NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage Caltoy Reindeer Hand Puppet 9" Tan Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $12.99
HIPPO GREY STUFFED ANIMAL11" CALTOY HIPPOPOTOMOS PINK EARS NOSE
Buy: $16.50
Goldfish Orange Blue Fish Hand Puppet Full Body Plush Tropical Lot Of 2 Caltoy
Buy: $18.00
Lot of  5 Caltoy Hand Puppets Animals Toucan Alligator Lion Skunk Fox
Buy: $40.00
Hand Puppets Caltoy Big Eyed Flying Insect Plush Pretend Play Toy Ant Beetle?
Buy: $12.88
Caltoy Fish Plush Hand Puppet Children's Ocean Pretend Play Sea Purple Green
Buy: $9.50
Caltoy 2 Hand Puppets Giraffe Chamelion Lizard Gecko Plush Storytime
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Dinosaur Pterodactyl Triceratops Gecko Reptile Fun Hand Puppets Lot of 4
Buy: $28.50
Caltoy Beaver Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Pretend Play 9.5" Long
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Hand Puppet Plush Lot Set Reptiles 2 Lizard Red Brown & Green Frog P59
Buy: $17.50
CALTOY Yellow Seahorse & DREAM Green Sea Turtle Plush Hand Glove Puppet Lot
Buy: $16.99
Caltoy American Bald Eagle Full Body Brown White Hand Glove Puppet Preschool
Buy: $8.00
Caltoy Plush Full Body Hand Puppet 16” Black Scorpion & Brown Spider Tarantula 
Buy: $21.99
Caltoy SNOW LEOPARD Glove Hand Puppet Plush Cat Teachers Preschool
Buy: $15.83
Caltoy Triceratops & Trex Knit Dinosaur Nursery Plush Stuffed Animal Lovey Toys
Buy: $17.95
Caltoy Gray Dinosaur hand puppet soft Plush 14” Golf Club Iron Head Cover
Buy: $14.25
CALTOY CUTE ELEPHANT HAND PUPPET 11” PLUSH (ML780)
Buy: $11.23
PLUSH HAND PUPPETS-DINOSAURS-GREEN TURTLE-TRICERATOP-T REX-LIZARDS-REPTILES-LOT
Buy: $28.99
Caltoy Hand Puppet Plush Lot Set FARM Animals Pig Rooster  Cow Sheep P26
Buy: $24.95
Cow & Giraffe 9" Hand Puppets by Caltoy Set of 2 Fleece Plush
Buy: $19.99
SKUNK CALTOY Hand Puppet 14” (includes tail)
Buy: $11.99
PLUSH Hand Puppets SKUNK-FOX-WALRUS-FULL BODY-TEACHERS STORYTIME-CALTOY-LOT-3
Buy: $23.50
Lot of 3 CALTOY Puppets Dinosaurs Plush Toy Pterodactyl Triceratops STEGOSAURUS
Buy: $14.95
Caltoy Green Turtle Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Play 10"  NEW
Buy: $13.00
PLUSH HAND PUPPETS FULL BODY-WHITE POLAR BEAR-GIRAFFE-DEER/MOOSE-ANIMAL LOT-3
Buy: $23.50
Caltoy & Beleduc Plush Dinosaur Brontosaurus Glove Hand Puppets Lot Of 2
Buy: $15.99
Caltoy Lizard Plush Hand Puppet Green Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $12.74
CALTOY PLUSH HAND PUPPET  White Polar Bear - Soft and Cuddly
Buy: $8.00
Caltoy 10" Horse Plush Hand Puppet
Buy: $10.50
Vintage Frog and Prince Reversible Puppet Caltoy Inc Princess and the Frog EUC
Buy: $29.97
PLUSH HAND PUPPET-FULL BODY-HORSE-CALTOY SOFT FARM ANIMAL
Buy: $14.99
CALTOY Orange Fish Goldfish & Parrot Bird Hand Puppet Plush Lot
