NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
First Impressions Lovey Security Blanket Plush Bunny Rabbit Pink Crown Silver
Buy: $14.99
First Impressions 10" Lion Colorful Rainbow 2013 Plush
Buy: $18.99
Stuffed Plush Narwhal Pink Whale Unicorn Horn First Impressions Macy's New NWT
Buy: $22.95
Macy’s Giraffe Plush First Impressions 10”Stuffed Animal Cream Tan Baby
Buy: $21.99
First Impressions Cream/Brown Teddy Bear Security Blanket Baby Lovey
Buy: $10.00
First Impressions COW Bull 9  Plush White Gray Macy's Lovey Stuffed Animal Baby
Buy: $31.97
First Impressions Baby Lovey Giraffe Pink Yellow Little Cutie
Buy: $12.00
First Impressions Baby Giraffe Spring Easter Yellow plush stuffed animal 12"
Buy: $14.00
First Impressions Baby Octopus Spring Easter Yellow Plush Stuffed Animal 7"
Buy: $14.00
FIRST IMPRESSIONS Lion Swirl Fur Cat Macys Plush 9" Stuffed Animal Toy Lovey
Buy: $13.49
First Impressions 12" Blue Shaggy Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Macys Baby
Buy: $13.30
First Impressions Macy's Stuffed Pineapple Plush flower Toy 11"
Buy: $14.25
First Impressions Little Cutie Giraffe Security Blanket Lovey Pink Yellow Baby
Buy: $17.99
First Impressions 1st Plush Lovey Security Elephant Gray White Cord Trunk
Buy: $10.99
First Impressions Lovey Security Plush Elephant Teddy Bear Cream Gray
Buy: $12.99
First Impressions Macys Macy's Stuffed Plush Holiday Xmas Reindeer 8" 10" Toy
Buy: $59.89
First Impressions Bunny Rabbit White Pink Tan 10" Lovey 2010 Macy's
Buy: $24.99
2017 First Impressions Macy’s Grey Plush Baby Lovey Elephant Corduroy
Buy: $11.95
First Impressions Baby Lovey Giraffe Little Cutie Pink Yellow Soother
Buy: $12.00
First Impressions ELEPHANT 15" Plush Blue Green Polka Dots Fleece Baby Lovey
Buy: $24.97
First Impressions Giraffe Plush Soft 9" 2018 Macys Cream Lovey Stuffed Animal
Buy: $7.95
Blue Teddy Bear Fluffy Plush Stuffed 13" Baby Toy Lovey First Impressions
Buy: $15.95
First Impressions Giraffe Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Macy's 9" White Tan
Buy: $12.75
EASTER Bunny Rabbit Plush Stuffed Animal First Impressions NEW
Buy: $20.00
First Impressions Yellow Giraffe Soft Plush Stuffed Animal 12" Toy
Buy: $18.99
First Impressions Plush Baby Lovey Giraffe Stuffed Animal Shaggy Floppy EUC
Buy: $12.00
First Impressions Grey Elephant Plush Stitched Face Baby Toy
Buy: $19.99
Elephant First Impressions New With Tags Plush Macy's  8" Adorable
Buy: $15.00
First Impressions Cream LAMB Plush Swirl Fur Cord Face Gray Feet Macy's H2
Buy: $17.97
Girls 8" Swan Plush Toy Macy's First Impressions White Gold Crown Tiara Stuffed
Buy: $38.24
First Impressions Pink Plush/Stuffed Bear With Pink Bow 13" Super Cute
Buy: $14.87
First Impressions Gray Elephant Plush Shaggy Corduroy Baby Macys 9" Stuffed NWT
Buy: $19.69
First Impressions Teddy Bear Pink Plush Soft Toy Stuffed Animal EUC
Buy: $13.00
First Impressions Pink Bunny Baby Lovey Security Blanket Princess Crown Tiara
Buy: $22.99
First Impressions Multi-Color Giraffe Beanie 10" Plush Lovey Stuffed Animal
