NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Ty Beanie Baby - ODIE the Dog (Cartoon Version)(8 Inch) MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $69.90
ty beanie baby garfield !!!
Buy: $32.00
Ty GARFIELD The Cat Beanie Buddy 12" (Laying Down Version) MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $44.90
beanie baby pookie
Buy: $65.00
Ty Beanie Baby Babies Rare Garfield Movie Cat 2004 MWMT!
Buy: $12.99
RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~LUCA THE DOG PUPPY FROM THE GARFIELD MOVIE 7"
Buy: $10.83
2004 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~ARLENE THE CAT FROM THE GARFIELD MOVIE 6"~NEW
Buy: $10.84
TY Beanie Baby - ARLENE the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) - MWMTs
Buy: $10.89
NWT Ty Beanie Baby Babies Garfield Odie Mini 6” Plush W/Tags
Buy: $19.95
TY Classic Plush GARFIELD & POOKY (15.5 in) BFF Best Friends Forever
Buy: $35.00
TY Beanie * NERMAL * CAT* From the Garfield Movie * Retired * RARE * 6" *MWMT
Buy: $19.99
NWT Ty Beanie Babies Garfield Happy Valentine's Day Heart Shirt Sunglasses 2005
Buy: $19.95
TY Beanie Baby - ODIE the Dog (Cartoon version) (8 inch) Rare! Stuffed Garfield
Buy: $44.95
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat (I DON'T DO PERKY) (9 inch) -MWMTs Stuffed Toy
Buy: $30.89
TY Bow Wow Beanie Babies - GARFIELD the Cat Bite Me (7.5 inch) - New Dog Toy
Buy: $32.89
2005 RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~GARFIELD THE CAT 8"~VALENTINES DAY VERSION~NEW
Buy: $19.94
Ty BABY GARFIELD in Diaper Beanie Baby 2010 - 8” Used
Buy: $15.99
2004 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~ODIE THE DOG FROM THE GARFIELD MOVIE 8"~NEW
Buy: $12.54
Ty Beanie Babies GARFIELD  Stuck On You  Plush 9" tall with suction cups & Tags
Buy: $16.00
2004 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~NERMAL THE CAT FROM GARFIELD MOVIE 8" TOY~NEW
Buy: $17.28
Ty Beanie Baby - POOKY THE BEAR (Garfield) 5" PLASTIC KEY CLIP New MWMT's
Buy: $34.95
2004 RARE RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY GARFIELD THE CAT GARFIELD MOVIE 7”NWT
Buy: $9.50
Ty Beanie Baby - LUCA the Dog (Garfield Movie)(6.5 Inch) MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $10.89
TY 2000 GOODNIGHT GARFIELD with POOKY the BEANIE BABY - MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $22.99
Ty Beanie Baby - GARFIELD THE CAT 5" PLASTIC KEY CLIP New MWMT's
Buy: $19.95
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) - MWMTs
Buy: $14.89
RARE HIS MAJESTY GARFIELD TY BEANIE BABIE WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $11.99
Ty Beanie Baby - GARFIELD THE CAT 5"  METAL KEY CLIP New MWMT's
Buy: $19.95
Ty GARFIELD The Cat Beanie Laying Down Buddy 12" NWT
Buy: $34.95
Lot of 9 Beanie Babies | Non-Mint Tags |Garfield, Dogs, Bears & More
Buy: $50.00
Lot of 9 Beanie Babies | Non-Mint Tags | Garfield, Soccer, Lefty &  More
Buy: $45.00
Vintage 2006 Garfield " I've been good...really!" TY Plush Toy
Buy: $45.00
TY GARFIELD the CAT (HAPPY VALENTINE'S DAY) BEANIE BABY - MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $22.99
TY Beanie Babies Luca Dog Garfield Plush 2004 Tags NWT Garfield The Movie
Buy: $14.04
Ty Beanie Baby GARFIELD the Cat Stuck On You 9 Inch Plush Toy Window Cling
Buy: $27.50
TY Beanie Babies Happy Holidays Garfield Plush w/ Santa Hat & Christmas Gift NWT
Buy: $17.87
TY Garfield Plush Beanie  Season Greetings Christmas Xmas 10" tall no hang tag
