NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage The Muppets Kermit the Frog Puppet From Eden Toys 24” Plush Stuffed Frog
Buy: $49.00
1986 Ernie Sesame Street Playskool 16" Hand Puppet Stuffed Plush - Vintage
Buy: $19.99
Vintage Plush Stuffed Animals Lot of 24/Bunnies Ernie Tommy Bears Beanies Kitty
Buy: $40.00
Vintage 1970s Sesame Street Big Bird Puppet Plush Figure Educational Toys Topper
Buy: $99.99
Vtg Sesame Street Kids Scrabble Game by Milton Bradley 1992 Vintage Game
Buy: $33.24
Vintage Fisher Price Play Family Sesame Street Apartment Building & Chalkboard
Buy: $28.00
GUND Sesame Street Abby Cadabby Fairy Doll Plush Glittery Wings Free Shipping
Buy: $14.99
GUND Sesame Street Elmo Plush 12" Take Along Buddy Soft Kids Toddler Toy NEW
Buy: $13.99
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's COOKIE MONSTER 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
Gund Set Sesame Street Cookie Monster Big Bird Oscar Grouch Stuffed Animal
Buy: $21.99
Sesame Street's GROVER 12” Tall Plush Free Shipping
Buy: $17.99
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's ELMO 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
Sesame Street - Grouchy Old Oscar Card Game
Buy: $3.98
Vintage Tickle Me Big Bird Doll 11.5" Battery Operated Toy 1996 Tyco Works Great
Buy: $20.00
Vintage 1982 Hasbro Sesame Street COOKIE MONSTER Tricycle Pull Along Toy Collect
Buy: $17.99
2008 Fisher-Price Sesame Street Talking Silly Sounds Remote Control Elmo K4673
Buy: $19.95
Little Tikes Story Dream Machine Big Bird And Friends Collection Elmo, Grover
Buy: $15.00
Vintage 1984 Sesame Street 123 Play House Hooper's Store Playskool
Buy: $30.00
Sesame Street My Pal Elmo Foam Floor Puzzle 24 inch 25 piece
Buy: $19.95
Ernie & Bert Playhouse Colorforms Sesame Street Muppets 1986 PARTS/PIECES
Buy: $8.49
1998 Tyco Sesame Street Turnover Choo Choo Toy Train With Box INCOMPLETE DAMAGED
Buy: $35.00
Hasbro Twister Splash – Summer  Water Toys for Kids
Buy: $18.00
Vintage Sesame Street Neighborhood Playskool Playset Toy 1984 New In Box
Buy: $149.99
New Sesame Street Hand Puppet Plush Stuffed Dolls Elmo Kids Birthday Toy Gift
Buy: $15.99
Live Video 2023 Talking Elmo Talks,Hugs,Kisses&Dances17 Inches
Buy: $27.00
ROWLF THE DOG PUPPET MUPPET SHOW 1977 FISHER PRICE #852 JIM HENSON GREAT SHAPE
Buy: $64.99
SESAME STREET SMALL ELMO PLUSH
Buy: $15.99
Sesame Street Playskool Friends Elmo 10" Plush Toy Cuddle Pal New/Tags
Buy: $13.99
Vintage 1980s Hasbro Sesame Street Bert & Ernie Plush Soft Stuffed Dolls 12”
Buy: $25.00
Sesame Street Elmo Musical Light up Keys Mini Guitar
Buy: $26.36
4 Vtg Playskool Wooden Puzzles Mickey Donald Cookie Monster
Buy: $38.00
Fisher-Price Vintage Fozzie Bear Muppets Hand Puppet in Original Box 1978
Buy: $124.99
NEW 2013 GUND SESAME STREET 7" ERNIE PLUSH Clip On #075390 NWT!
Buy: $9.86
Vintage Golden Frame Tray Puzzles Sesame Street 1991 and Chip 'n Dale Lot of 2
Buy: $15.00
NEW Sesame Street Kohls Cares Elmo 14 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush Pal Toy
Buy: $12.25
14" Blue Monster, Hand Puppet
Buy: $37.85
Vintage Fisher Price Little People Sesame Street Bert And Ernie Figures Muppets
Buy: $10.00
Preschool Pretend Play Medical Kit 7-Piece Doctor Bag Dress Up Toys for Kids ...
Buy: $16.99
Sesame Street Radio Controlled Construction Set Replacement Wrecking Ball Mixer
Buy: $19.32
Vintage 1997 TYCO Sesame Street Elmo's 1-2-3 Sprinkler BLUE FINS
Buy: $22.89
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's Oscar the Grouch 10" Tall Plush in Trash Can
Buy: $13.99
Hasbro Softies Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Gift 12...
Buy: $7.00
Sesame Street -Oscar The Grouch plush 75370 6” Made By Gund New W/Tags
Buy: $9.86
Vintage 90’s Vtech Sesame Street Super Animated Talking Computer + 8 Disc
Buy: $49.99
Big Bird Sesame Street Plush 13" Gund Yellow #75350 Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.99
New Vintage 8" Cookie Monster &Elmo Sesame Street Bean Bag Applause 1997 #3 J2
Buy: $24.99
Hasbro Twister Splash – Summer  Water Toys for Kids
Buy: $18.77
Fisher Price: Sesame Street “Zoe” Stuffed Orange Plush (2002)!