Buy: $8.79
First Impressions Plush Giraffe Stuffed Animal Baby Toy Lovey Soft
Buy: $18.00
First Impressions Macy’s Soft Pink Stuffed Animal Baby Plush Pig 2019 8"
Buy: $18.99
First Impressions Plush Unicorn Stitched Face  10" TALL Pink & White  Soft Toy
Buy: $15.99
First Impressions Macys White Fluffy Bear Lovey  14” Baby Plush Sewn Eyes HTF
Buy: $44.99
First Impressions White ivory Lamb Plush Toy 12” Macy's sheep baby
Buy: $19.95
First Impressions Multi-Color Giraffe Beanie Plush 10"
Buy: $12.00
Macy's First Impressions Gray Elephant Beanbag plush Stuffed Animal Toy Corduroy
Buy: $9.97
First Impressions Macys Stuffed Plush Yellow Octopus Baby Soft Toy
Buy: $18.00
First impressions Macy's Yellow Octopus Stuffed Baby Infant Plush Toy
Buy: $15.95
FIRST IMPRESSIONS PLUSH yellow tan giraffe lovey  spots fluffy cute10x12"
Buy: $14.99
First Impressions Macy's My First Doll Pink Clothes Baby Girl Stuffed Plush 2010
Buy: $13.00
13" Macy's First Impressions Panda Bear Plush Baby Toy Stuffed Animal Soft Eyes
Buy: $14.99
First Impressions Yellow Duck Chick Plush 14" Stuffed Animal Lovey 2010
Buy: $16.10
First Impressions Macy's 14" Christmas SANTA CLAUS Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
Buy: $16.13
First Impressions Giraffe Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Macy's Pre Owned EUC
Buy: $15.00
First Impressions Teddy Bear Blue Soft Furry 13in Plush Blue Nylon Bow Macy's
Buy: $18.99
First Impressions Plush Blue Teddy Bear Lovey Toy Stuffed Animal 12"
Buy: $10.95
First Impressions Macys Macy's Stuffed Plush Narwhal Pink Whale Unicorn Horn NEW
Buy: $22.99
First Impressions Macys 9" 2018 Giraffe Plush Lovey Sewn Eyes
Buy: $14.99
First Impressions Orange Fox Baby Lovey Security Blanket Soft Plush Toy Macy's
Buy: $38.00
First Impressions Macys Macy's Stuffed Plush Orange Crab 9" Baby Toy Lovey NEW
Buy: $33.91
Super Soft First Impressions Baby Giraffe
Buy: $11.20
First Impressions Macys Blue 12" 2010 Plush Teddy Bear Bow Lovey
Buy: $13.99
First Impressions Giraffe Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Sewn Eyes Lovey 10" Macy's
Buy: $17.98
`First Impressions Plush Macy's Stuffed Animal Pineapple Flower Baby Toy NEW 11"
Buy: $33.99
First Impressions Pink Baby My First Doll Plush Blond Hair Macy's Blue Eyes 2010
Buy: $16.99
First Impressions Green And Brown Alien Monster Baby Security Blanket Plush Toy
Buy: $79.99
First Impression Colorful Giraffe Plush Lovey Stuffed Toy Baby 9" 2013
Buy: $14.99
First Impressions Plush Macy's Stuffed Animal Bird Pink Flamingo Tutu Ballerina
Buy: $30.59
First Impressions Macys Macy's Stuffed Plush Holiday Xmas Penguin 8" Toy Bowtie
Buy: $39.99
First Impressions Macys Macy's Stuffed Plush Yellow Octopus Baby Infant Toy NEW
Buy: $29.99
First Impressions Giraffe Plush Shaggy Macy's 13" Stuffed Toy Sutton & Sons
Buy: $34.99
First Impressions 13" White Plush Bunny Rabbit Lovey Baby Toy 2010 Macys
Buy: $24.99
First Impressions Dinosaur Plush Baby Toy Soft Huggable Birthday Shower Gift NEW
Buy: $21.99