NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Carter's PRINCESS DOLL 12" Plush Toy with Blonde Hair and Blue Dress 0 Months +
Buy: $19.99
Carters Golden Retriever Lab Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Beige White 2018 7"
Buy: $26.32
Carters Just One Year Lovey Security Plush Baby Doll Pink Green Stripe Blonde
Buy: $48.99
NWT Carter's Just One You Baby AVOCADO Plush Beanbag Toy Kids 2023 China
Buy: $9.99
Carters Child of Mine Musical Gray Elephant Plush Wind Up Stuffed Animal Lullaby
Buy: $5.99
NEW With Tags Carters White Musical Sheep Lamb Blue Stars Head Moves Baby Lovey
Buy: $9.99
Carters Curly Soft Brown Baby Teddy Bear Red Bow 16" Plush Stuffed Animal
Buy: $16.15
Carters Pink White Brown Bow Laying Down Sheep Lamb Plush Soft Toy 398019
Buy: $44.99
Vtg 1999 Carters & Yoko Ono Lennon Pajama Bunny Rabbit Rattle Lovey Plush
Buy: $48.00
Carters Gray Donkey Baby Plush Soft Stuffed Animal Toy  7” tall 2016 Embroidered
Buy: $14.50
HTF Carter's 12"×12" Aqua Blue White Owl Security Blanket Lovey Baby 2016
Buy: $44.95
Carter's Sleeping Lady Bug Plush Toy 10" 2019 Great Condition
Buy: $19.99
Carters Just One Year Yellow Blue Musical Plush Crib Pull Toy Dots Spots
Buy: $26.99
Child of Mine Carters Lovey Security Plush Dinosaur Spot Green Blue NO MUSIC
Buy: $18.99
Carter's Child of Mine Backpack Monkey 9" Plush Soft Toy Stuffed Animal Musical
Buy: $16.99
Carters Owl Lovey Rattle Dark Blue 14" Square Silky Satin Blanket Toy
Buy: $18.00
A121 Carters White Gray Patches Bunny Plush 10" Stuffed Toy Lovey
Buy: $9.88
Carter's Gray Elephant Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Touch Lovey
Buy: $14.50
Just For You Carters puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal
Buy: $10.00
Carters Just One Year Brown Tan Beige Teddy Bear Plush Yellow Bow 13"
Buy: $22.39
Carter's Plush Rattle Hungry Caterpillar Stuffed Animal Eric Carle Sewn Eyes Vtg
Buy: $11.99
Carters Starters Baby Boy Blue Stuffed Plush Puppy Dog Beanbag Toy Spot Friends
Buy: $38.24
Carters Monkey Plush 13" 66987 Tan Brown Stuffed Animal Lovey 2016 NWT
Buy: $44.99
Vintage Carters Prestige My Best Friend Waffle Thermal Rattle Plush Puppy Dog TW
Buy: $54.99
Carters John Lennon Vintage Purple Rhino Rhinoceros Stuffed Plush Baby Rattle To
Buy: $9.99
Carter's Baby Bunny Plush Pink Wearing Sleeper + Slippers 13" Doll -Rattle Sound
Buy: $19.95
Carters Red White Hearts Blond Doll Rattle Plush Soft Toy Stuffed 2012 Soft Toy
Buy: $17.59
Carters Gray White Panda Bear Plush Baby Lovey Security Blanket Cuddle Teddy 14"
Buy: $24.99
Carters Plush Whale Baby Rattle Crinkle Fins Stuffed Animal Toy Stripe bottom 9"
Buy: $15.00
8" Carters Plush pull string Girl - Tested Works - FREE shipping
Buy: $15.99
Yellow Rubber Duck 3.5 in Height CARTER'S 2001 Kids II Toy SL1
Buy: $19.73
Carters Moose Plush Brown Stuffed Animal Lovey Toy
Buy: $16.07
Vintage Carters Tiny Little Bee Wrist Rattle Baby Infant Toy Reborn Doll Blue
