NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $59.49
VTG Hallmark 1982 Baby's 1st Christmas Teddy Bear Flat w Candy Cane & Apron 15"
Buy: $59.49
Buy: $23.16
Hallmark Itty Bittys Glinda The Good Witch Wizard Of Oz Limited Edition
Buy: $23.16
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Hallmark Brown Beanie Puppy Red Leather Collar Plush Stuffed Toy EUC
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $42.00
Hallmark Rocking Chair Teddy Bear Decorative Holiday Plush Stuffed Animal 13"
Buy: $42.00
Buy: $19.97
1987 Hallmark RUTHERFORD B BUZZARD Vulture 11" Plush Vintage Stuffed Animal Bird
Buy: $19.97
Buy: $11.99
2004 Hallmark 550 Piece Puzzle Country Garden New/Sealed Hasbro MB
Buy: $11.99
Buy: $7.24
2017 Hallmark Itty Bittys Marvel Iron Patriot Second In Series Red Plush NWT
Buy: $7.24
Buy: $8.05
Hallmark Itty Bittys ~ SNOOPY - HEART GLASSES - Peanuts Beanie - Valentine's Day
Buy: $8.05
Buy: $89.00
4 Hallmark Kiddie Car Classics Lot Dump Fire Truck Ranch Wagon 1992-1994 Large
Buy: $89.00
Buy: $16.99
Hallmark 2002 Dinotopia Egg #21 Ughbert Dinosaur Plush "26" Alpha Series
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $29.72
Snoopy Purple Plush Happy Hauntings NEW 2023 Halloween 10” NWT Hallmark Peanut
Buy: $29.72
Buy: $5.00
Hallmark Purr Tenders Cat Plush Stocking 8" 1987 Stuffed Animal Toy Burger King
Buy: $5.00
Buy: $7.75
Hallmark Itty Bittys Scooby Doo Daphne Plush
Buy: $7.75
Buy: $16.99
VTG 1975 Hallmark Road Rovers Series 1 #1 Chocolate Mouse Diecast Car Toy CD21
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $17.99
Hallmark “Hoops & Yoyo” Hoops Plush Keychain W/ Backpack 6”
Buy: $17.99
Buy: $39.87
Mixed Lot of Six Hallmark Keepsake Train Ornaments
Buy: $39.87
Buy: $30.00
Hallmark Until We Hug Again Plush Pink Bunny Record Message Talking - New
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $12.98
Hallmark My Best Friend Dachshund Dog Plush Stuffed Animal
Buy: $12.98
Buy: $32.72
Thanksgiving Feast Turkey Potato Pie 3 Plush dolls HALLMARK Better Together
Buy: $32.72
Buy: $49.99
Hallmark itty bittys Travis Kelce Plush Doll with 2020 Trading Card NEW on card
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $11.97
NEW Hallmark Disney Descendants Evie Itty Bitty Mini Plush Doll Toy
Buy: $11.97
Buy: $8.95
Hallmark Itty Bittys ELLEN RIPLEY Alien Sigourney Weaver Limited Edition NEW NWT
Buy: $8.95
Buy: $12.99
Hallmark Itty Bittys 4" Limited Edition Monster High Frankie Stein
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $21.99
Hallmark Egg Humpty Dumpty Vtg 1982 Toddler Nursery Decor Pastel Plush Free Ship
Buy: $21.99
Buy: $14.75
C-3PO and R2-D2 1997 Keepsake Ornament STAR WARS Hallmark MIB
Buy: $14.75
Buy: $7.15
Disney/Pixar Hallmark Itty Bitty's Inside Out 4" Fear Beanbag Plush
Buy: $7.15
Buy: $19.95
Hallmark Itty Bittys - Fashion Barbie Collector Set Exclusive Characters- NIB
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $19.99
Hallmark Plush Teddy Bear Basil White Tan Plaid Bow Tie Stuffed Animal Toy 13"
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $37.99
Hallmark HO Scale House & Shop Collection Series #27 2010 Colonial Home
Buy: $37.99
Buy: $33.00
Hallmark Snoopy Plush A Charlie Brown Christmas 40th Anniversary Stuffed Animal
Buy: $33.00
Buy: $8.74
New Hallmark Itty Bittys Girl Soccer Player and Boy Track Runner 4.5"
Buy: $8.74
Buy: $15.99
Hallmark Itty Bittys The Walking Dead Special Edition Carl Grimes Plush Figure
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $10.80
Hallmark MERRILY BEAR Christmas Teddy 10" Stuffed Curly Plush in Snowman Sweater
