NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Vintage ‘93 Manhattan Toy Company Black Bunny Plush Rabbit Floral Bow 15 In HTF
Buy: $80.00
Manhattan Toy Lego Brick Suit Girl 13 Inch Plush Figure NEW Easter Basket
Buy: $21.00
Manhattan Toy Company Maggie Mouse Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Pink vest
Buy: $19.00
Manhattan Toy Company Plush Dragon 8” Sea Green RARE HTF puff
Buy: $23.98
The Manhattan Toy Company, Dusty Blue, Stuffed Plush Octopus *New In Sealed Bag*
Buy: $13.99
LEGO Ninjago Lloyd Minifigure Green Cuddle Pillow Buddy Approx 20 inch Plush NWT
Buy: $19.95
17" Fraggle Rock Yellow WEMBLEY 2009 Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Doll JIM HENSON
Buy: $21.95
Manhattan Toy Company White Westie Dog Plush Pooch Party Ruffy Westie Stuffed
Buy: $21.95
Vtg Deecha Monster Weird Plush 90s Manhattan Toy Co Creature Doll Chicken *529
Buy: $20.00
Manhattan Toy Co. Little Voyagers OLIVE the GIRAFFE Plush 9.5" Soft Stuffed Toy
Buy: $14.99
MANHATTAN TOY Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Soft Fluffy White Tail CUTE
Buy: $15.95
Manhattan Toy Plush Lamb Cream White Sheep Stuffed Animal Soft Toy
Buy: $18.00
Manhattan Toy Floppies Brown Black Cream Baby Fawn Deer Stuffed Animal Plush 8"
Buy: $9.99
Vintage MANHATTAN TOY 1998 PIERRE PIG Terry Cloth TIP TOES BALLET Plush Animal
Buy: $67.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Poodle Puppy Dog Plush Fluffy White Stuffed Animal 7"
Buy: $12.00
Manhattan Toy Company Plush Jellyfish Pink Under the Sea Adorables Ocean Life
Buy: $18.95
Manhattan Toy Lavish Lanky Cats Snow White & Grey Plush Stuffed Animal, 12"
Buy: $19.95
Manhattan Toy Plush 14" Purple Green Royal Renaissance Bartholomew Dragon Figure
Buy: $16.39
MANHATTAN TOY Company Little Jurassics Chomp Stegosaurus Dinosaur Plush Teal
Buy: $15.96
Manhattan Toy RUFFY White Westie Bichon Frise Puppy Dog Plush Lovey Stuffed LC
Buy: $20.97
The Manhattan Toy Company, Navy Blue Stuffed Octopus *New In Sealed Bag*
Buy: $14.00
The Manhattan Toy Company Beige 13"  Sheep Stuffed Plush Animal Toy Play Doll
Buy: $23.99
Manhattan Toy Squeezmeez  Leopard Plush 5" Soft Stuffed Animal Rare
Buy: $9.99
Manhattan Toy Co, Dusty Blue/coral Stuffed Plush Octopus EUC
Buy: $12.00
Manhattan Toy Company Bunny Rabbit Plush Pink Stuffed Animal Lovey 12"
Buy: $17.95
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Furttleaf Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.99
Manhattan Toy Lovelies Pink Pig Plush Baby Toy Stuffed Animal Soft 8"
Buy: $29.99
Manhattan Toy Henley Black and White Chicken Stuffed Animal, 9"
Buy: $19.99
Manhattan Toy Plush Aviator Bear Stuffed Animal Toy Teddy Bear Collection 12"
Buy: $14.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Merkit Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.99
Manhattan Toy Octopus Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Soft Orange 2020 Collectible 12"
Buy: $15.83
MANHATTAN TOY Company Little Jurassics Chomp Stegosaurus Dinosaur Plush Teal
