NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
First & Main 18" Fanta Sasha Seahorse w/ flower GLASS Glitter Eyes Sparkles
Buy: $20.90
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear 12" Plush 2615 Baby Blue Shaggy Fur Sewn Eyes
Buy: $13.49
12" Vtg Chumley Plush Brown Sitting Bear Stuffed Animal Toy Leather Feet Ears
Buy: $69.00
Vintage First & Main Zooglies Tiger Soft Plush Jointed Posable Arms & Legs
Buy: $18.25
Plush Bear  "Tender Teddy" Brown w/ Patch Heart Cuddle Soft 14” Valentines
Buy: $5.95
First & Main 12" Plush Pot Belly Teddy Bear "Elliot" Floppy Stuffed Animal Brown
Buy: $13.50
Teddy Bear Plush First & Main Dean #1796 Stuffed Animal 11" Striped Bow
Buy: $14.04
First & Main Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 10.5" Standing
Buy: $12.97
READ NOTES First & Main Koby Bear 13” New Stuffed Animal
Buy: $11.49
NWT First & Main Western Horse Rough Wrangler 16" Stuffed Weighted Plush Animal
Buy: $7.93
First & Main Luv Ya Bear 7 inch Plush Stuffed Teddy Purple Heart Valentine v2104
Buy: $15.75
First & Main Benjamin Teddy Bear Plush 11” Brown Stuffed Animal Bow #1754
Buy: $11.05
1990s First & Main RINGO RACCOON 12" Plush Vintage Stuffed Toy Gray White H3
Buy: $25.97
First & Main HUGSIE BEAR Valentine Teddy 10" Cream Beige Plush-SO CUTE! NWT
Buy: $17.99
BLITZEN the Adorable Gold White Deer Bear Plush💛 First & Main Co Stuffed Animal
Buy: $15.00
First & Main Cream Plush Teddy Bear Angel Huggums Collectible 1302 6” Rose Wings
Buy: $15.00
First & Main Black Lab Labrador Plush Dog Puppy #3611 LOT of 2 EUC
Buy: $19.99
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Patchwork Heart Plush Stuffed Animal Tan Brown
Buy: $13.65
First And Main Bailey Bear Plush Gal Pals Stuffed Animal Toy Blue Teddy 7" 2017
Buy: $12.00
Sloth Stuffed Animal  Plush Toy Soft Brown Fur 7" First & Main Three Toed Small
Buy: $18.99
First and Main Tan Teddy Bear Dinky Plush Stuffed Animal NWT Red Bow
Buy: $9.99
 Stuffed Animal Zena Zebra  First Main  8345  Zena Zebra 10"
Buy: $13.59
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Beige Heart 10”
Buy: $12.50
Santa Bear Plush First & Main 15" Kris Kringle Christmas Magic Stuffed Animal
Buy: $6.99
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear #1415 Red 12” Plaid Heart Stuffed Plush Soft Toy
Buy: $12.99
Zooglies First & Main Jointed Plush Tiger Striped Red And Black Pre Owned
Buy: $23.49
First and Main Sherbet Purple Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Lace Paws 12"
Buy: $10.00
Vintage First & Main Menagerie 6" Coco the  Gorilla Stuffed Animal Plush Toy
Buy: $12.00
First & Main #1796 Dean TEDDY BEAR Stuffed Animal 16" Plush Toy w/Green Scarf
Buy: $19.99
First & Main Christmas "Minky" Bundle of Three Plush Collectible Teddy Bears
Buy: $23.18
First & Main Baby Sweetness Pink Bear Plush #2000 Pink Bow 8.5 in Cute Snuggly
Buy: $9.99
First & Main Bounce Back Jack Bear Plush Get Well Soon Robe Dog Stuffed Animal 1
