NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $150.00
Beanie Baby Babies Ty Pink Face Spangle 99 + Holiday 97 both RARE with Errors
Buy: $150.00
Buy: $129.99
Ty Beanie Baby Lot of 13 Halloween Themed
Buy: $129.99
Buy: $149.00
Ty beanie babies, Halloween collection 1995-2008
Buy: $149.00
Buy: $15.28
RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY HALLOWEENIE~BAT-E THE HALLOWEEN BLACK BAT 4"~NEW
Buy: $15.28
Buy: $9.99
TY Beanie Babies Halloween Beanies Pocus With Tag
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $6.00
Ty Creepers The Halloween Skelton Beanie Baby Babies Plush With Tag
Buy: $6.00
Buy: $15.00
YIKES TY Beanie Baby Halloween Bear Hallmark Gold Crown Exclusive Beanie Babies
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $2.00
Ty Beanie Baby Pumkin Halloween
Buy: $2.00
Buy: $9.89
TY Beanie Baby - HOCUS the Halloween Bear (9 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $9.89
Buy: $9.00
1995 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~SPOOKY THE HALLOWEEN GHOST 8" TOY~WITH TAGS
Buy: $9.00
Buy: $10.99
Ty Beanie Baby “Frankenteddy” Stuffed 8.5” Plush Halloween Tag Protector 2001
Buy: $10.99
Buy: $14.14
WITCHIE TY Beanie Baby Boos 2019 RARE & RETIRED Black Cat Halloween Witch 6"
Buy: $14.14
Buy: $10.00
Ty Beanie Baby Frankenteddy - MWMT (Bear 2001) Halloween Random Style
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $15.89
Ty Beanie Baby Gouliette - MWMT (Ghost Girl 2007) Halloween
Buy: $15.89
Buy: $10.00
Lot Of 3 TY Beanie Babies Holiday Halloween Valentines
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $18.89
Ty Beanie Baby Trickster - MWMT (Bear 2008) Halloween
Buy: $18.89
Buy: $14.50
TY Beanie Baby - POCUS the Halloween Bear (BBOM October 2005) 8.5"...NEW
Buy: $14.50
Buy: $8.95
Ty Beanie Babies Witch “Scary the Witch” 2001 Halloween Plush Vintage w/ Tag
Buy: $8.95
Buy: $16.25
Ty Beanie Baby Scared-e Orange Halloween Cat Online Exclusive Black Ribbon Feet
Buy: $16.25
Buy: $9.99
TY Beanie Baby HAUNTING the Halloween Bear NWT
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $11.95
Ty Beanie Baby Scooby Doo Halloween Vampire Dracula Happy Harroreen With Tag 6"
Buy: $11.95
Buy: $8.00
Vtg Ty Beanie Babies Plush Scary The Witch Halloween Stuffed Animal Toy 2001 7"
Buy: $8.00
Buy: $13.55
Ty Halloween Beanie Baby Sheets The Ghost DOB October 31 ,1999
Buy: $13.55
Buy: $15.89
TY Beanie Baby - SPELLS the Halloween Bear (Internet Exclusive) (9 inch) - MWMTs
Buy: $15.89
Buy: $10.96
Ty Beanie Babies TRICKY the Halloween Bear
Buy: $10.96
Buy: $9.95
Ty Halloween FRAIDY 9 black cat) NEW/ MWMT (REDUCED)
Buy: $9.95
Buy: $12.75
TY Beanie Baby - COUNT the Halloween Bear (9 inch) - NEW & MINT Tags
Buy: $12.75
Buy: $9.98
Hello Kitty Halloween Bat Orange Black 6" Ty Beanie Babies
Buy: $9.98
Buy: $499.99
1999 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~SHEETS THE HALLOWEEN GHOST 7"~NEW
Buy: $499.99
Buy: $22.46
RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~SCARED-E THE ORANGE AND BLACK HALLOWEEN CAT KITTEN 6"~NEW
Buy: $22.46
Buy: $14.89
TY Beanie Baby - YIKES the Halloween Bear (Hallmark Gold Crown Excl.) (8.5 inch)
Buy: $14.89
Buy: $8.34
1995 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~SPOOKY THE HALLOWEEN GHOST 8" TOY~WITH TAGS
Buy: $8.34
Buy: $14.95
Ty Beanie Babies Halloween Trio
Buy: $14.95
Buy: $15.81
Ty Beanie Babies Halloween Quivers the Ghost and Pumpkin
Buy: $15.81
Buy: $14.75
Lot Of 3 TY McDonald’s Beanie Babies Halloween, VAN PYRE, TREATSIES ,SCAREM Mint
Buy: $14.75
Buy: $11.72
SCREAMS cat with hat Halloweenie Ty Beanie Baby 3'-5" Halloween
Buy: $11.72
Buy: $9.95
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby FRIGHTS the Black Cat (4 Inch)Plush
Buy: $9.95
Buy: $9.03
TY Beanie Babies Set Lot of 3 Halloween Creatures Spooky Spinner Batty Ghost
Buy: $9.03
Buy: $17.99
Lot of 4 TY Halloween Beanie Babies Bears Pumpkin Witch Ghost Spider
Buy: $17.99
Buy: $9.99
Lot of 5 TY Beanie Babies Ghost Halloween Dragon Unicorn Fantasy Halloween
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $10.99
TY Halloween Beanie Baby Creepers Skeleton No Robe 2001 Retired Plush Toy
Buy: $10.99
Buy: $15.99
TY Beanie Baby HAUNT Halloween Orange Ghost 7" w/ Tag 2010 Plush Boo MINT
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $10.00
NEW TY Beanie Baby 2000 Scary the Witch with Tag NWT Halloween Gift Basket Cute!
