NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Kids Preferred Black Lab Pup Labrador Dog Stuffed Animal Plush Puppy Soft 2000
Buy: $39.90
Kids Of America Corp Gorilla Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Monkey Vintage Tags 10"
Buy: $16.79
Eric Carle The Very Hungry Caterpillar Plush Neck Pillow Stuffed Animal Toy 10"
Buy: $13.59
Eric Carle The Very Hungry Caterpillar Plush Neck Pillow Stuffed Animal Toy 10"
Buy: $8.49
Puppy Dog 10" Plush Blue Stripe Pajamas Lovey Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $14.95
ZaMoo Zany Brainy Spotted Plush Cow 19” Stuffed Animal Toy w/ Bell and Tag 1997
Buy: $25.95
Elmer The Elephant Plush Doll Rainbow Checkered Squares David Mckee 13"
Buy: $19.00
Squaredy Cats Midnight Collectible Plush Not Squared of The DARK Kids Preferred
Buy: $10.50
Squaredy Cats Tiger Lily Collectible Plush Not Squared to GO WILD Kids Preferred
Buy: $10.50
Guess How Much I Love You 9" Plush Beanbag Bunny 25th Anniversary Easter Rabbit
Buy: $7.99
Guess How Much I Love You Right Up To The Moon And Back Bunny Rabbit Plush 9”
Buy: $14.50
Where Are You Llama Llama Red Pajama Musical Jack in the Box Toy
Buy: $19.95
Guess How Much I Love You Nutbrown Hare Rabbit Bunny 11” Plush Kids Preferred
Buy: $12.95
Kids Preferred Yellow Lab Labrador Puppy Dog Golden Retriever Stuffed Plush 16"
Buy: $17.85
Kids Preferred Baby Pink Bear Plush 2008 Stuffed Animal Gift Card Holder 8inch
Buy: $22.49
Vintage Husky Wolf Puppy Dog RARE Plush Toy 1998 Kids Preferred Soft  Pup 16"
Buy: $89.99
Squaredy Cats Dazzle Collectible Plush Not Squared of The SPOTLIGHT Kids Preffer
Buy: $10.50
Eric Carle Very Hungry Caterpillar Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Rattle Baby Toy 5"
Buy: $16.99
Squaredy Cats Zanie Collectible Plush Not Squared to BE UNIQUE Kids Preferred
Buy: $10.50
Yellow Lab Plush Dog Kids Preferred Certified Asthma Friendly 2005 14" Stuffed
Buy: $21.21
2016 KIDS PREFERRED BEATRIX POTTER PETER RABBIT PLUSH DOLL FIGURE STUFFED ANIMAL
Buy: $20.00
Kids Preferred 1997 18" Christmas White Black Tiger Plush Animal Doll Vintage
Buy: $30.00
Squaredy Cats Coolette Collectible Plush Not Squared to BE HIP Kids Preferred
Buy: $10.50
Kids Preferred RUDOLPH the RED NOSE REINDEER Plush 8" Stuffed Character 2022
Buy: $13.99
Kids Preferred White Pink Spots Plush elephant Puppy Asthma allergy Friendly 10"
Buy: $23.76
Kids Preferred Guess How Much I Love You 25th Anniversary BUNNY Soft Plush 9"
Buy: $16.99
Guess How Much I Love You Bunny Lovey Bean Bag Kids Preferred 6” Brown and White
Buy: $19.99
Vintage 2000 Kid's Preferred Brown Horse Plush with White Hair
Buy: $15.00
Guess How Much I Love You Plush Bunny Rabbit Hand Puppet 2013 Kids Preferred
Buy: $17.00
Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer Plush Crinkle Ears 2014 Kids Preferred Stuffed 8"
Buy: $12.75
Peter Rabbit & Flopsy Stuffed Animals 9” Plush For 0+ by Kids Preferred 2022
Buy: $18.99
World of Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Flopsy Bunny Plush 8” Pink 2021
Buy: $21.99
Kids Preferred 2019 LLAMA LLAMA RED PAJAMA Plush 10" Soft Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $13.99
Guess How Much I Love You Baby Bunny Plush 25th Anniversary Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $7.00
Disney Baby Classic Eeyore Stuffed Animal Plush Toy, 9 inches
Buy: $24.99
Curious George Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Monkey 2020 Kids Preferred Collection 8"
Buy: $12.00
Goodnight Moon Bunny Rabbit Plush 12" Stuffed Animal Kids Preferred Red Balloon
Buy: $27.00
Kids Preferred 2000 11" " Christmas Papa  & Cub White Bears Plush Dolls Vintage
Buy: $30.00
Guess How Much I Love You Bunny Plush Full Body Hand Puppet Sam McBratney Rare!