Buy: $22.99
Caltoy HAND PUPPET COW Plush 10" Black and White Adorable Cow Plush Puppet
Buy: $13.99
Hand Glove Puppet ~ ELEPHANT ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 11" ~ NEW ~
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Dragonfly Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Plush
Buy: $15.00
Caltoy Seagull Pelican Plush Puppet Golf Club Cover Nautical Black White Bird
Buy: $15.99
2 Caltoy Plush Hand Puppets Black Bear & Eagle
Buy: $24.00
Caltoy Dinosaur Pterodactyl Hand Puppet Golf Club Iron Head Cover Free Shipping
Buy: $10.50
Caltoy DEER Glove Hand Puppet Plush Teachers Preschool Stuffed Toy H7
Buy: $12.97
Caltoy White KITTY CAT Glove Hand Puppet Plush Teachers Preschool Shaggy Stuffed
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Glove Hand Puppets Insect Alligator Dinosaur Stuffed Animals Lot of 3
Buy: $25.50
Caltoy Dinosaur Reptile Hand Puppet Bundle Set of 3
Buy: $19.99
Caltoy Donkey Plush Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal Toy with Big Eyes Pretend Play
Buy: $13.95
Hand / Glove Puppet ~ STRIPED FISH ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 11" ~ NEW
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Fox Plush Glove or Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal EUC
Buy: $10.00
Caltoy Hand Glove Plush Puppets Black Fly & Brown Spider Insect Arachnid Lot
Buy: $24.99
Caltoy Dream Hand Puppet Plush Lot Set Dinosaurs Blue Orange Triceratops P35
Buy: $12.95
Caltoy Hand Puppet Plush Lot Set ZOO Safari Animals Zebra Hippo Lion P73
Buy: $37.74
PLUSH HAND PUPPETS-OCTOPUS-CRAB-WHALE-SAND SHARK-TEACHERS AID-SEA LIFE-4
Buy: $31.50
CUTE MOOSE 10” HAND PUPPET PLUSH CALTOYS (ML480)
Buy: $12.23
Bumble Bee Hand Puppet By Caltoy
Buy: $8.00
Plush Hand puppets-Orca whale/squeaker-Caterpillar bug-Alligator-Octopus-LOT
Buy: $24.50
Caltoy Hand Puppet Polar Bear Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Toy 10”
Buy: $11.99
Caltoy Owl Hand Puppet Golf Club Cover Stuffed Animal Plush 12”
Buy: $16.99
CALTOY 10” BROWN MONKEY SOFT HAND PUPPET PLUSH (ML412)
Buy: $11.23
Vintage Frog & Prince Reversible Puppet Caltoy Inc Princess and the Frog w/ Tag
Buy: $15.99
Caltoy HIPPO Glove Hand Puppet Plush Gray Pink Nostrils Big Eyes 9"
Buy: $10.20
Caltoy - Black - Spider - Plush Hand Puppet
Buy: $12.50
Glove / Hand Puppet ~ Brown HORSE  ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 12" ~ NEW
Buy: $14.99
PLUSH HAND PUPPETS FULL BODY-PORCUPINE-BROWN BEAR-GIRAFFE-DEER/MOOSE-ANIMAL LOT
Buy: $25.50
Puppet Farm Animals Hand Puppets Plush X 3
Buy: $30.00
Caltoy Lion Full Body Hand Puppet Orange Brown White 2000 See VIDEO
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Frog and Giraffe  Plush Glove Hand Puppets Stuffed Animal Ex.Co.