Buy: $10.80
Buy: $9.99
Vintage 1984 Hallmark Felt Plush Rhonda Lady Reindeer
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $99.00
4 Hallmark Kiddie Car Classic Lot 1955 Fire Chief Boat Wagon Car Large 1993 1994
Buy: $99.00
Buy: $7.99
Hallmark Itty Bitty Plush Star Wars Characters U PICK DROP DOWN 10% off 2 +
Buy: $7.99
Buy: $125.00
4 Original 5 Five 1992 Hallmark Kiddie Car Classics 1955 Dump Fire Truck Large
Buy: $125.00
Buy: $27.99
Hallmark HO Scale House & Shop Collection Series #16 1999 House on Holly Hill
Buy: $27.99
Buy: $18.44
Hallmark Request A Song Mimi Mouse Plush Stuffed Animal Interactive Singing Toy
Buy: $18.44
Buy: $15.95
Hallmark Axolotl Valentine’s Day Plush 8" Hearts Stuffed Animal Toy NWT
Buy: $15.95
Buy: $49.99
Vtg 1986 Hallmark Zoobilee Zoo Bravo Fox Plush Hand Puppet Red Stuffed Animal
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $16.20
Hallmark Hoops & Yoyo 6" Pink Hoops with Backpack Plush Clip Keychain Toy
Buy: $16.20
Buy: $11.44
Hallmark Itty Bitty Bitty's BADTZ-MARU Sanrio Hello Kitty stuffed plush NWT
Buy: $11.44
Buy: $15.95
HALLMARK GREMLINS CHRISTMAS 8" PLUSH SANTA GIZMO A53
Buy: $15.95
Buy: $14.25
Hallmark Beagle toy stuffed animal Plush My best Friend Puppy Dog
Buy: $14.25
Buy: $3.14
NWT Hallmark little Brandon Bear Costume Glows In The Dark 8" Halloween Doll
Buy: $3.14
Buy: $14.99
Hallmark Axolotl Valentine’s Day Plush 8" Hearts Pink Stuffed Animal Toy NWT
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $15.00
Pedal Car Model Die Cast 1964 Tin Lizzie Hallmark Kiddie Car Classics 1333
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $9.99
Vintage Christmas Bridge 2-Table Tallies Petite Napkins Snowmen Hallmark NEW
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $13.95
Crayola Hallmark Expressions Zebra 5.5" Tall Teal Blue Stuffed Plush Animal 2001
Buy: $13.95
Buy: $12.00
Hallmark Itty Bittys Clippys Rainbow Brite and Twink Stuffed Plush Dolls
Buy: $12.00
Buy: $16.99
Vintage New Hallmark Valentine Plush Pig Cupid Hearts Wings Stuffed Animal Tags
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $25.00
Hallmark-Itty Bitty-Planet of The Apes Dr. Zaius & Dr. Cornelius-limited edition
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $15.79
Hallmark Rodney Reindeer Plush Christmas Stuffed Animal Red Scarf 2013
Buy: $15.79
Buy: $6.99
VTG 1984 Hallmark "KOKO" Koala Plush Stuffed Animal Red Bow & Holding Heart
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $16.49
Obi-Wan Kenobi Collector Series 2000 Keepsake Ornament STAR WARS Hallmark MIB
Buy: $16.49
Buy: $23.96
Vintage Hallmark Exclusive Purrrsonality Cats Franklin The Top Cat 1986 11"Plush
Buy: $23.96
Buy: $30.00
VINTAGE 1980'S HALLMARK MILTON BRADLEY SHIRT TALES CARD GAME IN BOX #4322
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $14.25
SNOOPY WOODSTOCK Peanuts Happiness Is A Hug Plush Hallmark
Buy: $14.25
Buy: $19.76
Vintage 1985 Hugga Bunch Patooty Plush Doll 17" Green Eyes Kenner/Hallmark
Buy: $19.76
Buy: $34.49
Vintage Kenner Yum Yums Collection Pink Cheery Cherry Snowcone Poodle Plush 1989
Buy: $34.49
Buy: $17.50
Hallmark Itty Bittys Harry Potter & Draco Malfoy Special Edition Set of 2, NEW
Buy: $17.50
Buy: $13.00
Hallmark Peanuts Plushie, 5" Woodstock, Shaggy
Buy: $13.00
Buy: $22.00
NEW HALLMARK RAINBOW BRITE ITTY BITTYS A BRITE AND STORMY SHOW BOOK AND PLUSH
Buy: $22.00
Buy: $10.99
KANSAS CITY ROYALS SLUGGERRR Itty Bittys MLB Special Edition Plush Toy NWT
Buy: $10.99
Buy: $14.99
Hallmark School Days Batman And Robin Vintage 1999 Mini Toy
