NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
American Girl Doll Shining Star Ornament Swarovski Crystals New in Box GPW63
Buy: $29.92
Personalized American Girl Nicki Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
Personalized American Girl Gwen Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
Personalized American Girl Lanie Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
Vintage Pleasant Company American Girl Paper Star Pinata Ornament w/ Candy Treat
Buy: $30.00
NIB ~ American Girl 2021 Winter Princess Ornament ~ Holiday Christmas Collector
Buy: $16.00
Adorable American Girl Angel Halo Ceramic Porcelain Figurine // July 4th.
Buy: $11.99
American Girl CHRISTMAS ORNAMENTS lot x2 cute vintage used holiday tree Xmas OOP
Buy: $5.99
Hallmark AMERICAN GIRL Set of 4 Miniature KIT'S TREASURES Ornaments
Buy: $11.95
Elf On The Shelf Mini Plushee Pals Keychains Black African American Boy New
Buy: $12.99
Elf On The Shelf Mini Plushee Pals Keychains Black African American Girl Boy New
Buy: $19.96
“Felicity” American Girls Collection by Hallmark Keepsake Ornament
Buy: $16.99
Candy Cane Pen with Peppermint Scented Ink - Tub of 36 Pens
Buy: $43.58
Personalized American Girl Chrissa Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
American Girl Luciana Vega Personalized Christmas Ornament Gift
Buy: $34.95
Personalized American Girl Rebecca Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
Hallmark Keepsake American Girl 1944 Molly Ornament
Buy: $19.99
Hallmark AMERICAN GIRLS Kits Treasures Set of 4 Miniature Ornaments. NIB!
Buy: $15.00
ADDY An American Girl Collection Hallmark Keepsake Figurine Ornament - NIB
Buy: $16.99
Candy Cane Pen with Peppermint Scented Ink - Tub of 36 Pens
Buy: $51.99
African American Choir Girl (3032)
Buy: $25.00
American Girl Christmas Stocking "A Special American Girl" With 6 Charms
Buy: $38.99
American Girl Collection by Hallmark, 1934 Kit, Retired, Vintage, Handcrafted
Buy: $19.99
Personalized American Girl Kailey Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95
Personalized American Girl Jess Christmas Ornament
Buy: $34.95