NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage The Muppets Kermit the Frog Puppet From Eden Toys 24” Plush Stuffed Frog
Buy: $49.00
Vintage Plush Stuffed Animals Lot of 24/Bunnies Ernie Tommy Bears Beanies Kitty
Buy: $40.00
Vintage Tickle Me Big Bird Doll 11.5" Battery Operated Toy 1996 Tyco Works Great
Buy: $20.00
Playskool Sesame Street Big Bird Counting Plush 123 Talking 18 Inch Vintage 1995
Buy: $61.56
Vtg Sesame Street Kids Scrabble Game by Milton Bradley 1992 Vintage Game
Buy: $33.24
GUND Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Fairy Doll Plush Glittery Wings Free Shipping
Buy: $14.99
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's COOKIE MONSTER 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
Gund Set Sesame Street Cookie Monster Big Bird Oscar Grouch Stuffed Animal
Buy: $21.99
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's ELMO 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
SET OF 6 COLLECT - A - PAL
Buy: $35.99
NEW Sesame Street Kohls Cares Elmo 14 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush Pal Toy
Buy: $12.25
Hasbro Twister Splash – Summer  Water Toys for Kids
Buy: $18.00
1998 Tyco Sesame Street Turnover Choo Choo Toy Train With Box INCOMPLETE DAMAGED
Buy: $35.00
Vintage 1997 TYCO Sesame Street Elmo's 1-2-3 Sprinkler BLUE FINS
Buy: $22.89
Puzzles Book Sesame Street Elmo To Help Your Toddler Learn Simple Spanish Words
Buy: $18.00
Sesame Place Plush Lot Abby Cadabby Zoe Toy Stuffed Animal Vintage 2010 Bundle 2
Buy: $37.59
Ernie & Bert Playhouse Colorforms Sesame Street Muppets 1986 PARTS/PIECES
Buy: $8.49
Children's Learning Flashcards - Math, Shapes, Language, Numbers, Colors & More
Buy: $5.95
SESAME STREET SMALL ELMO PLUSH
Buy: $15.99
Vintage Golden Frame Tray Puzzles Sesame Street 1991 and Chip 'n Dale Lot of 2
Buy: $15.00
NEW 2013 GUND SESAME STREET 7" ERNIE PLUSH Clip On #075390 NWT!
Buy: $9.86
Monopoly Sesame Street 35th Anniversary Edition NEW FACTORY SEALED 2004
Buy: $23.48
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's Oscar the Grouch 10" Tall Plush in Trash Can
Buy: $13.99
Hasbro Softies Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Gift 12...
Buy: $7.00
Big Bird Sesame Street Plush 13" Gund Yellow #75350 Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.99
Sesame Street -Oscar The Grouch plush 75370 6” Made By Gund New W/Tags
Buy: $9.86
Hasbro Twister Splash – Summer  Water Toys for Kids
Buy: $18.77
Fisher Price: Sesame Street “Zoe” Stuffed Orange Plush (2002)!
Buy: $11.00
NANCO Sesame Street Yellow Big Bird Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 16 inch
Buy: $16.73
Vintage PLAYSKOOL WOOD FRAME TRAY PUZZLE SESAME STREET 1976 lot of 4 puzzles
Buy: $30.00
2003 Vintage Sesame Street Grover Plush by Nanco, 10-12 in. Authentic Workshop
Buy: $19.95
Vintage Playskool Sesame Big Bird Plush 9-inch Stuffed Animal Toy Hanging 80s
Buy: $19.99
Sesame Street Dominos 2003 Complete
Buy: $11.98
Sesame Street Elmo Kohls Cares Plush Toy Stuffed 14" New
Buy: $9.99
Vintage 1982 Playskool Sesame Street Count Die Cast Car Purple Muppets R1
Buy: $9.58
New Vintage 8" Cookie Monster &Elmo Sesame Street Bean Bag Applause 1997 #3 J2
Buy: $24.99
VINTAGE Fisher-Price 2002 3D Viewmaster Blue And Green *FO
Buy: $4.48
ebba - Baby Talk My Forest Friends
Buy: $10.98
Sesame Street Fisher Price Ernie 15" 2008 Stuffed Toy Mattel Plush Doll
Buy: $17.99
Sand Molds Tools Sesame Street Elmo Cookie Set 2 Pack Summer Outdoor Fun
Buy: $12.99
Lucky Ducks Game Sesame Street Replacement 2011 Hasbro, YOU Choose
Buy: $10.25
Julia (Gund) - Sesame Street Stuffed Plush Toy Doll 14"
Buy: $14.50
Sesame Street Elmo and Cookie Monster Stuff Plush Doll Set New 10-12 inches New
Buy: $14.99
Vintage 1997 Sesame Street Beans Oscar The Grouch Plush by Tyco
Buy: $11.00
Worlds Coolest Sesame Street Talking Keychain
Buy: $13.99
Vintage Hasbro Softies Bert and Ernie in Pajamas Plush Dolls sesame street
Buy: $16.95
Jeff Gordon 2002 Sesame Street 1/64 Die Cast Action Racing Trading Card Elmo
Buy: $12.95
Cookie Monster VTG 70s Knickerbocker Sesame Street Plush Rattle Eyes Rare VHTF
Buy: $34.08
2022 Jada 1/24 Hollywood Rides SESEME STREET OSCAR GROUCH 59 VOLKSWAGEN BEETLE
Buy: $32.99
Rare Rosita Sesame Street Gund Plush 13" Bow Mint Green Hispanic 2016 EUC
Buy: $98.99