Buy: $10.00
First & Main Bailey Teddy Bear #1372 Soft Toy Plush Stuffed Animal Cream 5”
Buy: $8.25
First & Main Valentino Jr 9” Gorilla Realistic Black Furry Plush Stuffed Rose
Buy: $14.45
First And Main Blythe Teddy Bear Plush Heart Shirt 11 In
Buy: $12.00
First and Main Teddy Bear Edgar B Evergreen 11" Plush with Green Hat & Vest
Buy: $12.60
NEW with Tag - Plush Stuffed 11" Gray Elephant (Slowpoke) by First & Main 1002F
Buy: $9.95
First & Main Stripes Tabby Cat Black Gray Plush Holding Rose Stuffed Animal 7.5"
Buy: $15.74
First & Main Blue Babykins Sitting Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed
Buy: $13.99
First Main Plush Teddy Bear Sleepyhead Biff XS4205
Buy: $12.50
Rainbow Happy Birthday Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Doll First & Main 8" Colorful
Buy: $10.99
Rare First & Main "Scraggles" Sitting White Teddy Bear w/Pampered Chef Apron
Buy: $5.00
First & Main Patchwork Petey Bear Plush 8" Sitting Teddy Stuffed Toy New w/ Tag
Buy: $15.29
FantaZoo Sloth By First & Main, Purple, 7" Sitting, Brand New
Buy: $9.99
First and Main Black Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Teddy Toy
Buy: $11.55
First & Main Ebony Black Bear Stuffed Plush Animal Long Legs
Buy: $15.00
First & Main Tender Teddy Plush Brown Patchwork Bear Stuffed Animal w/Shirt 12"
Buy: $15.18
First & Main 9" White Teddy Bear With Green Bow Marked Lil' Scraggles #1863
Buy: $12.00
"Toodles" Plush Bear Tan Holding A Red Heart With Wings 10" Tags
Buy: $13.99
First & Main Lil' Scraggles Teddy Bear Tan 10" Animal Stuffed Plush Toy
Buy: $14.99
First & Main Angel Bear Brown White Wings #1304 11" Plush Stuffed Animal
Buy: $12.60
NEW First & Main Plush Tan Minky Teddy Bear PLUSH 9" Corduroy Paws Suede Tie
Buy: $12.99
NEW FIRST & MAIN #1955 JETHRO Plaid Bow Tan Soft Fuzzy Bear 13" Bean Plush Tags
Buy: $17.95
Get Well Plush Dog First & Main 15” Stuffed Animal
Buy: $14.25
MACABEE 8" Bear  Bow Tie Stuffed Animal RARE
Buy: $35.95
NEW First & Main Soft Brown 10" MAC Teddy Bear Beanbag Plush Toy
Buy: $12.00
First & Main Baby Chumley Brown Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed 8” VinylFeetEars Beanie
Buy: $19.99
Vintage First Main Plush Rainbow Bear Orange 6" with Original Tag
Buy: $9.50
Schnookums Sitting White Teddy Bear First & Main Pink Bow Polar Furry 11" shaggy
Buy: $13.45
First & Main Sorbet Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Multicolor Pastel Rainbow
Buy: $16.85
First & Main Tickled Pink Plush teddy bear 15” Lovey Stitched Eyes
Buy: $15.20
Plush First & Main Yellow Rainbow Bear Assortment 7”x6.5”x3” #1462
Buy: $11.19
*RARE* FROGGLE WOGGLE "VALENTINES HEART" PLUSH STUFFED FIRST MAIN ~ NEW NWT
Buy: $21.99
First & Main Baby Girl Boy Pink Rainbow Pastel Blue Teddy Bear Plush Set Tags 6"
Buy: $21.99
First & Main Mac Brown Tan Teddy Bear Plush Stitched Ears Feet Blue Bow w/ Tags
Buy: $13.59
First & Main Prayer Bear Pink White Plush Soft Toy 11"  Stuffed Teddy PJs
