NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
YOGI BERRA 1954 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #50 PSA 5 EXCELLENT HOF GRADED NY YANKEES
Buy: $210.00
1954 TOPPS SCOOP #65 ROCKY MARCIANO WALCOTT SGC 5 0149760
Buy: $99.99
1954 Red Heart Dog Food #NNO Richie Ashburn PSA 5 Phillies  (7404)
Buy: $260.00
1954 BOWMAN EDDIE MATHEWS #64 SGC 5 EX Sharp Well Centered & Bright
Buy: $124.95
1954 Topps WHITEY FORD #37 SGC 5 EX HOF
Buy: $139.00
1954 Topps Monte Irvin #3 SGC 5
Buy: $130.00
1954 Bowman #65 Mickey Mantle PSA 5 New York Yankees HOF
Buy: $2800.00
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #11 ANDY BATHGATE HOF 5 EX RANGERS
Buy: $69.99
1954 Wilson Franks Ted Williams PSA 5 Boston Red Sox HOF
Buy: $21000.00
1954 TOPPS SCOOP #40 JOE LOUIS SGC 5 5736684
Buy: $119.99
Ernie Banks 1954 Topps #94 Chicago HOF Rookie Card RC PSA 5 EX
Buy: $2350.00
1953 Bowman Color 65 R Roberts PSA 5 669693
Buy: $105.00
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #3 HARRY HOWELL HOF 5 EX RANGERS
Buy: $69.99
1950s Daily Herald Billy Liddell Bold Text Liverpool Rare SGC 5 2579
Buy: $150.00
1953 Bowman Color Richie Rich Ashburn Phillies #10 PSA 5 EX - NICE CARD!
Buy: $159.00
1954 John Scarbath Bowman NFL Football Card #3 Washington Redskins PSA 5 EX
Buy: $29.99
1954 Bowman - #132 Bob Feller - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $175.00
1954 Topps #107 Duane Pillette PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Baltimore Orioles
Buy: $39.96
1954 TOPPS BASEBALL #10 JACKIE ROBINSON PSA 5 EX HOF BROOKLYN DODGERS
Buy: $1342.42
1954 TOPPS - #201 - AL KALINE - ROOKIE CARD - PSA 5 - NICELY CENTERED - NEW SLAB
Buy: $1399.99
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #56 EDGAR LAPRADE HOF 5 EX RANGERS
Buy: $29.99
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #19 JACK "TEX" EVANS 5 EX RANGERS
