NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $250.00
Lot of 9 plush Funko The Nightmare Before Christmas Plushies Pumpkin Zero Lock +
Buy: $250.00
Buy: $59.49
Funko POP! Disney THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS Oogie Boogie Jack Sally Lot NWT
Buy: $59.49
Buy: $139.99
Vintage - Nightmare Before Christmas (Tiger Electronics LCD, 1993) Brand New! 🔥
Buy: $139.99
Buy: $43.69
Scentsy Buddy SALLY - TIM BURTON'S THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS ~ New! Rare
Buy: $43.69
Buy: $16.99
Yahtzee - Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington Hasbro Replacement Lot
Buy: $16.99
Buy: $14.99
Hoot Owl Hoot! Board Game A Cooperative Game Peaceable Kingdom 2-4 players 4+up
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $33.99
Monopoly The Nightmare Before Christmas Bonus Token Board Game (2015) COMPLETE
Buy: $33.99
Buy: $19.99
Squishmallows Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Plush Lot
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $7.90
APPLES to APPLES DICE GAME - Pop Open Fast Fun! - 2011 - 100% COMPLETE
Buy: $7.90
Buy: $17.00
Green Oogie Boogie ♡ 5" Nightmare Before Christmas Squishmallow ♡ BNWT HTF RARE
Buy: $17.00
Buy: $30.99
Munchkin The Nightmare Before Christmas Card Game New Box Damaged
Buy: $30.99
Buy: $23.41
DISNEY The Nightmare Before Christmas PREMIUM DICE SET w/ CUSTOM BAG HALLOWEEN
Buy: $23.41
Buy: $9.99
Lot of 2 - Nightmare Before Christmas Sally 5” Squishmallow Plush - New
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $149.00
Disney's The Nightmare Before Christmas 5” Squishmallows Lot- 2021 Set Of 5
Buy: $149.00
Buy: $19.99
Squishmallow Christmas Ornaments Bartie the Elf Gina the Gingerbread Plush Lot 2
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $145.00
Squishmallows Mixed Halloween Lot New w/Tags (Qty 18)
Buy: $145.00
Buy: $12.83
Zombie Duck Nightmare Before Christmas Monopoly Metal Game Token
Buy: $12.83
Buy: $19.99
Would Yule Rather Dice Christmas Game Demdaco Let's get This Party Rolling New
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $19.99
Peaceable Kingdom Hoot Owl Hoot! Award Winning Cooperative Game, USED, Complete
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $45.00
Disney Store Nightmare Before Christmas Lot of 5 Mini Bean Bag Plush W/Tags
Buy: $45.00
Buy: $29.99
Disney Nightmare Before Christmas lot of 3 Spooky Shakers pull toys plush-NIP
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $99.00
Lot 4 Nightmare Before Christmas Games Monopoly Clue Trivial Pursuit Tarot Deck
Buy: $99.00
Buy: $4.99
Apples To Apples Dice Game (2011 Game) NEW
Buy: $4.99
Buy: $14.99
Monopoly The Nightmare Before Christmas Replacement Game Token Pieces Lot Of 5
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $20.00
Monopoly The Nightmare Before Christmas Replacement Game Token Pieces Lot Of 5
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $14.77
Squishmallow 7" Glena Eggplant RARE Size Soft Purple Veggie Plush BNWT Free Ship
Buy: $14.77
Buy: $29.95
Loter�a: Disney Tim Burton�s The Nightmare Before Christmas | Traditional Lot...