Buy: $35.00
World Of Eric Carle Soft Toy Plush Very Hungry  Caterpillar Kids Toy Plush 2019
Buy: $21.17
Guess How Much I Love You Plush 25th Anniversary Toy Hare Bunny Rabbit EUC
Buy: $12.99
Original Peter Rabbit 8" Plush Kids Preferred FW 2007 Blue Jacket By Beatrix...
Buy: $14.99
Beatrix Potter PETER RABBIIT Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Kids Preferred 24" 2019
Buy: $19.95
Peter Rabbit Bunny 8" Small Plush Doll with Jacket New with Tags
Buy: $16.99
Rabbit Bunny Full Body Hand Puppet Guess How Much I Love You Bunny Plush Animal
Buy: $12.95
NWT  Smokey The Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Doll W Shovel & Hat 15" TALL
Buy: $28.99
Beatrix Potter Stuffed Peter Rabbit Bean Bag Frederick Warne Kids Preferred 8"
Buy: $9.99
Doug The Pug Puppy Dog Sheep Plush 2016 By Kids Preferred NEW
Buy: $22.00
vtg 1997 Kid's Preferred Smokey The Bear Plush Doll+Bonus I'm Helping Smokey Pin
Buy: $24.97
Kids Preferred Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer plush  Rattle 5"
Buy: $16.49
Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Bunny Plush Kids Preferred Stuffed Animal NWTs 21"
Buy: $25.55
Kids Preferred Disney Baby Ariel The Little Mermaid Plush Doll Age 0 Months & Up
Buy: $29.99
Llama Llama Red Pajama Large Stuffed Animal, 13”
Buy: $34.64
Kids Preferred Peter Rabbit Plush 2019 Stuffed Animal Bunny Blue Coat 21" Tall
Buy: $12.99
Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Stuffed Animal Plush Toy Kids Preferred 22"
Buy: $24.95
Kids Preferred Disney Baby Belle In Gold Dress Plush Doll Age 0 Months & Up
Buy: $29.99
1 Count Kids Preferred Disney Baby Mickey Mouse Plush Age 0 Months & Up
Buy: $23.79
Guess How Much I Love You 12” Bunny Rabbit Plush Hand PUPPET Baby Safe Toy 2005
Buy: $16.99
Goodnight Moon Beanbag Stuffed Animal Plush Pajama Bunny, 13"
Buy: $18.49
Peter Rabbit Plush Cuddle Pal Round Squishy Beatrix Potter
Buy: $29.99
NEW The Gruffalo Plush Animal Stuffed Doll Soft Toy Donaldson/Scheffler 8-9"
Buy: $33.90
Disney Baby Ariel The Little Mermaid Plush Doll by Kids Preferred
Buy: $25.00
KIDS PREFERRED Llama Red Pajama Large Stuffed Animal, 13” 13 inches,
Buy: $39.59
☆ ~Guess How Much I Love You 20" Nut Brown Hare Plush Bunny By Kids Preferred~ ☆
Buy: $32.99
The World Of Beatrix Potter Peter Rabbit Blue Flopsy Bunny 22" Easter Plush Doll
Buy: $21.99
Kids Preferred Cuddle Pals Stuffed Animal Plush Unicorn
Buy: $25.99
The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle Plush Toy 16" Long : Year 2007
Buy: $25.00