NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Bolo Tie Jelly Belly Blue by ART with small flowers goldtone
Buy: $45.90
VTG Trafari Gold Tone Swan Brooch With White Jelly Belly Cabochon Faux Pearl
Buy: $99.99
Vintage Love Birds Brooch Pin Figural Bird Jelly Belly Rhinestones Moon glow
Buy: $29.99
Vintage Jelly Belly Pair Gold Pink Glass Angel Fish Scatter Pins Brooches
Buy: $34.95
1940s Mr. Bird CORO Blue Enamel Jelly Belly Rhinestone Brooch Verrecchio
Buy: $45.00
Large Gold Tone Enamel Snail with Blue Jelly Belly Stones Pin Brooch
Buy: $28.00
Vintage Clear Jelly Belly Owl Brooch Pin~Vintage Jelly Belly Pin~Vintage Costume
Buy: $30.00
BIG Vintage Sterling Silver Lucite Jelly Belly Fly Brooch 14.5g with Loose Stone
Buy: $95.00
Vintage Turtle transparent Blue Jelly Belly Pin Art Deco Jewelry brooch
Buy: $28.99
Vintage CORO Jelly Belly Lucite Rhinestone Elephant With Rider Pin Unsigned
Buy: $100.00
Jelly Belly Bug Gold & Crystal Brooch Made In Western Germany In The Early 1930s
Buy: $39.96
New In Box Jelly Belly Two Tone Owl Ring Sz 7
Buy: $12.00
Turtle Jelly Belly Rhinestone Stick Pin Brooch Vintage Jewelry Hat Pin Lapel #99
Buy: $19.95
Vintage Turtle Jelly Belly Earrings Aquamarine Color Silver Plate Vs ? Sterling
Buy: $30.00
Vintage Trembler Brooch Pin Insect Bug Jelly Belly Pinkish  Rhinestone
Buy: $15.00
VTG  TRIFARI JELLY BELLY FROG slide Pendant GREEN Back Jewelry
Buy: $29.00
Beautiful Vintage Pink Jelly Belly Rhinestone Bug Insect Beetle Brooch Pin
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Signed Ambassador Gold toned Buddha Pin/Brooch Green Jelly Belly Accent
Buy: $12.99
Vintage Scitarelli Pin Lot Jelly Belly Birds Rare!
Buy: $34.99
Lucite Jelly Belly Flower Pot Pin
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Brooch Silver Tone Jelly Belly Parrott with Black Stone 2 Inches Length
Buy: $18.00
Gorgeous Jelly Belly Monet Faux Turquoise Rhinestone Turtle Tortoise Brooch Pin
Buy: $50.00
Vintage Gold Tone Wasp Bee Bumble Bee Jelly Belly Rhinestone Pin 2"
Buy: $19.99
Cats Eye Jelly Belly Parrot Bird Brooch Pin Silver Tone Enamel Rhinestone
Buy: $19.00
VTG Scottish Clansman Pin Moonglow Jelly Belly Face, Gold Tone with Plaid Kilt
Buy: $20.00
SET OF *3* VINTAGE JELLY BELLY ANIMAL BROOCHES PINS Cat, Fox, Bird Monet + More
Buy: $45.00
Vintage Amber Jelly Belly Gold Tone Owl Pin Brooch 1.25" Free Shipping
Buy: $9.00
Vtg Jelly Belly Parrot Bird Trio Brooch Pin Gold Tone Green Red Blue Rhinestone
Buy: $22.49
Vintage Rare JELLY BELLY Enamel Rhinestone Lucite SNAIL Brooch with red eyes
Buy: $99.00
VTG French Jelly Belly Cat Pin, Gold Tone w/Black Cabochon, Faux Ruby Eyes. Rare
Buy: $100.00
Mix Culture Jelly Belly Multi Strand Wire Necklace Genuine Pearl Beaded Colorful
Buy: $12.00
Vintage Bordello Jelly Belly Pink And Purple Rhinestones Brooch/Pendant
Buy: $65.00
Pink Lucite Jelly Belly Fly Insect Brooch Pin Unsigned Maeve Carr?