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $24.99
Vintage Ty Beanie Baby Batty the Bat 1996 Errors Tags Retired PVC Halloween HTF
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $5.00
Ty Beanie Baby Haunt - (Bear Halloween 2000) Halloween decoration
Buy: $5.00
Buy: $12.99
Retired Tricky Ty Beanie Baby Bear Halloween Pumpkin 2002 2003
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $8.00
Ty Teeny Ty's Webster Halloween Spider MWMT Free Shipping
Buy: $8.00
Buy: $14.99
Ty Halloween Beanie Babies Vlad Bat Costume Vampire Plush 8" With Tag
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $15.00
Ty Classic Shadow Black Cat 12" Beanie Babies Plush with Tag, 1999, Halloween
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $16.70
TY Beanie Baby - 2005-2007 - Mini Halloween Lot of 6 - with Tags 4-5"
Buy: $16.70
Buy: $17.48
Ty Beanie Boos ~ RADAR Halloween Bat & OMEN the Flippable bat 6" NEW FREE SHIP
Buy: $17.48
Buy: $20.00
Ty Beanie Babies "Treator" Halloween Orange Bear Holding Candy Corn W/Tag
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $13.99
Ty Beanie Boos "Haunts" The Halloween Ghost, 6", MWMTs ( Claires Exclusive)
Buy: $13.99
Buy: $18.82
RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY PUNKIES~SPOOKERS THE ORANGE HALLOWEEN CAT 8"~NEW
Buy: $18.82
Buy: $11.99
Disney Beanie Babies Pooh Halloween MBBP
Buy: $11.99
Buy: $3.50
Ty Beanie Baby Hocus The Halloween Bear - GREAT CONDITION WITH TAGS
Buy: $3.50
Buy: $7.99
TY Halloween Beanie Babies Spooky Ghost 1995 and Pumkin the Pumpkin 1998
Buy: $7.99
Buy: $6.60
Ty Beanie Baby Sheets - MWMT (Ghost 1999) Halloween
Buy: $6.60
Buy: $250.00
TY Beanie Baby PUMKIN The PUMPKIN 1998 Halloween Retired PLUSH TOY
Buy: $250.00
Buy: $15.99
Ty Beanie Baby Halloween Lot of 3/ Hocus, Ghoul and Moonlight
Buy: $15.99
Buy: $12.00
ty beanie babies halloween bear
Buy: $12.00
Buy: $10.00
TY GHOULIANNE the HALLOWEEN GHOST BEANIE BABY - MINT with MINT TAG
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $12.95
TY HALLOWEENIE - VAN PYRE DRACULA BEAR 4" BEANIE BABY Plush New MWMT'S
Buy: $12.95
Buy: $5.50
Ghostio The Ghost Ty Beanie Baby - Halloween, GREAT CONDITION W/TAGS
Buy: $5.50
Buy: $19.95
New Ty Beanie Baby "Frankenteddy" Halloween Bear Original 9"
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $29.99
Lot of (4) TY Beanie Babies Halloween Teddy Bear(s) - Haunt Frankenteddy w/Tags
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $9.58
2003 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~QUIVERS THE HALLOWEEN GHOST BEAR 7"~NEW
Buy: $9.58
Buy: $8.00
TY Beanie Baby - HAUNTING the Halloween Bear, GREAT CONDITION W/TAGS
Buy: $8.00
Buy: $12.69
TY HALLOWEEN BEANIE BABY BOOS 6" CREEPER PURPLE SPIDER PLUSH ANIMAL TOY 2017
Buy: $12.69
Buy: $25.00
2010 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~HELLO KITTY HALLOWEEN WITCH COSTUME 6"~NEW!