Buy: $16.99
Manhattan Toy Company Sea Turtle Stuffed Animal
Buy: $11.99
Manhattan Toy Curly Q Plush Puppy Dog Stuffed Animal Lovey  14” Bean Bag Stuffie
Buy: $16.00
Manhattan Toy Squeezmeez Orange Octopus Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Gift Idea
Buy: $14.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Merkit Stuffed Animal
Buy: $8.99
VINTAGE AND RARE MANHATTAN TOY Soft Plush Mouse Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $100.00
Manhattan Toy Navy Blue Whale Plush 14" Soft Stuffed Adorables Ocean Lovey 2018
Buy: $15.99
NEW Manhattan Toy Company SQUEEZMEEZ Reindeer Squishy Plush Toy NWT
Buy: $9.89
Manhattan Toy Luxe Saffron 13" Stuffed Animal Dog Plush Toy Adorable Soft Toys
Buy: $60.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Holiday Cream Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 7”
Buy: $11.69
Manhattan Toy Dress Ups Firefighter Dalmatian Stuffed Animal Plush FD
Buy: $39.97
The Manhattan Toy Company Stuffed Octopus - Dusty Blue - New in Sealed Bag
Buy: $11.99
Manhattan Toy Adorables Theo Bunny Stuffed Animal, 12" Gray NWT Free Shipping
Buy: $17.59
New 2020 MANHATTAN TOY 8" Plush WOOLIES HUSKY Dog Gray White Standing Stuffed
Buy: $16.99
Manhattan Toy Company Folksy Foresters Fox Corduroy Plush Stuffed Animal 13”
Buy: $23.09
Manhattan Toy Co REX Puppy Dog Plush 15" Brown Ribbed Stuffed Animal Eye Patch
Buy: $14.50
The Manhattan Toy Company Green Undersea Turtle Soft Stuffed Animal
Buy: $14.00
Manhattan Toy Company Dusty Blue Octopus, Soft Plush Stuffed Animal BRAND NEW
Buy: $15.00
The Manhattan Toy Company Orange Morphies Snappafire Snail Apple Hybrid Plush
Buy: $11.00
New 2019 MANHATTAN TOY 14" Plush SOFT PAWS BLUE BUNNY Rabbit White Tail Large
Buy: $19.99
LEGO ICONIC White Unicorn Girl 17" Plush Minifigure Character EUC
Buy: $18.99
Manhattan Toy Company Voyagers Emmie Deer Plush 9” Stuffed
Buy: $15.95
Manhattan Toy Co. Adorable Emmet Elephant Gray Ribbed Plush Stuffed Lovey 13"
Buy: $20.00
Lego Shark Suit Guy 14" Plush Minifigure Character Plush Stuffed Toy Blue
Buy: $17.95
Manhattan Toy Nursing Nissa Hedgehog Stuffed Animal with 3 Baby Hedgehogs
Buy: $32.95
NEW Manhattan Toy Company SQUEEZMEEZ Owl 5"" Squishy Plush Toy NWT
Buy: $9.89
Manhattan Toy Company Green Dinosaur Stegosaurus Plush 10" Stuffed Animal
Buy: $17.10
LEGO ICONIC Butterfly Girl with Flowers RARE 12" Plush Figure Character
Buy: $15.00
Manhattan Toy Company Plush Hippopotamus Pink Stuffed Animal Toy Hippo 1993 14”
Buy: $14.99
Manhattan Toy Co. Floppies 9” LLAMA ALPACA Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Eyes Tag
Buy: $16.95
Manhattan Toy White Cat Petit Pomme Stuffed Animal Kitten Plush 7” 2019 Soft
Buy: $24.95
Manhattan Toy Company Plush Octopus w/ Tentacles Navy Blue
Buy: $12.00
The Manhattan Toy Company Green Plush Dinosaur with Red and White Striped Hat
Buy: $12.00
Lego Shark Suit Guy 14" Plush Minifigure Character Stuffed Animal Manhattan Toy
Buy: $22.99
Manhattan Toy Floppies Brown Black Cream Baby Fawn Deer Stuffed Animal Plush 8"