Buy: $22.50
1954 Topps Monte Irvin #3 PSA 5 EX 
Buy: $139.99
1954 Bowman #89 Willie Mays PSA 5 EX Giants HOF Baseball Card
Buy: $798.00
1954 Topps #17 Phil Rizzuto New York Yankees SGC 5 EX HOF
Buy: $74.98
1954 Topps #5 Ed Lopat - PSA EX 5 - New York Yankees - VSCARDS
Buy: $35.00
1954 Topps #220 Ruben Gomez RC - PSA EX 5 - New York Giants - CENTERED - VSCARDS
Buy: $69.00
1954 NY Journal American Roy Campanella PSA 5 Brooklyn Dodgers HOF
Buy: $525.00
1954-55 TOPPS HOCKEY #27 MARCEL PRONOVOST HOF SGC 60/5 EX RED WINGS
Buy: $49.99
NYY PSA 5 EX YANKEE STADIUM 1954 QUAKER #27 GRADED BABE RUTH MICKEY MANTLE TPHLC
Buy: $83.97
1954 Topps #201 Al Kaline HOF RC PSA 5 EX C86159
Buy: $1200.00
1954 Topps #32 Duke Snider HOF  PSA 5 EX C86156
Buy: $150.00
1954 Bowman Baseball #19 Bobby Shantz, Philadelphia Athletics — PSA EX 5
Buy: $35.00
1954 Bowman Hank Bauer #129 PSA 5
Buy: $69.99
1954 Topps #5 Ed Lopat - PSA EX 5 - New York Yankees - VSCARDS
Buy: $42.00
1954 Bowman #6 Joe Perry HOF  PSA 5 EX C85027
Buy: $45.00
1954 Topps MONTE IRVIN #3 New York Giants HOF EX PSA 5 SP Bright Color
Buy: $159.95
1954 TOPPS #45 RICHIE ASHBURN BVG 5 (3621)
Buy: $99.99
1954 Topps Dave Hoskins #81 - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $48.99
1954 Topps #23 Luke Easter PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cleveland Indians
Buy: $69.96
1954 Topps Del Crandall #12 PSA 5 EX - Just Graded!
Buy: $49.99
1954 Bowman #15, Richie Ashburn, Philadelphia Phillies PSA 5 EX.
Buy: $65.00
1954 Topps #94 Ernie Banks PSA 5
Buy: $2500.00
WILLIE MAYS 1954 RED MAN TOBACCO HAND CUT - WITHOUT TAB PSA 5 (EX) CARD GIANTS
Buy: $795.00
1954 Topps Ed Bailey #184 - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $39.99
1954 NY JOURNAL AMERICAN PEE WEE REESE SGC 5 3138960
Buy: $259.99
1954 Topps #52 Vic Power PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Philadelphia Athletics
Buy: $139.96
1954 Topps #36 Hoyt Wilhelm PSA 5 (MC) Graded Baseball Card MLB New York Giants
Buy: $61.96
1954 Topps #30 Ed Mathews Eddie Mathews PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Braves
Buy: $299.96
1954 Topps Richie Ashburn #45 - PSA 5 EX - Nice Card!
Buy: $99.99
WILLIE MAYS PSA 5 EX 1954 TOPPS #90 NEW YORK/ SAN FRANCISCO GIANTS HOFER
Buy: $1099.00
1954-55 PARKHURST HOCKEY #78 AL DEWSBURY PSA 5 EX BLACK HAWKS
Buy: $25.00
1954 RED MAN TOBACCO #16 EDWIN "DUKE" SNIDER w/ TAB, DODGERS, HOF - PSA 5 (0904)
Buy: $199.96
HANDSOME SGC 5 EX CARL FURILLO 1954 BOWMAN #122 GRADED VINTAGE UNCREASED *TPHLC
Buy: $46.50
1954 TOPPS #13 BILLY MARTIN NEW YORK YANKEES MINT GRADING SERVICE 5 EX
Buy: $75.00
1954 Topps Whitey Ford #37 - PSA 5 EX - Nice Card!
Buy: $199.99
1954 Topps #126 Ben Wade PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Brooklyn Dodgers
Buy: $62.96
1954 RED MAN TOBACCO #24 JIM DELSING w/ TAB, DETROIT TIGERS - PSA 5 (0896)
Buy: $63.96
1954 Topps Baseball #49 — RAY MURRAY, Philadelphia Athletics — PSA EX 5
Buy: $31.00
1954 Topps Carl Scheib #118 PSA 5 EX - Freshly Graded at PSA!
Buy: $49.99
1954 Topps Joe Black #98 - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $79.99
1954 Topps #70 Larry Doby, Cleveland Indians PSA 5 EX
Buy: $350.00
1954 Topps Ernie Banks (HOF) #94  Rookie Card. PSA 5 !
Buy: $2599.00
1954 Bowman #173 Dee Fondy PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card Chicago Cubs MLB
Buy: $26.96
1954 Red Man #AL13 Mickey Vernon PSA 5 Senators  (9410)
Buy: $80.00
1954 Topps #50 Yogi Berra PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB New York Yankees
Buy: $397.96
1954 Topps Bobby Adams #123 - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $47.99
1954 Topps #17 Phil Rizzuto PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB New York Yankees
Buy: $249.96
1954 Bowman #47 Gerald Weatherly Bears - EX
Buy: $9.99
TOUGH PSA 5 EX PAUL RICHARDS 1954 WILSON FRANKS GRADED HIGH-END VINTAGE *TPHLC
Buy: $495.00
1954 Bowman #170 Duke Snider HOF  PSA 5 EX C86869
Buy: $175.00
1954 Topps #7 Ted Kluszewski PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cincinnati Redlegs
Buy: $89.96
1954 Bowman #1 Phil Rizzuto New York Yankees SGC 4 VG-EX Sharp HOF
Buy: $69.99
1954 Del Crandall Bowman MLB Baseball Card #32 Milwaukee Braves SGC 60 5 EX
Buy: $29.99
1954 TOPPS BASEBALL #132 TOMMY LaSORDA RC PSA 5 EX HOF ROOKIE
Buy: $444.44
1963 Fleer Checklist SP PSA 5 663401
Buy: $309.00
1954 Topps #3 Monte Irvin PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB New York Giants
Buy: $229.96
PHIL CAVARRETTA Signed 1954 Topps Card #55 AUTO Chicago Cubs SGC 60 EX 5
Buy: $60.00
1954 Bowman #52 Lou Groza HOF BVG 5 EX C78584
Buy: $37.00
1954 Topps #70 Larry Doby PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Cleveland Indians
Buy: $323.96
1954 Topps Andy Carey #105 - PSA 5 EX - Just Graded!
Buy: $69.99
1909 T206 68 Camnitz (arms folded) PSA 5 662861
Buy: $509.00
1954 BOWMAN BASEBALL #13 PAUL MINNER, CHICAGO CUBS - PSA 5 EX (82699)
Buy: $23.96
1954 TOPPS #95 - HAL RICE- OUTFIELDER PITTSBURGH PIRATES - ST. LOUIS, MO- SGC EX
Buy: $35.00
1954 Topps #250 Ted Williams HOF  SGC 60 EX 5
Buy: $1250.00
1954 Topps #166 Johnny Podres PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB Brooklyn Dodgers
Buy: $76.96
1954 Bowman #76 Leo Nomellini PSA 5 Graded Football Card San Francisco 49ers
Buy: $49.96
1954 Topps #139 Eddie O'Brien/Johnny O'Brien PSA 5 Pirates  (3983)
Buy: $260.00