Buy: $19.99
Carters John Lennon Vtg  Purple Rhino Rhinoceros Stuffed Plush Baby Rattle Toy
Buy: $14.99
Carter's Gray Elephant Lovey Security Blanket 2020
Buy: $18.99
Carters Shake and Jingle Stuffed Plush Pink Orange Inchworm Worm Caterpillar Bug
Buy: $23.79
Carters Pink Unicorn Plush Soft Toy Stuffed 12" 2017 Animal White
Buy: $10.80
Just One You Carters 10" Gray Koala Bear Stuffed Animal 2020 Plush
Buy: $19.99
11" CARTER'S 2014 BABY PINK MOUSE STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY # 66740 SOFT
Buy: $39.00
Carters Seahorse Plush Stuffed Animal Pink Sea Creature 10” Sewn Eyes
Buy: $19.99
Carters Yellow Duck Chick with Duck Chick Feet - Plush - by Prestige Toy - plush
Buy: $17.99
Carter's Just One You Musical Green Dinosaur Twinkle Twinkle Little Star #67969
Buy: $24.99
Carters White Pink Unicorn Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Toy 16" 2017 67263
Buy: $16.99
Carter's Mermaid Activity Toy
Buy: $3.99
Carters Popsicle Plush Ice Cream Stick Green Yellow Pink Stuffed Anthropomorphic
Buy: $12.95
Carters Child of Mine Kitty Cat Musical Animated Plush Stuffed Animal Pink
Buy: $19.99
Carter's Green Dinosaur Soft Plush Green With Light Gray Stuffed Animal 10"
Buy: $15.18
Carters Green Baby Alligator 2018 Plush Stuffed Animal 11” Floppy Arms & Legs
Buy: $9.50
A162 Carters White Lamb Blanket 2016 Plush 14" Stuffed Toy Lovey
Buy: $18.88
Carters vintage My First Duck rattle plush baby toy yellow blue dots 8"
Buy: $70.00
Carter's My Little Angel Pink Baby Girl Musical Plush String Brahms' Lullaby
Buy: $11.99
Carters Thank Heaven For Little Babies Baby Duck Rattle Plush 9" Pacifier NEW
Buy: $69.99
Carters Just One You Green Dinosaur Dino Plush Baby Toy Stuffed Animal 67840
Buy: $22.49
Carters Just One You Plush Green DINOSAUR Corduroy Lovey #68163 Target NEW
Buy: $33.99
Carter's Baby Dinosaur Plush Mint Green Aqua White 60115
Buy: $14.99
Carters Pink Gray Poodle Puppy Dog Plush Soft Toy Stuffed Animal 9" 2014
Buy: $16.14
Carters Just One Year Baby Cuddles Puppy Dog blue robe plush Duck
Buy: $16.99
Carter's Child Of Mine Stars Puppy Dog Security Blanket Lovey Navy Blue Rattle
Buy: $10.80
Carters 2013 Child of Mine Plush Mini Brown 8 IN Rattle Monkey 62075 Stuffed Toy
Buy: $16.00
Carter's Child Of Mine Blue Plush Rattle Brown Bear Minky Security Blanket Lovey
Buy: $14.99
Carters Blue Stripes Elephant Plush Rattle Soft Toy 10" 2013 Stuffed Animal
Buy: $16.99
Carter's Plush Avocado Just One You Lovey Toy Stuffed 10” Baby Toy Tags
Buy: $19.99
Carters Brown Orange Giraffe Plush Rattle Teether Crinkle Squeaker Soft Toy
Buy: $17.59
Carter’s Child Of Mine Brown Monkey Rattle Plush Lovey Stuffed 8” Tan Belly
Buy: $19.99
Carters Child of Mine Musical Gray Elephant Plush Wind Up Stuffed Animal 2021
Buy: $17.95
Carters Just One Year Brown Monkey Tan Tummy Plush 11" Stuffed Animal Toy 92914
Buy: $17.99
RARE Carters John Lennon Blue Elephant 6" Lovey Rattle Plush Yellow Feet Vintage