Buy: $11.00
Vintage 1982 Playskool Sesame Street Count Die Cast Car Purple Muppets R1
Buy: $9.58
Sesame Street Dominos 2003 Complete
Buy: $11.98
Sesame Street Elmo Kohls Cares Plush Toy Stuffed 14" New
Buy: $9.99
Sesame Street Talking Alphabet Electronic Learning Toy Big Bird&Elmo/WORKS/ TYCO
Buy: $55.25
Elmos Scavenger Hunt Learn Through Music Sesame Street Mattel 2002 BB
Buy: $14.92
ebba - Baby Talk My Forest Friends
Buy: $10.98
Sesame Street Little People Muppets Inc Lot 5 / Big Bird Prairie Dawn Roosevelt
Buy: $44.99
Sesame Street Nursery House Play Set toy BOX!! TYCO PRESCHOOL JIM HENSON
Buy: $40.00
Vintage Fisher Price Toy Hickory Dickory Dock Windup Music Box WORKS Clock 1971
Buy: $21.70
VINTAGE Fisher-Price 2002 3D Viewmaster Blue And Green *FO
Buy: $4.48
Sesame Street Replacement Block Number Tyco Number 4
Buy: $10.95
Julia (Gund) - Sesame Street Stuffed Plush Toy Doll 14"
Buy: $14.50
Sesame Street Elmo and Cookie Monster Stuff Plush Doll Set New 10-12 inches New
Buy: $14.99
Vintage Hasbro Softies Bert and Ernie in Pajamas Plush Dolls sesame street
Buy: $16.95
ThinkFun Sesame Street® Zingo! for Ages 4+ 2-6 players
Buy: $19.99
Worlds Coolest Sesame Street Talking Keychain
Buy: $13.99
Sesame Workshop Sesame Street ELMO Plush Small Red 8” 2007 Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $14.99
Vintage Sesame Street LAMP POST 767-3 Fisher Price Little People
Buy: $14.80
Jeff Gordon 2002 Sesame Street 1/64 Die Cast Action Racing Trading Card Elmo
Buy: $12.95
Cookie Monster VTG 70s Knickerbocker Sesame Street Plush Rattle Eyes Rare VHTF
Buy: $34.08
Vintage 1997 Sesame Street Beans Oscar The Grouch Plush by Tyco
Buy: $11.00
Rare Rosita Sesame Street Gund Plush 13" Bow Mint Green Hispanic 2016 EUC
Buy: $98.99
Hasbro Twister Splash Water Game for Kids Backyard Sprinkler Outdoor Games
Buy: $15.99
Fisher Price Little People Vintage Brown Sesame Street Ernie E Bed
Buy: $4.24
Playskool Wooden Tray Puzzle Mixed Lot of 11 Disney Sesame Street Garfield Vtg
Buy: $68.99
Vintage Fisher Price Sesame Street Little People Mr. Hooper Lunch Counter
Buy: $12.95
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's COOKIE MONSTER 14" Tall Plush -New Tags
Buy: $12.50
Play Town Learning Curve Figures Sesame Street Elmo Grover Wood Little People
Buy: $14.99
Elmo On The Go Alphabet Letters Red Carrying Case Sesame Street Hasbro 2014
Buy: $22.36
Fisher-Price Little People Sesame Street Vintage - Misc. Lot of 10 figures / pcs
Buy: $39.99
Vintage Sesame Street Suprise Party Audio Card Game
Buy: $9.99
Tyco Sesame Street  Amusement Park Roller Ride Coaster Toy Vintage box Complete
Buy: $52.99
VGN Tyco Sesame Street Beans Betty Lou 8"  1997 Plush Stuffed Doll Toy Pink
Buy: $14.96
Me Reader Jr Sesame Street Electronic Interactive Toy Pi Kids Replacement Reader
Buy: $15.96
Sesame Street Elmo & Big Bird Child Toy Purse Bag - Vintage Tyco
Buy: $10.00
Buy One Get One 1/2 Off Puzzles-Wooden Puzzle Playskool When it Rains It Pours
Buy: $4.00
Big Bird 15" Plush Soft Kohls Cares Sesame Street Stuffed Animal Doll Toy TAGS
Buy: $24.95
TYCO Sesame Street Preschool Home Play House Accessory Replacement Stool (105
Buy: $6.49
Kohl's Cares -Sesame Street's Oscar the Grouch 10" Tall Plush in Trash Can NWT
Buy: $7.99
Sesame Street SING WITH ME ELMO Plush 17" NOS Vintage 1997 TESTED WORKS Tyco NEW
Buy: $20.99
Fisher Price Figures Sesame Street Roosevelt Franklin & The Count Vintage Lot
Buy: $24.99
Vintage Fisher Price Little People Sesame Street Big Bird Figure (B)
Buy: $3.15
Fisher Price POWERTOUCH learning system with 3 Books - Tested & Works
Buy: $18.00
VTG Sesame Street ERNIE 6” Bean Bag Plush Applause 1997 Jim Henson NWT
Buy: $12.99
Sesame Street Radio Controlled Construction Set Replacement Safety Cones Barrels
Buy: $19.32
MasterPieces Puzzle Set - 4-Pack 24 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle for Kids - Sesame
Buy: $16.99
2004 Sesame Street Chutes and Ladders Game Replacement Cookie Monster Token
Buy: $6.97
Sesame Street Brushy Brush Elmo 12-inch Plush Sings the Brushy Brush Song NEW
Buy: $29.99
Sesame Street Cookie Monster PVC Figure Toy Sailboat Jim Henson Sailor 80s Tara
Buy: $9.85
Vintage 1970s Sesame Street Fisher Price Little People Play Family Playset 938
Buy: $34.40
Vintage Applause Count Von Count Plush Toy Sesame Street 1994 Original Tag Hands
Buy: $39.99
Puzzles Book Sesame Street Elmo To Help Your Toddler Learn Simple Spanish Words
Buy: $18.00