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's COOKIE MONSTER 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
Hasbro Twister Splash Water Game for Kids Backyard Sprinkler Outdoor Games
Buy: $15.99
Playskool Wooden Tray Puzzle Mixed Lot of 11 Disney Sesame Street Garfield Vtg
Buy: $68.99
Jada 1:24 Diecast 1963 VW Bus No Cookie Monster Figure Great Pre-owned Condition
Buy: $22.78
VGN Tyco Sesame Street Beans Betty Lou 8"  1997 Plush Stuffed Doll Toy Pink
Buy: $14.96
Me Reader Jr Sesame Street Electronic Interactive Toy Pi Kids Replacement Reader
Buy: $15.96
Buy One Get One 1/2 Off Puzzles-Wooden Puzzle Playskool When it Rains It Pours
Buy: $4.00
Big Bird 15" Plush Soft Kohls Cares Sesame Street Stuffed Animal Doll Toy TAGS
Buy: $24.95
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's Oscar the Grouch 10" Tall Plush in Trash Can NWT
Buy: $7.99
Vintage Sesame Street Suprise Party Audio Card Game
Buy: $9.99
Lot Of 3- Bubble Guppies, PJ Mask, Sesame St Mini Puzzle In Metal Tin New Sealed
Buy: $18.95
2007 Sesame Street Singing Pizza Elmo Fisher Price Animated Toy Vintage NOS ~D2
Buy: $99.99
Sesame Street My First Electronic Game Cookie's Cookie Catch
Buy: $15.00
Sesame Street - Big Bird - Playing Cards - Poker Size - New
Buy: $14.99
Vintage Sesame Street Puzzle Jigsaw Frame Tray Shapes Muppets 1971 USA Complete
Buy: $14.99
Sesame Street Bert Stuffed Toy 2013 Hasbro Plush Doll Preschool 11"
Buy: $15.55
3 PACKS  SESAME STREET FLASH CARDS - WORDS - ABC's - COLORS - 36 CARDS EA. - NEW
Buy: $11.95
Sesame Street's Grover Soft Mini Plush Puppet Character Mouth - Approx 10" Long
Buy: $22.22
Sesame Street "Best Friends" - Large 36-Piece Floor Puzzle for Children Aged
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Cookie Monster Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 3" Tall Retro Plastic Eyes Rare
Buy: $27.99
Brain Teaser Cross Puzzle IQ Solve Secret Wood Adult Kid Pocket Learn Puzzle
Buy: $12.59
Sesame Street ELMO PLUSH 50th Anniversary 2019 Toy FACTORY Red Muppets Doll (B4)
Buy: $18.99
Sesame Street Abby Cadabby With Yellow Flower 10" Plush Doll Fairy
Buy: $16.15
Sesame Street Pop Up Game Vintage Unfold & Play Unisex Kids Colors Letters 1999
Buy: $19.99
Vtg Jakks Pacific Limbo Legs Genie the Giraffe Plush Standing Stuffed Animal NWT
Buy: $14.88
Sesame Street 50th Anniversary Blind Box Plush
Buy: $13.99
Sesame Street - Elmo 12" Inflatable Beach Ball (2023) *NEW* Official PBS
Buy: $10.99
Kohl's Cares ELMO 14" Plush & 5"x7" Book "The Bunny Hop" Sesame Street
Buy: $21.00
ELMO 2005 Mattel TOUCAN BIRD Sesame Street Talking Plush (DOESN'T WORK WELL)
Buy: $16.49
Sesame Street 123 Mr. Hooper's Store Playskool 1984 Parts 2 beds
Buy: $9.99
Wonder Forge 2017 Sesame Street Matching Game Ages 3+ Preschool
Buy: $16.99
Sesame Street 3 Wood Puzzles W/Tray & Storage Box - NEW - Sealed
Buy: $15.00
Kohls Cares For Kids - The Rainbow Fish - Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 12"
Buy: $17.99
Sesame Street Muppet Ernie Toy Plush 13" Stuffed Doll GUND 2013
Buy: $9.22
Vintage Fisher Price SESAME STREET Play House #938 & Acessories with Characters
Buy: $60.00
NEW 12.2" Sesame Street Inflatable Beach Ball Lot of 3 Elmo Cookie Monster Oscar
Buy: $24.99
EBBA - BABY TALK - "MY FOREST FRIENDS" - Plush Stuffed Animal Toys - NEW W TAGS
Buy: $39.99
Applause Telly Sesame Street Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Jim Henson 1995 Purple 7”
Buy: $21.61
Great Explorations Glowing Star Pack-Planets & Stars 30/Pkg
Buy: $11.63
Sesame Street Elmo's Bookbag Playset Plush Backpack Accessories 5-Piece
Buy: $30.36
Vintage Playskool Elmo Sesame Street Plush Toy 1990’s
Buy: $19.95
NEW GUND Elmo Plush with platic eyes year 2012 #075351
Buy: $22.99
Sesame Street Talking Singing Elmo Plush 12" Spaceship Shirt and Cell Phone
Buy: $9.00
Sesame Street Gund Happy Birthday Elmo Singing Dancing Light Up Cupcake 14"
Buy: $34.95
Jakks Limbo Legs Tara the Turtle Plush w/ Tags 2000 Purple Turtle Stuffed Animal
Buy: $19.99
Vintage big bird beanbag plush Sesame Street Knickerbocker company
Buy: $18.99
Vintage 70s Playskool SESAME STREET People in your Neighborhood Match Ups Puzzle
Buy: $16.22
Fisher Price Mattel Sesame Street ZOE Plush 11" Stuffed Orange Doll Vintage 2001
Buy: $12.00
14” Sesame Street Big Bird Plush Stuffed Toy- Kohl’s Cares
Buy: $16.00
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 17 inches EUC
Buy: $14.99