NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $359.00
1909-S 1C Indian Head Cent NGC VG8 *Grand Pa’s Collection* Nice1, Don’t Miss
Buy: $359.00
Buy: $541.72
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny CHOICE FINE+/VF FREE SHIPPING E612 TECM
Buy: $541.72
Buy: $564.00
1909-S Indian Cent PCGS VF35 Key Date Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike
Buy: $564.00
Buy: $498.88
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny. RARE Date!!!
Buy: $498.88
Buy: $425.00
1909-S INDIAN CENT NICE DETAIL TOUGHER KEY DATE #5528
Buy: $425.00
Buy: $299.99
1909 S Indian Head Cent 1c San Francisco Key Date ANACS F12 Damaged #73846
Buy: $299.99
Buy: $625.00
1909 S INDIAN HEAD CENT KEY DATE CHOICE XF+!!! JUST BEAUTIFUL
Buy: $625.00
Buy: $612.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS VF30 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $612.75
Buy: $498.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny VF Very Fine Key Date
Buy: $498.00
Buy: $129.94
1909-S Lincoln Penny Wheat Cent 1c in XF Condition
Buy: $129.94
Buy: $399.00
Indian Head Cent set. 1857 to 1909. Coins total.
Buy: $399.00
Buy: $495.00
1909-S Indian Head cent NGC graded VF25 key date
Buy: $495.00
Buy: $610.99
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny VF+/XF E125 KEYR
Buy: $610.99
Buy: $389.99
1909-S Indian Head Cent 1C PGCS (VG10) - Key Date
Buy: $389.99
Buy: $593.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS VF25 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $593.75
Buy: $1450.00
1909 S Indian Head Cent * Penny * Choice / Gem BU Red * #1
Buy: $1450.00
Buy: $491.35
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny CHOICE FINE FREE SHIPPING E137 YEEA
Buy: $491.35
Buy: $530.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny 1C PCGS VERY FINE 30 VF 30 Type 3, Bronze RARE
Buy: $530.00
Buy: $450.00
1909-S Indian Cent, XF Detail, Reverse Rim Dings
Buy: $450.00
Buy: $470.80
1909-S Indian Head One Cent 1c Penny PCGS F15
Buy: $470.80
Buy: $1995.00
1857-1909 Flying Eagle + Indian Head Cent Penny Collection COMPLETE Dansco Album
Buy: $1995.00
Buy: $1889.99
1909-S Indian Head Cent 1C PCGS CAC MS63BN
Buy: $1889.99
Buy: $399.95
1909-S Indian Head Cent NGC VG10 BN Brown 1c
Buy: $399.95
Buy: $593.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified ANACS VF25 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $593.75
Buy: $24.99
1909 Indian Head Penny Cent*Lowest Philadelphia Mintage In 1900’s*F+
Buy: $24.99
Buy: $62.10
1909 INDIAN HEAD PENNY TYPE COIN LOT OF 13 1491S G VG
Buy: $62.10
Buy: $390.00
1909 S - INDIAN HEAD CENT - PCGS Environmental Damage VF details
Buy: $390.00
Buy: $589.95
1909 S Indian Head Cent KEY DATE XF
Buy: $589.95
Buy: $517.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified NGC VF Details - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $517.75
Buy: $565.00
1909 S Small Cents Indian Head Penny NGC VF-30 BN
Buy: $565.00
Buy: $399.99
1909 S Indian Head Cent 1c Circulated Corroded but ** FULL LIBERTY ** #54500
Buy: $399.99
Buy: $517.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified NGC F15 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $517.75
Buy: $500.00
1909-S INDIAN HEAD CENT 1C NGC VF 30 BN - Really nice look! GP
Buy: $500.00
Buy: $58.83
Set of 30 Indian Head Pennies From the 1900s (1900-1909)
Buy: $58.83
Buy: $564.99
1909 S Indian Head Cent VF 30 BN NGC Penny 1c Coin SKU:I8732
Buy: $564.99
Buy: $525.00
PCGS VF25 1909 S INDIAN HEAD CENT NICE EYE APPEAL KEY DATE
Buy: $525.00
Buy: $498.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS VF Details - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $498.75
Buy: $36.00
1909 Indian Head Cent 1C Nice Choice AU Good Luster Peripheral Toning S684
Buy: $36.00
Buy: $600.00
1909-S 1C Indian Cent in Extra Fine XF Condition, All Brown Color, Bold Liberty
Buy: $600.00
Buy: $662.50
1909-S Indian Head Cent NGC XF-40 BN
Buy: $662.50
Buy: $199.95
Indian Head Cent Penny 1880 - 1909 Short Set (30 COINS)
Buy: $199.95
Buy: $115.71
Short Set 1880 - 1909 Indian Head Cent Penny (30 COINS) G / VG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $115.71
Buy: $502.66
1909-S Indian Head Cent Fine-12 PCGS
Buy: $502.66
Buy: $20.00
Short Set 1900 - 1909 Indian Head Cent Penny (10 COINS) G / VG FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $3.99
(1) VG to Fine Indian Head Penny 1 Cent US Coins Lot 1880 - 1909 Partial Liberty
Buy: $3.99
Buy: $499.99
1909-S Indian Head Cent PCGS F15 - Key Date Original!