Buy: $25.00
Buy: $10.00
Ty Beanie Baby FRAIDY the Halloween Black Cat 🎃 Autumn Fall 6" 10/13/2000
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $10.95
Ty Beanie Baby Halloween - Trick R. Treat the Pumpkin MWMT Retired Vintage
Buy: $10.95
Buy: $14.99
Ty Beanie Babies Ghoulianne November 1, 2004 Halloween
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $13.95
Ty Beanie Baby - SCARES The Halloween Bear 8.5" Stuffed Plush New MWMT's
Buy: $13.95
Buy: $7.50
1995 TY BEANIE BABY~SPOOKY THE HALLOWEEN GHOST, GREAT CONDITION W/TAGS
Buy: $7.50
Buy: $19.95
Ty Beanie Baby-ALACAZAM HALLOWEEN DOG" NEW MWMT's FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $19.95
Buy: $11.99
TY Beanie Babies "SCAREM" Halloween Bat w/ Orange Wings Animal Doll 2007
Buy: $11.99
Buy: $7.00
Halloween Ty Beanie Baby Scream the Pumpkin 2007 P.E.
Buy: $7.00
Buy: $14.99
TY Beanie Babies Baby Jinxy Black Orange Bow Halloween Cat Plush
Buy: $14.99
Buy: $15.00
Pocus October Halloween Beanie Of The Month 2005 Ty Beanie Baby - MWMTs
Buy: $15.00
Buy: $12.89
TY Beanie Baby - HAUNT the Halloween Bear (8.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $12.89
Buy: $11.75
Ty Beanie Babies- Shivers The Halloween Bear-MWMT
Buy: $11.75
Buy: $20.04
TY Beanie Babies Halloween bear "yikes"( Hallmark Gold crown exclusive ) 2006
Buy: $20.04
Buy: $10.79
Ty Beanie Baby Halloweenie Beanies FRIGHTS Black Cat Halloween
Buy: $10.79
Buy: $9.99
Vintage TY Beanie Babies Pumkin' the Pumpkin Halloween Plush Toy w/ Hang Tag
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $13.95
Ty Beanie Baby Trickster The Bear 8" Trick or Treat Bag MWMT Halloween
Buy: $13.95
Buy: $12.99
Ty Beanie Babies FRAIDY Halloween Black Cat 6” Plush Bean Bag Vintage 2001 Toy
Buy: $12.99
Buy: $14.84
2004 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~JINXY THE BLACK HALLOWEEN CAT KITTEN 6"~NEW
Buy: $14.84
Buy: $18.89
TY Beanie Baby - RATZO the Rat (Halloween Version - Internet Excl) (5.5 inch)
Buy: $18.89
Buy: $17.95
Merlin The Black Cat - Ty RETIRED Halloween Beanie Baby 6" - NEW with MINT Tags
Buy: $17.95
Buy: $9.89
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - CREEPS the Spider (3 inch) - MWMTs Halloween Toy
Buy: $9.89
Buy: $11.98
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby GHOSTERS Halloween Ghost 5 Inch
Buy: $11.98
Buy: $2.00
TY Beanie Baby - "Sheets" the Ghost 1999 Halloween GOOD CONDITION W/TAGS
Buy: $2.00
Buy: $11.25
Ty Beanie Boos - MORTIMER the Halloween Bat (6 Inch) Plush Toy NEW 2022
Buy: $11.25
Buy: $9.89
TY Halloweenie Beanie Baby - TRICKY the Bear (5.5 inch) - MWMTs Halloween Toy
Buy: $9.89
Buy: $7.00
SCAREM bat Halloweenie Ty Beanie Baby 3.5 Inch Halloween 2007 P.E. Pellets
Buy: $7.00
Buy: $695.00
**HAUNT** TY Halloween Bear Beanie Baby with TAG ERRORS
Buy: $695.00
Buy: $72.86
2010 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY~HELLO KITTY HALLOWEEN BAT COSTUME 6"~NEW
Buy: $72.86
Buy: $48.52
TY BEANIE BABY~PHANTOM & HAUNTED HALLOWEEN SET GHOST BEAR~BORDERS EXCLUSIVE~NEW
Buy: $48.52