NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
Buy: $64.95
Nice Original KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING! KC92UN
Buy: $64.95
Buy: $45.00
Buffalo Nickel 1921 S Feather Variety, Condition as Pictured
Buy: $45.00
Buy: $64.95
Original KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING! KD51IN
Buy: $64.95
Buy: $74.95
Nice Original KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING! KC85ND
Buy: $74.95
Buy: $69.95
1921 S Buffalo Nickel VG ..................Lot 4226
Buy: $69.95
Buy: $55.00
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 2 Feather VG Key Date
Buy: $55.00
Buy: $90.00
1921 S Buffalo Nickel Key Date Only 1,557,000 Minted Nice Detail #BU012
Buy: $90.00
Buy: $44.99
(1) Beautiful Antique 1921-S Buffalo/Indian Head Nickel G-GOOD BETTER DATE
Buy: $44.99
Buy: $80.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel - VG Very Good - Displays Very Well - Nice Date
Buy: $80.00
Buy: $29.99
1921-S Buffalo Nickel - Semi Key Date - Low Mintage - Free Shipping!
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $49.99
(1) Beautiful Toned Antique 1921-S Buffalo/Indian Head Nickel G-GOOD
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $49.99
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c Good G Or Very Good VG Key Date Original
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $625.67
1921-S Buffalo Nickels XF+ E284 JNPH
Buy: $625.67
Buy: $41.95
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C G Good
Buy: $41.95
Buy: $72.95
Nice KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ --Obverse Lamination-- FREE S&H! KC76ST
Buy: $72.95
Buy: $285.00
1921-S NGC VF25 Buffalo Nickel Great Eye Appeal
Buy: $285.00
Buy: $49.99
(1) Beautiful Antique 1921-S Buffalo/Indian Head Nickel GOOD
Buy: $49.99
Buy: $159.00
1921 s buffalo nickel Bargain Better Date Check My Listings Please 👊👀😊
Buy: $159.00
Buy: $69.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Circulated VG Very Good ICG VG8
Buy: $69.00
Buy: $3900.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c MS63 PCGS Secure 948567-9
Buy: $3900.00
Buy: $78.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VG SN2457
Buy: $78.00
Buy: $74.99
1921-S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC VG8 #6849316-006 FRESHLY GRADED!
Buy: $74.99
Buy: $65.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel NGC G-6 Great For Lowball Set!
Buy: $65.00
Buy: $100.70
1921-S 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS VG-8
Buy: $100.70
Buy: $91.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel - Fine Details, Cleaned (#52315-H)
Buy: $91.00
Buy: $74.99
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c PCGS F Detail
Buy: $74.99
Buy: $105.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel, NGC VG8, Key Date, Issue Free.
Buy: $105.00
Buy: $75.00
1921 S Buffalo Nickel Key Date Only 1,557,000 Minted Nice Detail #BU011
Buy: $75.00
Buy: $54.95
1921 S Buffalo Nickel, Good Condition, Tough Early Date, Free Shipping, C6695
Buy: $54.95
Buy: $72.95
Original KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ FREE SHIPPING! KD28UI
Buy: $72.95
Buy: $134.99
1921 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel 5 Cent Piece VG 10 PCGS 5c SKU:I542
Buy: $134.99
Buy: $275.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c PCGS VF20
Buy: $275.00
Buy: $575.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel XF Detail Key Date
Buy: $575.00
Buy: $59.99
1921-S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC VG DETAILS "CLEANED" #6849316-030 FRESHLY GRADED!
