NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage valentines diecut Wall Art lot Cupid Flocked Hearts Hallmark Eureka Peck
Buy: $110.49
Blow Mold White Bears Giant Heart Valentine’s Day Lighted Union Set Of 3
Buy: $109.00
Pier 1 Happy Holidays 2009 Heart Shaped Glass Ornament Li Bien Vintage Christmas
Buy: $25.00
Hand Blown Spun Glass Heart with Flower Christmas Ornament
Buy: $19.99
Dept 56 HEARTS AND BLOOMS COTTAGE Valentines Celebrate Love Swing Set
Buy: $21.99
Hallmark Keepsake "The Heart Of A Princess - Cinderella" 2022 Ornament NEW OTHER
Buy: $10.75
2pc Dr Seuss How The Grinch Stole Christmas Tree Ornament Grinch Heart Turkey
Buy: $7.99
Gingerbread Wreath Ornament | Kurt Adler
Buy: $9.99
20x Funny Tokens Funny Wooden Valentines Ornaments Funny Romantic Sex Gift Set W
Buy: $2.63
Natural Horseshoe Cross With Heart -Original Quality Handmade DIY Art Decoration
Buy: $23.99
Dept 56 Possible Dreams Santa Doctor "From the Heart" Clothique 4037291D
Buy: $85.00
6" Mexican Red hand made  Heart Ornament Sun Catcher
Buy: $30.00
Hallmark Keepsake - Our First Christmas Together - 2022 **NEW / FREE SHIPPING**
Buy: $7.00
Sacred Heart of Jesus Icon Gold Foil Icon Arched With Stand Religious Gift Idea
Buy: $19.95
SIGNED 1999 Craig ZWEIFEL Iridescent Christmas ORNAMENT Pulled Hearts #1079
Buy: $149.99
Danbury Falls Water Globe Co Together Forever Snow Globe Engravable Box Musical
Buy: $45.99
Department 56 Chapel of Love & The Happy Couple The Original Snow Village & Box
Buy: $99.00
Buy 1, Get 1 Free - Velvet Plush Heart Christmas Tree Ornament with Jute Loop
Buy: $2.00
Exclusively For Cracker Barrel Red Barn, Water Globe, Snow Globe
Buy: $20.00
Acorn Ornament
Buy: $11.99
Vintage Black Cat Heart Unicorn Hallmark Merry Miniatures Lot Valentine's Figure
Buy: $16.99
2023 Hallmark Heart of a Warrior Disney Mulan 25th Anniversary New MIB
Buy: $9.00
TARGET SPRITZ  Ceramic Love Birds 2024 Red Set of 2 Free Ship!
Buy: $22.00
Hallmark Keepsake - Love You, Mom - 2021 **NEW / FREE SHIPPING**
Buy: $7.25
HALLMARK 2022 THE HEART OF A PRINCESS DISNEY CINDERELLA ORNAMENT
Buy: $12.99
Snowbabies Department 56 Just One More Pair 2004 Shoes & Penguin With Box
Buy: $15.00
Pug Christmas Heart Ball Ornament
Buy: $11.95
Enesco Heart of Christmas Mouse Sleeping in Teacup Ornament 2.87 in
Buy: $29.95
Hallmark MVP OF MY HEART Stitched BASEBALL Valentines Day Gift NEW IN BOX
Buy: $44.98
Snowbabies Department 56 School Crossing 2006 With Box Penguins
Buy: $15.00
Pier One Li Bien Painted Glass Heart Shaped Christmas Ornament in Box 2010 VTG
Buy: $19.99
2013 Pier 1 Li Bien Reverse Painted Heart Shaped Glass Ornament "HAPPY HOLIDAYS"
Buy: $19.99
Hallmark 2023 Mulan Heart of a Warrior 25th Anniv Disney Keepsake Xmas Ornament
Buy: $11.88
Hallmark Keepsake - Little Angel - Miniature - 2022 **NEW / FREE SHIPPING**
Buy: $8.25
Waterford Holiday Heirlooms God Bless America Ball With Original Box Mouth Blown
Buy: $20.00
Knit Christmas Stocking 22 Inch Red Angels Hearts Holiday
Buy: $14.98
2023 Hallmark A HEART REMEMBERED Keepsake Christmas Ornament
Buy: $22.50
Lindsay Personalized Heart Christmas Ornament, Ganz My Very Own Angel, Holiday
Buy: $4.50
Tiffany & Co 2018 Puffy Heart Ornament Crystal Blue Glass Christmas NEW (no Box)
Buy: $275.00
Vintage Dept 56 Glass Embellished Gold Heart Christmas Ornament Poland 3.5"
Buy: $19.95
6FT Easter Inflatable Outdoor Decoration Bunny Couple Holding Love Heart, Lig...