Buy: $5.00
Garfield The Movie 2004 TY Beanie Buddy 9” Plush Orange Cat w/ Collar Stuffed
Buy: $14.96
RETIRED TY BABY BEANIE BUDDY~CHRISTMAS GARFIELD CAT SEASONS GREETINGS 12"~NEW
Buy: $29.52
TY BEANIE BABY~STUFFED THE THANKSGIVINGS DAY TURKEY BIRD 6"~BBOM NOV 2006~NEW
Buy: $24.48
RARE JIMBO ELEPHANT TY BEANIE BABIE WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $11.99
Ty Beanie Baby - ODIE the Dog from Garfield the Movie 2004 NWT
Buy: $12.25
TY Beanie Baby - ODIE the Dog ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (5.5 inch)
Buy: $6.99
Ty Beanie Buddy-GARFIELD  CHRISTMAS 13" WITH HAT NEW MWMT's
Buy: $24.95
TY Beanie Baby Garfield Cat Happy Holidays Christmas Present 9" 2005 Retired
Buy: $15.00
TY Beanie Babies Happy Holidays Garfield Plush 2005 Tags W Christmas Gift NWT
Buy: $16.68
TY Garfield Plush Stuffed Animal Beanie 8" Season Greetings Christmas Xmas
Buy: $7.97
2004 Ty Garfield the Movie Cool Cat & Pooky Mini Plush Toy Set
Buy: $39.99
TY Beanie GARFIELD Cat 7" with Red Collar Retired 2004
Buy: $6.99
TY Arlene the Cat Plush Bean Bag Garfield Character Toy Stuffed Animal BIN 1
Buy: $14.95
Ty Beanie Babies GARFIELD the Cat Movie 2004 Plush Stuffed 10” Collectible Toy
Buy: $14.95
RARE LOUIS GARFIELD MOVIE TY BEANIE BABIE WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $14.99
RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~GARFIELD THE CAT ST PATRICKS IRISH (4-H VERSION) 9"~NEW
Buy: $24.98
Ty Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD THE CAT LAYING DOWN 12" MEDIUM PLUSH New MWMT's
Buy: $39.95
Ty Beanie Baby Arlene - MWMT, Cat Garfield
Buy: $14.89
TY Beanie Babies Happy Holidays Garfield Plush w/ Santa Hat & Christmas Gift NWT
Buy: $19.99
TY Original Beanie Babies Garfield The Cat Movie Plush Toy 2004 Orange Striped
Buy: $14.99
2007 Ty Garfield Perfection Is Hard To Improve Plush Toy Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.00
Ty Beanie Babies Happy Holidays Garfield Christmas Cat
Buy: $12.99
TY Beanie Baby -  LUCA 6" DOG GARFIELD MOVIE NEW MWMT's
Buy: $10.95
RARE GARFIELD TY BEANIE BABIE WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $14.99
TY GARFIELD (STUCK ON YOU!) Beanie Babies baby plush orange cat
Buy: $22.00
2005 RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~GARFIELD CAT HAPPY HOLIDAYS CHRISTMAS PRESENT 9”
Buy: $11.04
Ty Beanie Baby- BABY GARFIELD 8" NEW MWMT's
Buy: $34.95
TY Beanie Babies Season's Greetings Garfield Plush 2006
Buy: $12.74
RARE HAPPY HOLIDAYS GARFIELD CHRISTMAS TY BEANIE BABIE WITH TAG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $11.99
Garfield Ty Beanie Babies - 2004 Collar, 7" Soft Plush
Buy: $15.95
RARE & HTF-Ty 2006 Beanie Baby-Garfield 4-H- Garfield w/Apple-For 4-H Clubs-MWMT
Buy: $24.95
TY Garfield The Cat Movie Pooky Odie Set Lot Of 3 Beanie Baby Babies NWT
Buy: $79.99
TY BEANIE BABIES GARFIELD & ODIE
Buy: $12.99
2004 TY  Beanie Babies ODIE Morsel The Dog from Garfield Movie 8 Inch Tags Brown
Buy: $14.99
TY LUCA the DOBERMAN Dog from the 2004 Garfield Movie - 6" NEW
Buy: $8.95
Garfield the Cat 10” 2004 TY Plush Beanie Buddies Collection
Buy: $19.99
Ty Beanie Baby Odie (Garfield movie) Dog 8" 20cm New MWMTs Rare Retired
Buy: $12.99
TY GARFIELD THE CAT BEANIE BUDDY - LAYING DOWN VERSION - MINT with MINT TAGS
Buy: $40.00
Ty Beanie Baby - COOL CAT The Garfield Movie (2006 Release) New With Tags
Buy: $21.99
Ty Garfield Duo. New! Good Night Garfield And Perfectly Lovable Garfield.