Buy: $39.95
CARTER'S Kitty Cat MY FIRST HALLOWEEN Purple Orange Black Hat 8.5" Rattle Plush
Buy: $11.66
Child Of Mine Tan Brown Monkey Plush Rattle Soft Toy Stuffed Animal 8" 62075
Buy: $23.96
Carters Just One You Sheepdog Puppy 6” Plush 2019 White And Gray
Buy: $10.99
Carters Just One You Dog Plush Wind Up Musical Stuffed Animal
Buy: $21.99
A162 Carters Unicorn Pony White Pink Silver Plush 11" Stuffed Toy Lovey
Buy: $12.88
Carters Just One You Gray Lion Plush  Baby Toy Stuffed Animal 9" 2019 Lovey
Buy: $9.95
Carters Tan Brown Plush Teddy Bear Baby Ribbon Toy Plush Baby Toy Small Lovey
Buy: $11.98
Carters Corduroy Dinosaur Ribbed Green Stuffed Animal Dino Plush Baby Toy 2019
Buy: $19.95
Vintage 2001 Carter's John Lennon Yoko Ono Baby Toy Rattle Pink Elephant Plush
Buy: $39.99
Carter's Heart Polka Dot Pink Brown White Circle Plush Fleece Baby Blanket
Buy: $24.99
Carters Pink Bunny Rabbit Bean Bag Baby Toy Heart Flower Brown Stuffed Plush
Buy: $35.99
Carter's Child of Mine Bean Elephant Plush Floppy 12" Long Stuffed Animal toy
Buy: $10.87
Just One Year Musical Crib Pull Toy Baby Bug Insect Dragonfly Blue Yellow Green
Buy: $20.80
Carters Child Of Mine Yellow Giraffe Baby wind up musical lullaby
Buy: $18.99
Carters Musical Wind Up Stuffed Plush Pink Elephant Gray Star Lullaby Waggy Toy
Buy: $39.99
Carter's  Plush Giraffe,Plays Brahms Lullaby and Moves
Buy: $13.95
Just one Year Musical Wind Up Blue Green Polka Dot Dog Bear Plush w/Tags
Buy: $24.95
Vintage Carters John Lennon Stuffed Plush Pink Elephant Baby Toy Small Mini 5"
Buy: $29.74
CARTER'S PRESTIGE WHITE BUNNY RABBIT RATTLE BLUE STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY LOVEY
Buy: $22.49
Carters John Lennon White/Ivory Stuffed Plush Bunny Rabbit Pink Sun Squeak
Buy: $29.33
🏝️ Carters Plush White Swan Bird Gold Princess Crown Baby
Buy: $14.99
Carter's Super Soft Lion Plush Baby Stuffed Animal Sewn Eyes
Buy: $16.10
Carters Pink White Striped Bunny Rabbit Plush Heart Baby Teal Teether Musical 8"
Buy: $13.45
Carter's Bunches Of Love Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Purple Sweet Baby
Buy: $39.99
Carters Just One You Giraffe Brown Blue Star 9" Plush Stuffed Lovey Toy Rattle
Buy: $9.97
NWT Carter's John Lennon Elephant Pink Plush Rattle Wearing PJ's RARE Vintage
Buy: $67.99
Carter's Fox Plush #68123 Pink White 2021 Lovey Stuffed Animal Soft Toy
Buy: $33.74
Carters Poseable Velour Stripe Frog Rattle Plush Soft Toy Stuffed  10"
Buy: $16.96
CARTER'S MY FIRST BABY DOLL BLONDE Hair Blue Eyes Pink PLUSH RATTLE TOY Lovey
Buy: $26.43
Carters Just One You Gray Koala Bear Stuffed Animal Plush No Tag EUC
Buy: $13.00
Carters Sheep Lamb Plush White Musical Green Stars 2015 Head Moves Lovey NWT
Buy: $23.99
Carter's Emu Namae Orange Green Purple Lion Plush Musical Crib Pull Baby Toy
Buy: $31.90
CARTER'S Red Hippo Swim Inner Tube ANIMAL PLUSH TOY Vintage Carters HTF RARE
Buy: $39.99