Buy: $45.18
Old World Christmas Small Red Heart Tree Ornament Glass Hanging Valentines
Buy: $9.99
Snowbabies Department 56 The Littlest Christmas Tree 2001 With Box Snow Globe
Buy: $15.00
2 Christmas Ornament Picture Frame Christmas Wreath Photo Frame (Read Descriptio
Buy: $10.99
Raggedy Ann & Andy Christmas Ornaments Heart Gift Macmillan Plastic 1992 *NEW*
Buy: $16.50
Hallmark Acrylic Heart Love Ornaments Vintage Lot Of 6
Buy: $9.99
BEAUTIFUL HAND Spun Glass Ornament Lot of 15 - NICE Assortment!! FREE SHIPPING!
Buy: $26.00
Christopher Radko HEART RIDE Cupid on Heart Christmas Ornament w/ Tag
Buy: $24.99
Meadowbrooke (?) Gourds Black Dog Heart Halloween Decoration Hand Made Carved
Buy: $24.99
Hyde and EEK! Boutique 2023 Halloween Felt Tombstone Skeleton Duo Figurine
Buy: $13.99
Primitives by Kathy Felt Mouse Couple Heart Critter Love Valentines Day Cute
Buy: $16.95
Book Lovers Heart Ornament, Reading Book Christmas Gift  Ornament, Acrylic Tree
Buy: $6.23
Target Spritz Valentine’s Day 2024 Red Ceramic Eiffel Tower Eiffel In Love
Buy: $19.95
Memorial Ornament, My Mind Still Talks to You, Heaven Cardinal Ornament Tree Car
Buy: $15.29
3 LEFTON VALENTINE TRIO BELLS HEARTS  ❤️ GIRLS FIGURINES ❤️ PLANTER
Buy: $299.00
Dept 56 I WILL HONOR CHRISTMAS IN MY HEART Dickens Village 6009738 NEW 2022
Buy: $36.00
Anglechic 36 Pcs Vintage Valentine Ornaments Wooden Tree Ornaments Angel Heart L
Buy: $14.35
Chicago Skyline Glass Snow Globe I Heart Chicago Souvenir Gift 2"
Buy: $12.99
Lemax Upsy Daisy! 92289 and Child At Heart 92308 1999 Figurines Retired NEW
Buy: $30.00
2  Christmas Ornament Photo Picture Frame Silver Hearts Circle Ornament
Buy: $10.99
Hallmark Keepsake - Meant to Be - 2022 **NEW / FREE SHIPPING**
Buy: $10.99
Jim Shore Snoopy Laying On Heart Figurine Peanuts 5.25”H Valentines Love  NIB
Buy: $47.99
DISNEY BELLE & BEAST  (BEAUTY & THE BEAST) SIGNED TRUE LOVE VALENTINE HEART CARD
Buy: $7.90
Hallmark Christmas Ornament Baby's First Girl's Pink Bear Princess Teether 2014
Buy: $6.99
2022 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament ~ "Family Forever" Heart Shaped Photo Holder NEW
Buy: $8.59
Life Is Good Set Of 4 Wooden Ornaments Holiday Be Kind Heart
Buy: $22.00
A Day At The Beach 2015 Hallmark Keepsake NIB Ocean Sand Glass Hanging Ornament
Buy: $20.00
2022 Hallmark Keepsake “Our Anniversary” Metal Changeable Date Brand New In Box
Buy: $6.87
Valentine’s Day Heart Shaped Candy Dish With Poinsettia Glass
Buy: $7.95
KEY TO MY HEART - a Gift for your Sweetheart -  Swarovski crystal & "LOVE" Charm
Buy: $5.29
Precious Moments 'Have A Heart-Warming Christmas' 2019 Dated Ornament 191002
Buy: $32.00