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $12.00
Vintage Smooshees Halloween Hideaways Ghost Ghoul Cauldron Plush Toy 1989
Buy: $12.00
Buy: $13.00
NEW Hallmark Itty Bittys Plush (YOU CHOOSE)
Buy: $13.00
Buy: $12.00
2 Vintage Original 1981 Hallmark SHIRT TALES Animals Paper Place Mats 16”x11”
Buy: $12.00
Buy: $9.00
ITTY BITTYS LOT STAR WARS C3P0, CHEWBACCA, LUKE, OBI, MICKEY
Buy: $9.00
Buy: $13.99
Mary's Angels Hallmark Soft Plush Boy Figure w/ Puppy Newborn Faith Jesus Gift
Buy: $13.99
Buy: $13.00
2003 Hallmark Bunnies by the Bay ~ Buttercup Plush ~ 12 Inch ~ NWT ~ Free Ship
Buy: $13.00
Buy: $12.99
Hallmark Itty Bittys CHOOSE Snoopy My Little Pony Mary's Angels FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $23.98
NEW Hallmark Easter Plush EGG LAYING DINOSAUR 14" Interactive Motion Music Song
Buy: $23.98
Buy: $12.99
HALLMARK Little Heartly Dog Plush Stuffed Animal 7"
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $12.99
PEACE ON EARTH,WINDOWS OF FAITH,Yr 2012 Hallmark Keepsake,FINAL IN SERIES
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $18.50
Hallmark Plush Puppy Dog XOXO says "You're So Doggone Cute" Valentine's Day Gift
Buy: $18.50
Buy: $11.26
Hallmark Halloween Toe-Tappin Trick Or Treat Bag Sound & Motion Sings Working
Buy: $11.26
Buy: $22.50
Vintage Shirt Tales Tyg Tiger Plush 1981 Hallmark Stuffed Animal
Buy: $22.50
Buy: $11.98
Hallmark Itty Bittys Disney Frozen Movie Anna Doll Stuffed Plush 5" EUC
Buy: $11.98
Buy: $12.99
Hallmark Itty Bittys CHOOSE Star Wars Marvel Comics DC Comics FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $22.99
*HALLMARK MYSTERY ORNAMENTS - HARRY POTTER - HOGWARTS EXPRESS TRAIN- SUPER RARE*
Buy: $22.99
Buy: $8.95
HALLMARK STAR WARS SOLO ENFYS NEST PLUSH BEAN BAG NEW
Buy: $8.95
Buy: $13.95
Crayola Hallmark Expressions Zebra 5.5" Tall Blue Stuffed Plush Animal 2001
Buy: $13.95
Buy: $5.95
White Teddy Bear Plush by HALLMARK Soft & Fully Jointed 16" w/ Pink Gingham Bow
Buy: $5.95
Buy: $24.95
17" Hallmark Pink Winnie Bunny Plush Gingham Flower Bow Stuffed Animal
Buy: $24.95
Buy: $24.00
Lullaby League Girl Hallmark Itty-Bittys Special Edition Wizard Of Oz w/ tag
Buy: $24.00
Buy: $15.99
Pepe Le Pew Plush Skunk with Flower I Pick You Looney Tunes Hallmark 10" Talks
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $8.05
Hallmark Itty Bittys ~ SNOOPY w/HOLIDAY HAT - Peanuts Beanie Plush for Christmas
Buy: $8.05
Buy: $17.99
Hallmark Santa And Gifts Puzzle 1000 Pcs 30 X 24 Goeff Greenleaf Xmas Toy Tree
Buy: $17.99
Buy: $10.90
Hallmark Love Ya Plush Brown Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Blue T-Shirt Sitting 9”
Buy: $10.90
Buy: $19.99
Hallmark Dr. Seuss How the Grinch Stole Christmas Max Dog Plush 1998 w/ Tags
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $28.88
Vintage 1983 Hallmark 10" RAINBOW BRITE Hugger with White Sprite Doll Lšk! š
Buy: $28.88
Buy: $22.00
Rodney Reindeer plush toy lot nylon vintage 80s Christmas themed stuffed animals
Buy: $22.00
Buy: $16.88
Hallmark Itty Bittys Sorcerer Mickey Disney Fantasia Stuffed Animal Plush NWT
Buy: $16.88
Buy: $19.99
Hallmark Itty Bittys Fashion Barbie Collector Set of 4 NEW
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $12.99
Hallmark Forever Friends 8” Tan Crinkle Bear Pink & White Polka Dot Feet Plush
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $17.99
1986 Hallmark Moondoggies Plush I'd Follow You Anywhere Mini 4.5" Stuffed Animal
Buy: $17.99
Buy: $14.75
HALLMARK'S "COLDWELL" PLUSH Christmas SNOWMAN 10" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $14.75