Buy: $35.00
Happy Valentine's Day Original TY Beanie Babies Lot Of 2
Buy: $20.00
TOM-E the Turkey ✨️Gorgeous Mint MWMT ✨️ original TY Beanie Baby Ty Store Excl.
Buy: $14.00
VTG 2001 Club Garfield 4-H Tshirt 4H Plush w tags 8” Paws Fine Toy collectible
Buy: $19.99
My kingdom my rules poem HIS MAJESTY Garfield Ty Beanie Baby A Tale of 2 Kittens
Buy: $11.39
Ty Beanie Baby Luca - MWMT (Dog Garfield Movie Beanie)
Buy: $11.00
LEX the Bear 🧸 Gorgeous Mint MWMT 🧸rare original TY Beanie Baby Vintage
Buy: $12.00
TY Beanie Baby - NERMAL the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) - MWMTs
Buy: $19.89
Cat’s rule dogs drool poem HIS MAJESTY Garfield Ty Beanie Baby Tale of 2 Kittens
Buy: $11.99
Garfield ‘His Majesty’ Plush 2006 Cat King Crown Beanie Baby TY 7"
Buy: $7.97
TY Beanie Baby - LUCA the Dog Garfield Movie Beanie 6.5 inch regular all tags
Buy: $7.50
New Ty Classic Garfield Sleepy Laying Down Beanie Plush
Buy: $99.99
Rare 2004 Set of 8 Ty Beanie Baby Garfield Characters with Name Tag/Collar MWMT
Buy: $130.00
Ty Beanie Baby GARFIELD- HIS MAJESTY- It’s Good To Be King 7” Collection Retired
Buy: $11.59
TY Beanie Baby - LUCA the Dog ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) (6.5 inch) - MWMT's
Buy: $9.89
2005 Ty Beanie Baby Happy Holidays Garfield Holding Present With Santa Hat 9"
Buy: $14.99
TY Beanie Babies GARFIELD Perfection is Hard to Improve RARE & RETIRED (NEW)
Buy: $29.00
Ty Beanie Buddies GARFIELD  Lying Down  * RETIRED * Rare 2006
Buy: $17.94
Ty Beanie Babies-Luca The Dog-MWMT-Garfield The Movie With Golden Name Tag-6"
Buy: $12.99
2006 TY The Beanie Babies Collection Garfield the Cat  🐱Your Majesty 👑
Buy: $11.99
TY Beanie Baby - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Beanie ) 6.5"...NEW Mint Tags
Buy: $17.50
Ty Beanie Baby GARFIELD the Cat Orange 5in Soft Plush 2004 Red Collar Name Tag
Buy: $13.99
2004 TY Garfield the Movie "GARFIELD THE CAT" 6.5" Character Beanie Plush w/ Tag
Buy: $24.95
CT* TY Beanie Buddy - GARFIELD the Cat ( Garfield Movie Promo ) (9.5 inch) MWCT
Buy: $20.90