New Kurt Adler Delft Blue Porcelain Star Ornament J7310 Free Shipping
Buy: $8.95
DISNEY SNOW WHITE & THE PRINCE AUTOGRAPHED TRUE LOVE VALENTINE HEART CARD
Buy: $6.50
Hallmark Ornament Our Christmas Together 2015 Glass Heart Metal Snowflake Love
Buy: $12.99
1986 Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament Loving Memories heart bear bell gift
Buy: $14.99
Hallmark 2022 Ornament - The Heart Of A Princess - Disney - Cinderella
Buy: $11.95
Hallmark Acrylic Christmas Ornament The Miracle of Love Heart 1984 Decoration
Buy: $12.99
HAND & HAMMER Sterling Christmas Ornament - HEART - Through Stained Glass Window
Buy: $69.00
HALLMARK ORNAMENT "A TOAST TO LOVE" 2009 FIRST CHRISTMAS * NEW * FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $9.99
KURT ADLER 4" RESIN "I LOVE THE BEACH" HEART COASTAL CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT J1436
Buy: $9.78
HALLMARK 2014 A YEAR OF DISNEY MAGIC SWEETS FOR THE SWEET MINNIE ORNAMENT
Buy: $8.07
Lenox Lot of 7 Porcelain Pins: Angels, Doves, Heart, Snowman~ 1-2" tall
Buy: $20.00
Bethany Lowe Set Of 4 Different Tin Valentine Heart Ornaments TF8590
Buy: $16.50
HALLMARK 2023 FAIRY TALE FIRST DANACE DISNEY BEAUTY AND THE BEAST ORNAMENT
Buy: $16.58
Christopher Radko Valentine's Day 1997 "Heart Ride" Ornament with Box
Buy: $39.99
Dept 56 Snowbabies "You're Sweetheart" Porcelain Figurine In Original Box
Buy: $16.99
1989 Our First Christmas Together Heart  w/ Mice On Swing Ornament
Buy: $16.99
HAND & HAMMER Sterling Christmas Ornament - HEART OF CHRISTMAS "The Creche"
Buy: $69.00
Valentines Crepe Paper Party Tablecloth Vtg 60s 70s Cherubs Hearts Pink Kitsch
Buy: $11.99
Dept 56 A CHRISTMAS HONEYMOON Dickens Village 6009742 BRAND NEW 2022 Cricket's
Buy: $35.91
Hallmark 2022 Little Angel with Ceramic Heart Miniature New Ornament
Buy: $7.95
Hallmark 2016 Disney Cinderella Ornament ~ A Dream Is A Wish Your Heart Makes
Buy: $14.99
Disney Poison Apple Ornament Heart Keepsake Box Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Buy: $63.99
Vintage Vibrant Wooden 2 Painted Birds Red & Yellow Christmas Ornaments
Buy: $12.49
Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Baby Mickey's Sweet Dreams Mickey & Co Christmas 1999
Buy: $9.97
Fitz & Floyd Home Warms the Heart Sentiment Tray Small Oval Christmas Platter
Buy: $12.99
Hallmark 2016 Our First Christmas Keepsake Ornament Gold Tone Beaded Heart ~ NIB
Buy: $8.50
Hallmark 'I Love The Hallmark Channel' Mittens In Heart Shape 2023 Ornament NIB
Buy: $8.95
Vintage Christopher Radko Love is the Air Cupid Valentine Heart Glass Ornament
Buy: $43.98
Pier 1 Li Bien Glass Red Heart Christmas Ornament 2008 Joy/Noel Vintage w/ Box
Buy: $25.00