Buy: $499.99
Buy: $2.89
Indian Head Penny, (1) 1900-1909 Penny from Grandaddy's Trunk, Ships SAME day
Buy: $2.89
Buy: $595.00
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified ANACS VF25 - Old Holder
Buy: $595.00
Buy: $495.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent ANACS VF20 Old Holder
Buy: $495.00
Buy: $6.99
1909 U.S. 1C Indian Head Cent Nice Coin Better Date Coin (003)
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $6.99
1909 U.S. 1C Indian Head Cent Nice Coin Better Date Coin (005)
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $219.98
U.S. 1909-P Indian Head Cent - 1c - DDO!!!
Buy: $219.98
Buy: $659.99
1908-S Indian Head Cent 1C NGC MS63RB - Semi KEY DATE
Buy: $659.99
Buy: $660.25
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS VF30 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $660.25
Buy: $449.98
U.S. 1909-P Indian Head Cent - 1c - RB CHBU DDO!!!
Buy: $449.98
Buy: $4009.63
1909-S Indian Head Cent MS-64 PCGS CAC (Red)
Buy: $4009.63
Buy: $495.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent PCGS XF Details Environmental #47067674
Buy: $495.00
Buy: $498.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified ANACS XF40 Details - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $498.75
Buy: $696.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny XF KEY DATE FREE SHIPPING
Buy: $696.00
Buy: $894.95
1909 S PCGS AU Detail - Indian Head Cent Penny - 1c US Coin #44667A
Buy: $894.95
Buy: $743.00
1909-S Indian Cent - XF (#48333-L)
Buy: $743.00
Buy: $3386.70
1909-S Indian Head Cent PCGS MS-65 RB
Buy: $3386.70
Buy: $593.75
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS VF25 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $593.75
Buy: $689.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent NGC XF-45 BN
Buy: $689.00
Buy: $624.50
1909-S Indian Cent PCGS VF 35 - Key Date - Eagle Eye Photo Seal! - F#0985
Buy: $624.50
Buy: $199.00
1909 INDIAN HEAD PENNY TYPE COIN LOT OF 35 CIRCULATED 1244S
Buy: $199.00
Buy: $6.99
1909 U.S. 1C Indian Head Cent Nice Coin Better Date Coin (001)
Buy: $6.99
Buy: $3.29
Indian Head Pennies 1800s-1900s coper Cent Full readable date Random
Buy: $3.29
Buy: $629.00
1909 S Indian Head Cent - ICG EF-45
Buy: $629.00
Buy: $349.98
U.S. 1909-P Indian Head Cent - 1c - BN CHBU DDO!!!
Buy: $349.98
Buy: $3.99
20th Century Small Cent U.S. Coin Lot Indian Head Steel Wheat 95% Memorial Penny
Buy: $3.99
Buy: $959.95
1909-S 1C Indian Head Cent PCGS Genuine AU Detail
Buy: $959.95
Buy: $2386.00
1909-S Indian Cent NGC MS64 RB Key Date Great Eye Appeal Strong Strike
Buy: $2386.00
Buy: $743.32
1909-S Indian Head Cent VF-30 PCGS CAC (Brown)
Buy: $743.32
Buy: $349.98
U.S. 1909-P Indian Head Cent - 1c - BN CHBU Snow-1 DDO!!!
Buy: $349.98
Buy: $2500.00
1909-S Indian Head/Oak Wreath rev Cent CERTIFIED NGC MS 64 RED BROWN 1-Cent
Buy: $2500.00
Buy: $1007.00
1909-S Indian Cent 1C - Certified PCGS AU55 - Rare Key Date Penny!
Buy: $1007.00
Buy: $675.00
1909 S INDIAN HEAD PENNY CENT ANACS RARE LOW MINTAGE
Buy: $675.00
Buy: $2897.33
1909-S Indian Head Cent MS-65 NGC (Brown)
Buy: $2897.33
Buy: $299.98
U.S. 1909-P Indian Head Cent - 1c - RB BU DDO!!!
Buy: $299.98
Buy: $1705.88
1909-S Indian Head Cent MS-63 PCGS (Brown)
Buy: $1705.88
Buy: $1395.00
Genuine BN 1909-S Indian Head Cent ICG *0200
Buy: $1395.00
Buy: $9.99
(5) Vintage Indian Head Pennies 1 Cent US Coins Penny Lot 1880 - 1909 Cull to AG
Buy: $9.99
Buy: $611.00
1909-S Indian Head Cent Penny, Very Scarce Key Date ** Free Shipping!
Buy: $611.00
Buy: $532.34
1909-S 1C VF20 Anacs Graded Collectible US Coin Indian Head Penny
Buy: $532.34