Buy: $59.99
Buy: $88.50
1921 S US Buffalo Nickel - Two Feather Variety FS-401 + Free Shipping (RD35)
Buy: $88.50
Buy: $174.99
1921 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel F 15 ANACS 5c Coin SKU:I6272
Buy: $174.99
Buy: $259.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Circulated Very Fine NGC VF25
Buy: $259.00
Buy: $3750.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c MS63 NGC BRIGHT uncirculated key date
Buy: $3750.00
Buy: $90.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS VG08
Buy: $90.00
Buy: $79.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C, Fine F
Buy: $79.00
Buy: $139.99
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 5c Better Grade Full Date #56928
Buy: $139.99
Buy: $55.95
1921 S 5c Buffalo Nickel PCGS Genuine | VG Detail
Buy: $55.95
Buy: $204.95
1921-S Buffalo 5c Nickel NGC VF 20 (Semi-Key Date)
Buy: $204.95
Buy: $119.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VG Uncertified #913
Buy: $119.00
Buy: $74.95
1921 S Buffalo Nickel Item # 11344
Buy: $74.95
Buy: $10.00
1921 1928-D 1928-S Buffalo Nickel ---- Nice Details Coin Lot ---- #494P
Buy: $10.00
Buy: $277.19
1921-S Buffalo Nickel CHOICE VF E161 RCLM
Buy: $277.19
Buy: $107.70
1921-S Buffalo Nickel CHOICE FINE E205 VUMM
Buy: $107.70
Buy: $498.50
1921 S Buffalo Nickel - NGC VF20 - Ultra Tough Date + Free Shipping (RD55)
Buy: $498.50
Buy: $29.99
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 5c Circulated Acid Date #69318
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $20.00
BUFFALO NICKEL LOT: 1923S, 1921, 1918, 1916! AG-G #13108
Buy: $20.00
Buy: $29.99
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 5c Circulated Corroded #53162
Buy: $29.99
Buy: $74.99
1921-S 5C BUFFALO NICKEL NGC VG8 #2147141-024 FRESHLY GRADED!
Buy: $74.99
Buy: $125.00
1921 "S" Indian Head *BUFFALO* Nickel 5c #A1 East Coast Coin & Collectables, Inc
Buy: $125.00
Buy: $69.50
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VERY GOOD 5c
Buy: $69.50
Buy: $110.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5c ICG F12 - Cool Mint Error Laminated
Buy: $110.00
Buy: $36.92
1921 S U.S. BUFFALO NICKEL US 5 CENT COIN
Buy: $36.92
Buy: $128.88
1921-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS F-12. RARE Date!
Buy: $128.88
Buy: $137.75
= 1921-S FINE+ BUFFALO Nickel, Nice EYE Appeal, FREE Shipping
Buy: $137.75
Buy: $119.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VG Uncertified #1229
Buy: $119.00
Buy: $85.00
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 5c - ICG F12 (SL359)
Buy: $85.00
Buy: $247.00
1921 S Buffalo Nickel VF Very Fine STRONG STRIKE Indian Bison 5c
Buy: $247.00
Buy: $59.95
1921 S 5C Buffalo Nickel ANACS AG 3
Buy: $59.95
Buy: $41.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel - Good Details, Damaged, Acid & Grainy (#52314-Z)
Buy: $41.00
Buy: $69.95
KEY Date 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ -Strong Obv Lamination Error- FREE S&H KB33UU
Buy: $69.95
Buy: $107.70
1921-S 2 1/2 Feathers Buffalo Nickel CHOICE FINE E206 STMM
Buy: $107.70
Buy: $2254.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel AU55 PCGS (CAC)
Buy: $2254.00
Buy: $104.99
1921 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel VG 10 NGC 5c Coin SKU:I10771
Buy: $104.99
Buy: $148.88
1921-S Buffalo Nickel. Rare date! ICG F15 Details.
Buy: $148.88
Buy: $289.99
1921-S Buffalo Nickel - NGC VF20 - ✪COINGIANTS✪
Buy: $289.99
Buy: $54.95
1921 S Buffalo Nickel Item # 6691
Buy: $54.95
Buy: $12.95
SIX MIXED BUFFALOS -- 1921-P, 2 x BETTER DATE 1923-S AND 3 OTHERS WITH ISSUES
Buy: $12.95
Buy: $800.00
1921 S BUFFALO NICKEL - 2 FEATHER - VF - SEE PICS! - (N9186)
Buy: $800.00
Buy: $64.94
1921-S Buffalo Nickel Five Cent 5c Coin in Good/Very Good Condition
Buy: $64.94
Buy: $99.99
1921 S Buffalo Nickel 5c Better Grade Damaged FULL DATE #51468
Buy: $99.99
Buy: $345.00
1921-S 5C Buffalo Nickel in Choice VF Condition #BH01018
Buy: $345.00
Buy: $89.00
1921-S 5C Buffalo Nickel with Fine Detail Cleaned #10890
Buy: $89.00
Buy: $49.95
1921 S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel ~ G GOOD ~ 5 Cent Piece ~ 5c US Coin
Buy: $49.95
Got Free Shipping? (US)
Got Free Shipping? (US)