Buy: $15.25
First Main Angel Bear Plush 11" 1304 Wing Sitting Guardian Toy Girl Women Pink
Buy: $17.84
First & Main Red Tender Teddy Plush Bear Stuffed Toy
Buy: $19.99
First Main Blue Teddy Bear Plush with Embroidered Heart Stuffed Animal Soft Toy
Buy: $12.00
First & Main Rainbow Bear, Green, 6.5" Tall, Brand New with Tag
Buy: $8.99
First & Main 13" Melancholy Melanie Puppy Dog, Multicolor
Buy: $12.99
First & Main Rainbow Bear 7” Yellow Plush Stuffed Animal Toy with Bow & Hang Tag
Buy: $14.99
First & Main 12” Plush Wizard Baby Doll Hocus Pocus Sewn Eyes Trick Or Treat
Buy: $14.99
Vintage First & Main Rainbow Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Purple Collectible
Buy: $15.00
First and Main Sullivan #6223 10" Monkey Plush Stuffed Animal
Buy: $14.00
First & Main Tucker Brown Teddy Bear W/Red Bow Plush/Stuffed New With Tags #1715
Buy: $17.87
First & Main Teddy Bear 10 in Plush Be Mine Berries N Cream Valentine v1224
Buy: $14.95
FIRST & MAIN TENDER TEDDY Tan Brown Heart Patch Bear Plush Red Ribbon EUC
Buy: $12.00
First & Main Bumbley Bear, Brownish Gray, 9" Tall, Brand New
Buy: $10.99
12" FIRST & MAIN TENDER Freddie Teddy BEAR Green HEART Tan STUFFED Brown PLUSH
Buy: $9.56
NWT WHITE PLUSH BEAR LIL' DENA RED HEART I LOVE YOU STITCHED EYES, NOSE & MOUTH
Buy: $12.99
First & Main Lil Scraggles Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Teddy Fuzzy No. 1923
Buy: $10.00
My First Christmas 2000 Blue Pink Moose Plush Main Joy Rattle Inside
Buy: $20.00
FIRST & MAIN GUARDIAN ANGELS BABY TEDDY BEAR STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY NEW W TAG
Buy: $45.00
First & Main Skeeter Winter Bear White Red Scarf Plush Soft Toy 17" Stuffed
Buy: $22.49
First & Main Gal Pals Ella Elephant, Green, 8" Sitting, Brand New
Buy: $14.99
First & Main Tiger Cub Sleepurrr  #6593- Voice Box Does Work
Buy: $10.00
13” First & Main Valentino Gorilla Realistic Black Furry Plush Stuffed Bow Rose
Buy: $16.49
First & Main Hugh Ewe Super Soft Floppy Stuffed Lamb Easter
Buy: $17.99
First & Main Bear Plush Named Smedley 12"
Buy: $10.00
First & Main Sit Ups Gray Elephant Plush #2272 Vintage EUC
Buy: $17.99
Plush Dear LTD Edition FIRST & MAIN CLASSIC "EDITH" 2N nice
Buy: $18.95
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear Plush Stuffed Animal Brown Red Plaid Heart 12”
Buy: $14.50
First & Main Tender Teddy Bear 10" Plush 2615 Baby Blue Shaggy Fur Sewn Eyes
Buy: $13.88
First & Main Brown Bear Witherspoon 1965 Plush Stuffed Fluffy Weighted 16.5”
Buy: $15.00
First & Main FantaZoo Elephant, 10" Sitting, Neon Orange, Brand New
Buy: $19.99
First Main Xmas Minky Bear XS1502 8 Inch Stuffed Animal Vest Christmas Hat
Buy: $6.25
6" Vintage First & Main BLUE Rainbow Bear #1362 BRAND NEW Ages 3+ NWT
Buy: $14.95
First & Main Plush Cream Lela Lamb Curly Fur Blue Eyes Stuffed Animal 10 Inch
Buy: $18.00
Rare VTG First & Main Knot Knee 15” Burgess Gray Hippo Soft Floppy Bean Plush
Buy: $49.00