Buy: $15.00
Pegasus Caltoy Lavender Sparkly Wings Glove Hand Puppet Plush 10" long
Buy: $13.75
Caltoy Horse Pony Full Body Hand Puppet Brown 10" EUC
Buy: $14.99
Playful Pals Push Hand Puppet Lion 10" Full Body Vintage Mervin's Exclusive
Buy: $15.82
Caltoy Giraffe Big-Eyed Glove Hand Puppet Plush Teachers Preschool 9" Long
Buy: $8.48
Rhinoceros Caltoy Hand Puppet Plush Gray Stuffed Animal Rhino
Buy: $15.00
Lot of 2 Caltoy Plush Dinosaur Hand Puppet Triceratops Pterodactyl 12" Green Red
Buy: $19.99
Caltoy LAMB Sheep Glove Hand Puppet Cream ivory Plush Big Eyes Stuffed Black
Buy: $24.99
Caltoy Nemo Clown Fish Plush Glove Hand Puppet Stuffed Animal  Preschool 10"
Buy: $14.95
CALTOY Orange Fish Goldfish Hand Puppet Full Body Plush Shimmer Fin
Buy: $14.95
Hand/Glove Puppet ~ Purple PEGASUS ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 12" ~ NEW ~
Buy: $14.99
Caltoy Green Brown Lizard Dino Plush Puppet Golf Club Cover 13"
Buy: $13.99
Caltoy Green Dragon Dinosaur Hand Puppet 13” Long Stegosaurus Plush Soft
Buy: $16.99
CALTOY~Hand Puppet~BROWN DINOSAUR~Big Cute Eyes
Buy: $12.56
Caltoy Hand Puppets Giraffe & Monkey Plush Lot Of 2 FAST SHIPPING
Buy: $16.99
Caltoy Preston Pig Hand Puppet (J7)
Buy: $25.99
Caltoy Bird Hand Glove Puppet Lot of 3 Flamingo, Eagle, Peacock
Buy: $28.56
Dragon Caltoy Orange Blue Sparkly Wings Glove Hand Puppet Plush 13" long
Buy: $13.75
Caltoy Vibrant Dinosaur Hand Puppet Plush Yellow Orange
Buy: $12.95
PLUSH HAND PUPPETS-DINOSAURS-RED PARROT-TRICERATOPS-T REX-LIZARDS-REPTILES-LOT
Buy: $28.99
RARE LIFELIKE CALTOY  PLUSH ORANGE & PURPLE HAND PUPPETS EXCELLENT FISH
Buy: $28.00
REALITIC LIFELIKE CALTOY PLUSH DOLL FIGURE RED MACAW PARROT PUPPET TOY
Buy: $14.40
6" Peeper Big Eyes Golden Lab Bean Plush Puppy Dog w/ Eyelashes by Caltoy
Buy: $7.56
Caltoy Dinosaur Pterodactyl Hand Puppet 010523
Buy: $9.95
Caltoy Hand Puppet Triceratops Green Orange Dinosaur Plush Stuffed Animal B25
Buy: $15.99
Caltoy Plush Hand Puppets Lot Of 4 Sealife Ocean Seahorse Dolphin Seal Starfish
Buy: $34.90
Caltoy Ladybug Hand Puppet Pretend Play Teachers Aid Animal Toy
Buy: $15.99
Caltoy Plush Elephant Hand Puppet Gray Pretend Play Stuffed Toy. Preowned.
Buy: $10.00
Lot of 4 Caltoy Hand Puppets Plush Pink Pig Sheep Chicken Tan Dog Farm Animals
Buy: $23.96
Caltoy Cow Plush Hand Puppet Farm Animal - Teacher / Preschool
Buy: $6.99
Hand / Glove Puppet ~ Blue DINOSAUR ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 14" ~ NEW
Buy: $14.99
Hand / Glove Puppet ~ Orange DINOSAUR ~Plush~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 14" ~ NEW
Buy: $14.99
Lot 3 Caltoy FAO Hand Puppets Itsy Bitsy Spider, Fly Guy, Puff the Magic Dragon
Buy: $34.99
Hand / Glove Puppet ~ Brown DINOSAUR ~ Plush ~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 14" ~ NEW
Buy: $14.99
Hand/Glove Puppet ~ Triceratop DINOSAUR ~Plush~ CALTOY ~ Approximately 13" ~NEW
Buy: $14.99
CALTOY Hand Puppet Glove Pretend Play Iguana VGUC
Buy: $13.95
SET LOT 6 HAND PUPPETS BLUEBIRD CARDINAL COW DALMATIAN SNOWMAN IKEA CALTOY BOYDS
Buy: $21.24
SET LOT 5 HAND PUPPETS COW LADYBUG NOAHS NOAH'S ARK SHEEP LAMB POLAR BEAR
Buy: $15.29