Buy: $29.95
Buy: $26.99
Disney Store Nightmare Before Christmas White Dog ZERO Plush w/6" Clip LOT
Buy: $26.99
Buy: $45.98
Mini barco de control remoto de batería de juguete para niños de 6"
Buy: $45.98
Buy: $14.21
Mayor's Hearse Nightmare Before Christmas Monopoly Metal Game Token
Buy: $14.21
Buy: $19.60
Trivial Pursuit Tim Burton’s: The Nightmare Before Christmas 2010 100% Complete
Buy: $19.60
Buy: $19.99
Creatology 8.5" Halloween USED GREEN Witch Stuffed DOLL EMBROIDERED EYES 3+
Buy: $19.99
Buy: $30.00
Nightmare Before Christmas Monopoly Game Collector's Edition 2009 Disney NIB
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $18.50
Lot of 2 Squishmallow Series 5 Squishville Mystery Mini Set In-Hand U.S seller
Buy: $18.50
Buy: $33.00
SQUISHMALLOWS SALLY JACK Nightmare Before Christmas SET Lot 2 Nwt
Buy: $33.00
Buy: $15.00
Zero the Ghost Dog ♡ 5" Nightmare Before Christmas Squishmallow ♡ BNWT HTF RARE
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $12.00
Vintage Doll Sally Nightmare Before Christmas - Disney
Buy: $12.00
Buy: $119.99
NEW 2022 Squishmallow Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Sally Zero Oogie Lot Of 5
Buy: $119.99
Buy: $49.99
Disney The Nightmare Before Christmas UNO Card Game 2017 RARE, NEW SEALED
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $20.00
Vintage 2003 The Night Before Christmas Lot Of 3 Not Tested
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $16.50
Disney Nightmare Creepy Cuff Lock W Packaging NEW SCARCE SOLD OUT Rare Item
Buy: $16.50
Buy: $40.49
Clue Critical Role The Mighty Nein Campaign Edition Board Game
Buy: $40.49
Buy: $35.94
USAOPOLY CLUE: Critical Role | Solve The Mystery in This Collectible Clue Game F
Buy: $35.94
Buy: $25.00
Vintage Disney World Nightmare Before Christmas JACK 13” Mini Bean Bag Plush
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $49.99
Squishmallow Halloween lot 3.5" Otto Grim Reaper, Aldron & Emily Key Chain clip
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $24.99
Denton the Chameleon 12" Squishmallow Kellytoy Green with Rainbow Scales NWT
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $16.00
Sally ♡ 5" Nightmare Before Christmas Disney Squishmallow ♡ BNWT HTF RARE
Buy: $16.00
Buy: $8.79
Ty Beanie Baby Bongo The Monkey
Buy: $8.79
Buy: $16.00
Sally ♡ 5" Nightmare Before Christmas Squishmallow ♡ BNWT HTF RARE
Buy: $16.00
Buy: $94.99
RARE 14" Scary Teddy Plush Nightmare Before Christmas FIRST VERSION w/tags
Buy: $94.99
Buy: $30.00
NEW Tim Burton’s Nightmare Before Christmas Edition Funko Card Games ~ Lot of 2
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $7.99
Apples to Apples Dice Game - Pop Open Fast Fun!
Buy: $7.99
Buy: $19.79
St Nicholas Reindeer Christmas Holiday Square Door Draft Stopper Stuffed Animal
Buy: $19.79
Buy: $75.00
SQUISHMALLOWS SALLY JACK ZERO Nightmare Before Christmas SET 8 inch Lot 3 Nwt
Buy: $75.00
Buy: $49.00
Lot of 4 Squishmallows 8" Nightmare Before Christmas Grace ,Bella,Frankie,Paige
Buy: $49.00
Buy: $30.00
Lock Nightmare Before Christmas 12" Squishmallow ♡ BNWT Rare Disney
Buy: $30.00
Buy: $49.99
Squishmallow Zero The Ghost Dog 12" NWT Nightmare Before Christmas Plush Rare
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $14.95
IT Chapter Two: Playing Card Tin Set
Buy: $14.95
Buy: $42.00
SQUISHMALLOWS SALLY JACK ZERO Nightmare Before Christmas SET 6” Lot 3 Nwt
Buy: $42.00
Buy: $55.00
Squishmallow Zero Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Plush 8" Rare Limited NWT
Buy: $55.00
Buy: $75.00
Squishmallows 5” Nightmare Before Christmas Set Lot Of 5 Jack Sally Zero Oogies
Buy: $75.00
Buy: $18.99
Christmas Noah bear Chocolate 12"