Buy: $15.00
Red Jelly Belly Candy Beans in Chef Hats Vintage Dangle Earrings
Buy: $12.50
Jelly Belly Gold Tone Charm Bracelet
Buy: $14.99
Vintage Cat Pin Jelly Belly Purple Stone Silver Tone Cat Brooch Large Cat
Buy: $24.99
Vtg Owl Jelly Belly Faux Pearl Brooch Pin Yellow Gold Tone
Buy: $10.40
Vintage Mexico Silver Turquoise Amber Jelly Belly Fortune Teller Pin 2-1/8” 34g
Buy: $119.99
JELLY BELLY OWL BROOCH PIN GOLD TONE CORAL PEACH STONE 2.25"
Buy: $18.00
Vintage Crown Trafari Owl Pin Jelly Belly Chocolate Brown Gold Brooch RARE
Buy: $125.00
VINTAGE MINIATURE ENAMELED RHINESTONE JELLY BELLY FIGURAL PIN BROOCH LOT
Buy: $39.99
Jelly Belly Faux Pearl Teddy Bear Brooch Pin
Buy: $12.00
Vintage Norma Sterling Jelly Belly Duck Pin/Brooch CZ eye Marked
Buy: $200.00
Vintage Cobalt Blue Jelly Belly Duck Swan Brooch Pin
Buy: $12.00
Vintage PINK jelly belly Style duck bird TOP HAT pin brooch ( 1 stone missing)
Buy: $35.00
Vintage Jelly Belly Faux Pearl Cat Brooch Rhinestones for Tail Figurine
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Kimberlee Teddy Bear Lucite Jelly Belly Brooch Pin
Buy: $15.00
Lucite Jelly Belly Turtle Pin
Buy: $19.99
Turtles Sweater Brooch Duet Set Pink Jelly Belly Silver Vintage Art Deco Jewelry
Buy: $44.00
Vintage Marcasite Pin Sterling Silver Art Deco Mother of Pearl Brooch Pin 1960's
Buy: $32.75
Vintage Beetle Red Jelly Belly Gold Plated Pin Brooch Rhinestones
Buy: $14.95
Vintage LUCITE JELLY BELLY OWL clear pendant silver tone rhinestones eyes 2.25”T
Buy: $28.00
Vintage Sphinx Red Lucite Fish Brooch
Buy: $69.00
Vintage Sterling Silver Amber Teddy Bear Pin Pendant Jelly Belly Brooch 6.5g
Buy: $42.00
Herman Goelitz Jelly Belly Jelly Bean USA Flag Brooch Patriotic Pin
Buy: $9.99
Vintage Unsigned Foil Glass Jelly Belly Owl Pin w/Green Rhinestone Eyes
Buy: $18.99
Vintage Jelly Belly Seahorse Gold Tone Ruby Rhinestone Eye Brooch Pin
Buy: $30.00
Original Vintage Jelly Belly Ladybug Pin/Brooch
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Blue & Yellow Lucite Jelly Belly Graduated Bead Choker Necklace
Buy: $19.99
Unique GP Jelly Belly Blue & Pink Love Birds Pendant Charm Bracelet - 7" Long,
Buy: $58.50
Jelly Belly Peach  Lucite Gold Toned Fish Brooch Red Eyes Vintage Estate Jewelry
Buy: $40.49
Rare Antique Pair Of Tiny " Jelly Belly" Turtle Brooches Unique BLUESTONE ~ Old
Buy: $35.99
1930s Celluloid Jelly Belly Fish Orange Figural Large Fin Fish Orange Necklace
Buy: $99.90
VTG Nice Green JELLY BELLY LUCKY SHAMROCK CLOVER Silver Rhinestones Brooch
Buy: $49.99
VINTAGE CLEAR LUCITE CARVED FISH JELLY BELLY PIN BROOCH RED EYE
Buy: $70.00
Crab Jelly Belly Brooch w Red Crystal Rhinestone Eyes Gold Tone Pin ~Never worn!