Buy: $19.00
The Manhattan Toy Company Stuffed Octopus - Navy - New in Sealed Plastic bag
Buy: $11.99
Best Friends Dog Terrier Plush "Frankie" Manhattan Toy Co Stuffed Animal Coral
Buy: $8.00
Manhattan Toy Adorables REX Puppy Dog Tan 14" Plush NWT 2016 White Spot Stuffed
Buy: $39.97
The Manhattan Toy Company Orange Morphies Snappafire Snail Apple Hybrid Plush
Buy: $13.41
Manhattan Toy Pink Pig Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 8”
Buy: $14.95
Manhattan Toy Kitty Cat White Plush Stuffed Animal 8" Soft
Buy: $19.95
Gray Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal Manhattan Toy Co Theo New
Buy: $24.99
Manhattan Toy Company OCTOPUS Plush 14" Soft Stuffed Animal with Curly Legs 2020
Buy: $16.99
Dinosaur Plush Red Parasauropholus Little Jurassics Holiday Manhattan Toy EUC
Buy: $9.00
2015 Manhattan Toy Luxe Blush Bunny Plush Stuffed Animal Pink Floppy Super Soft
Buy: $32.00
Manhattan Toy Co. SPARKLES UNICORN Plush 11" White Stuffed Animal Toy 2016
Buy: $15.99
Manhattan Toy Red Dinosaur Plush Parasauropholus Little Jurassics Holiday Scarf
Buy: $12.00
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Merkit Stuffed Animal Plush NWT
Buy: $9.95
Manhattan Toy Company SQUEEZMEEZ NARWHAL Plush 5" Blue Stuffed Animal 2018 NWT
Buy: $9.99
Manhattan Toy Sea Turtle 14" Plush Teal and Green Soft Stuffed Animal
Buy: $15.00
Manhattan Toy Twiggies Ozzie Ostrich Stuffed Animal, 16"
Buy: $16.99
Manhattan Toy Company Unicorn Plush Pink Striped Scarf Stuffed Candy Cane 16"
Buy: $13.45
Manhattan Toy Co Red Silver Dragon Plush Stuffed Medieval Toy 2005 12" Laying
Buy: $12.71
Manhattan Toy Company Pterodactyl  Dinosaur Plush 10" Soft Green Stuffed Toy
Buy: $15.99
Manhattan Toy Company Unicorn 8" Plush  Twinkle White Stars Pink 2019
Buy: $9.00
Manhattan Toy Plush Bunny Pattern Pals Soft Gray Rabbit Green Polka Dot Ears
Buy: $16.95
Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Snappafire Stuffed Animal
Buy: $11.99
Manhattan Toys Tiptoes Touche BABETTE the pink Pig Plush Toy #109820 w tag. 2003
Buy: $34.00
Manhattan Toy Squeezmeez Squeezable Pink Owl Stuffed Animal Plush Gift Idea
Buy: $14.99
Manhattan Toy Company HORSE Plush Lovey Huggables Hugo Brown Lovey Animal 15"
Buy: $29.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Snappafire Stuffed Animal
Buy: $9.95
The Manhattan Toy Company Morphies Furttleaf Stuffed Animal
Buy: $11.99
The Manhattan Toy Company Little Jurassics Parasauropholus Red Plush Toy.
Buy: $13.99
Manhattan Toy Squeezmeez Blue Bunny Plush 5" Soft Stuffed Animal Rabbit Rare
Buy: $7.99
MANHATTAN Toy Company White Westie Dog Plush Pooch Party Ruffy Westie NEW LOVEY
Buy: $23.00
Manhattan Toy Nursing Nola Rabbit Stuffed Animal, 10" with 3 Bunnies
Buy: $34.95
The Manhattan Toy Company Home for The Holidays Fur Shop – Bear 15”
Buy: $10.00
Dr Seuss The Cat In The Hat Plush Toy Stuffed Animal 2002 Vintage Collectible 9"
Buy: $11.87
Morphies Furttleaf Green Turtle 8" Tree Plush Stuffed Animal Manhattan Toy
Buy: $9.99