Buy: $18.99
Buy: $12.99
Squishmallows Squooshems Classic Squad 2”Fidget Toys 1x Mystery Blind Bag
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $115.00
Disney Store Nightmare Before Christmas NBC Beanie Plush Lot 7 Unopened Packages
Buy: $115.00
Buy: $13.94
IT Chapter Two: Playing Card Tin Set 3c4
Buy: $13.94
Buy: $20.00
Jack Skellington Nightmare Before Christmas 5" Squishmallow BNWT Rare Disney
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $35.00
NEW RELEASE Squishmallows 12" Hug Mees Paislee the PandaCorn Christmas 2021 NEW
Buy: $35.00
Buy: $30.49
Something Wild! Nightmare Before Christmas Card Game & Outdoor Wristband Lot
Buy: $30.49
Buy: $10.00
Mattel Apples to Apples Dice Game in a Can - 3-6 Players Ages 8+ Complete
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $48.95
RARE 5” Nightmare Before Christmas Green “Oogie Boogie” Squishmallow Plush! 🎃👻
Buy: $48.95
Buy: $14.95
Kellytoy Squishmallows 3" Len Clip-On Frankenstein Bear Halloween
Buy: $14.95
Buy: $8.99
PEACEABLE KINGDOM~Hoot Owl Hoot! Board Game Cooperative 4+ 2-4 Players Complete
Buy: $8.99
Buy: $89.95
48" The Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington Sandy Clause Jumbo Plush Lot
Buy: $89.95
Buy: $44.80
Disney Nightmare Before Christmas 16” Jack Skellington & Sally Plush (Lot of 2)
Buy: $44.80
Buy: $27.99
Squishmallow Halloween LOT OF 2 NBC Jack Skellington 8" XIOMARA Leopard 8" NWT!
Buy: $27.99
Buy: $25.99
TY Beanie Kids Collection: Boomer/Princess / Dazzlin rare plush baby Toy
Buy: $25.99
Buy: $50.00
nightmare before christmas barrel yoyo Vintage
Buy: $50.00
Buy: $49.95
Monopoly The Nightmare Before Christmas Bonus Token Board Game (2015) COMPLETE
Buy: $49.95
Buy: $49.99
RADICA 2001 Crossword Challenger II Handheld Electronic Game Model 72050
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $17.99
TY Beanie Kids Collection: Ginger/Cookie (1992 - 1995 ) rare plush baby Toy
Buy: $17.99
Buy: $229.95
Monopoly - Seattle Seahawks Collector's Edition
Buy: $229.95
Buy: $33.59
Lot 3 Squishmallow Kellytoy Nightmare Before Christmas Jack , Zero & Oogie 8”
Buy: $33.59
Buy: $10.39
2011 Mattel Apples to Apples Dice Game in a Can Complete BRAND NEW SEALED
Buy: $10.39
Buy: $29.99
Funko Pop Nightmare Before Christmas Plush Jack Skellington & Sally Lot
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $40.83
20mm Mini Travel Mahjong Set with Majiang Table Travel Board Game Chinese Tradi
Buy: $40.83
Buy: $35.00
Vintage Christmas Rag Doll Dressed for the Season by Dan Dee 28 in
Buy: $35.00
Buy: $19.50
NEW! Nightmare Before Christmas Sally Squishmallow 6” Rare!! 🔥
Buy: $19.50
Buy: $58.03
Squishmallow 14" ZERO the GHOST DOG NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS NWT VERY RARE NEW
Buy: $58.03
Buy: $399.00
Squishmallows Nightmare Before Christmas 12-14"LOT of 8 JACK SALLY MAYOR OOGIE+!
Buy: $399.00
Buy: $74.99
The Nightmare Before Christmas Jenga Collectors Edition Complete 2009 Tim Burton
Buy: $74.99
Buy: $39.99
2004 Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Board Game , Near Mint Complete
Buy: $39.99
Buy: $12.99
Peaceable Kingdom Hoot Owl Award Winning Cooperative Game 100% Complete
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $19.95
NEW! Nightmare Before Christmas Sally Squishmallow 6” Rare!! 🔥
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $50.00
Zero Disney Nightmare Before Christmas Plush Squishmallow 8 Inch Rare HTF 8 Inch
Buy: $50.00
Buy: $19.95
Nightmare Before Christmas RARE NWT 5” Jack Skellington Kellytoy Squishmallow
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $335.00
Nightmare Before Christmas LARGE AND MEDIUM Squishmallow *SET* RARE
Buy: $335.00