Buy: $27.00
Vintage Jade Jelly Belly Pin
Buy: $29.95
Vintage 60's Cute AB Rhinestone Lavender Jelly Belly Cabochon Deer Brooch 862o9
Buy: $14.99
Jelly Belly Vintage gold tone 3 parrots pin/brooch Great Condition
Buy: $20.00
Vintage Lovebird Brooch 1930’s USA Faux Pearl Eggs Pin Jelly Belly
Buy: $250.00
Vintage 60's Foil Art Glass Cab Jelly Belly Tortoise Turtle X Cute Brooch 880jl1
Buy: $16.49
Vintage Jelly Belly Dog Brooch Pin w/ Red Gemstone Eyes RARE
Buy: $49.99
Lot Of Vintage Rhinestone/Jelly Belly Brooches, Pins, Earrings, Etc.
Buy: $44.99
VINTAGE WHITE JELLY BELLY CLIP ON EARRINGS WITH IRIDESCENT STONES PRETTY
Buy: $19.95
Moonstone Lucite Jelly Belly Rhinestone Teddy Bear Brooch 1950s vintage
Buy: $12.95
Vintage Jelly Belly Opal Essence Gold Plated Seahorse Brooch Ocean Sea Animals
Buy: $44.99
Unique Jelly Belly White Stone GoldTone Filigree Swan Pin Made Spain Jewelry
Buy: $25.00
VINTAGE STERLING SILVER & AMBER JELLY BELLY ELEPHANT PIN BROOCH 
Buy: $28.00
Vintage 🌿 Red Jelly Belly Leaf Design Brooch Pin 🌿 Gold Tone
Buy: $30.00
Beautiful Vintage Gold Color Napier Penguin Jelly Belly Brooch with crystals
Buy: $38.50
PEACOCK Unique  Jelly Belly/Teardrop Colourful Broach Brooch/Pin/Vintage
Buy: $45.00
Vintage Signed Gerrys Doddz Jelly Belly Owl Brooch
Buy: $12.50
Vintage Gnome Elf Jelly Belly Amethyst Brazil Sterling Silver Pendant
Buy: $55.00
Tiny Vintage Figural Lucite Jelly Belly Thinestone Winking Kitty Cat Pin Brooch
Buy: $24.99
Sterling Silver Jelly Belly Spider Brooch Native American Navajo John Hornbeck
Buy: $250.00
Vintage Owl Pendant Necklace Brown Jelly Belly Cabochon Rhinestone Eyes Goldtone
Buy: $26.00
Vintage Feisty Cat Brooch with Lucite Jelly Belly
Buy: $18.00
Vintage bracelet,jelly belly amber color glass,great cnd,7"long,1 1/4"wide,
Buy: $59.99
Vintage Alfredo Villasana signed sterling silver "jelly belly" swag Brooch
Buy: $58.00
Vintage Angelfish Faux Coral Jelly Belly Red Stone Eye Aurora Borealis Pin
Buy: $10.00
Vnt CAT CABOCHON Rhinestone JELLY BELLY Brooch 3" Gold CRAFT Pin Badge Halloween
Buy: $29.98
VINTAGE Enamel & light pink JELLY BELLY BROOCH PIN  PARADISE BIRD
Buy: $36.79
VINTAGE STERLING SILVER TAXCO MEXICO SEAHORSE AMBER JELLY BELLY PIN BROOCH
Buy: $99.00
Rare Vintage Gold Tone Brooch With Stone Accents Jelly Belly Bird 7-21
Buy: $126.84
Vintage 2000 Liztech Artist Brooch Hulahoop Jelly Belly Skirt 8-lg
Buy: $139.52