PSA 5
Buy: $120.00
1965 Topps #122 Joe Namath Rookie Card New York Jets SGC 5 EX! BEAUTIFUL CARD!!!
Buy: $6845.00
1969 MLB PHOTOSTAMPS PANEL W/ WILLIE MAYS ROBERTO CLEMENTE SUTTON PSA 5 EX POP 1
Buy: $249.00
1929 Kashin Publications BABE RUTH R316 PSA EX 5 VERY RARE CARD
Buy: $8200.00
Rickey Henderson 1983 Granny Goose Potato Chips Card #35 With Coupon PSA 5 EX
Buy: $129.99
PSA 5 EX JORDAN UD AUTHENTICATED UPPER DECK MICHAEL HOF NBA GRADED VINTAGE TPHLC
Buy: $46.50
Rick Barry 1976-1977 Topps 3 Inscriptions Signed Autograph AUTO PSA/DNA 4 Pop 1
Buy: $149.95
LeBron James 2003 Upper Deck Holiday Season #NPL03 PSA 5 - JUMBO - Winter League
Buy: $199.60
Jerry Rice 2003 Fleer Platinum Big Signs #7BS - PSA 5 - POP 1 - NONE higher!!
Buy: $27.60
1947-66 Exhibits Bob Lemon - PSA  EX 5 - Glove Not Visible - INDIANS - VSCARDS
Buy: $50.00
1959 BAZOOKA DEL Crandall MILWAUKEE BRAVES SGC 5 Beauty!!!
Buy: $440.00
⚾1971 Milk Duds #5 BILLY GRABARKEWITZ Full/Complete Box⚾ PSA 5 EX ~ SHARP!
Buy: $127.46
PSA 5 EX ROGER STAUBACH HOF ROOKIE 1972 NFLPSA VINYL STICKER GRADED NFL RC TPHLC
Buy: $83.97
1952 Topps Dick Sisler #113 PSA 5 P1280
Buy: $59.99
1952 Topps Clyde King #205 CSG 5 EXCELLENT FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $35.00
1956 TOPPS # 113 Phil Rizzuto PSA 5 EX # 67611059  NEW YORK YANKEES !!!!
Buy: $313.49
Paul Molitor 1997 Bowman's Best #33 JUMBO REFRACTOR - PSA EX 5 - NICE!
Buy: $59.99
1955 Topps Chuck Stobbs #41 CSG 5 Excellent ** Free Shipping**
Buy: $24.95
1947-66 Exhibits Gil Hodges - B on cap - PSA EX 5 - Brooklyn Dodgers VSCARDS
Buy: $129.00
1956 Topps ED FITZGERALD #198 Washington Nationals PSA 5 EX SP Nice Color
Buy: $39.95
Garrincha 1962 Villarreal PSA  EX 5 Prohibitively RARE! Pop 1, FINEST KNOWN ⚽️
Buy: $900.00
1956 TOPPS # 89 Norm Zauchin WHITE BACK PSA 5 EX # 45818379  BOSTON RED SOX !!!
Buy: $33.24
Dick Ellsworth 1968 Dexter Press Postcard PSA 5 Ex Vintage Red Sox POP 1 ☘️
Buy: $17.99
1962-65 Jay Publishing Photos Mickey Mantle Type 2 Batting Two Ears PSA 5 EX
Buy: $750.00
1987 Circle K Coca-Cola Hulk Hogan Supermatch Card w/Tab #1 PSA 5 RARE! LOW POP
Buy: $399.99
1955 TOPPS # 146 Dick Donovan RC PSA 5 EX # 54599742  CHICAGO WHITE SOX !!!!
Buy: $45.12
1947-66 Exhibits #175 Johnny Pesky  Boston RED SOX  SGC 5 EX
Buy: $200.00
1987 Circle K Coca-Cola Supermatch Card w/Tab PSA Graded RARE! LOW POP  10
Buy: $599.99
1947-66 Exhibits #235 Bucky Walters  Cincinnati REDS  SGC 5 EX
Buy: $150.00
1954 Topps Andy Carey #105 - PSA 5 EX - Just Graded!
Buy: $69.99
1956 Topps Football #43 Gary Knafelc Rookie Packers PSA 5
Buy: $24.95
1947-66 Exhibits #229A Mickey Vernon Washington SENATORS  SGC 5 EX  Throwing
Buy: $150.00
1956 Topps New York Giants Team #226 PSA 5 EX (Willie Mays)
Buy: $129.95
2007 Topps Turkey Red RYAN HOWARD DP RH Box Topper Oversize NM 5 3/4" X 8" NM
Buy: $19.99
1987 Circle K Coca-Cola Hulk Hogan Supermatch Card w/Tab #1 PSA 5 RARE! LOW POP
Buy: $399.99
1955 bowman chet ostrowski #64 psa 5 redskins!
Buy: $21.00
1980 DIEGO MARADONA *PSA 5* (RARE) *Only 2 *HIGHEST GRADED* ((SVIJET SPORTA))
Buy: $2500.00
1976-77 Topps #16 Jamaal Keith Wilkes Signed Warriors Card PSA/DNA 78222295
Buy: $249.95
1969 TOPPS BASKETBALL #75 ELVIN HAYES PSA 5 EX  "ROOKIE" 🏀🏀
Buy: $159.00
1969 TOPPS BASKETBALL #75 ELVIN HAYES PSA 5 EX  "ROOKIE" 🏀🏀
Buy: $159.00
1956 Topps Football #51 Ted Marchibroda Pittsburgh Steelers PSA 5
Buy: $59.95
1993 Triple Play Action Baseball Game Card #30 Joe Carter Card PSA 5 Pop 1
Buy: $24.99
1972 Icee Bear Wilt Chamberlain PSA 5 *Oversized
Buy: $350.00
Rollie Fingers 1984 Rare 5x7 Pic Photo Milwaukee Brewers HOF
Buy: $1.49