NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
1981 Topps Football #216 Joe Montana HOF San Francisco 49er RC rookie card PSA 5
Buy: $139.95
Pete Rose Signed 1963 Topps Rookie Reprint Card PSA GRADED Slabbed Auto GEM 10 5
Buy: $189.99
Lamar Jackson 2018 Panini Black Friday Happy Holidays Cracked Ice /5 BGS 9.5 Gem
Buy: $450.00
1982 Fleer Al Hrabosky Atlanta Braves #438 PSA 10 GEM MINT 5'10" Back
Buy: $91.00
1952 Topps #1 Andy Pafko PSA 5
Buy: $2500.00
1933 Goudey #25 Paul Waner PSA 5
Buy: $3000.00
1964 Topps Ernie Banks #55 PSA 5
Buy: $75.00
2008 Sports Illustrated for Kids Usain Bolt #294 - Centered - Looks Mint!
Buy: $64.00
Nolan Ryan / J. Koosman MLB Baseball Rookie Card 1968 Topps #177 GRADED SGC 5 EX
Buy: $949.95
1974 Laughlin Old-Time Black Stars #15 Satchel Paige PSA 5
Buy: $499.00
1989 O-Pee-Chee #113 Joe Sakic PSA 5. FRESH CLEAN SLAB!
Buy: $15.99
2005 Leaf Limited Threads #LT-92 Tom Brady Jersey Number 11/12 SGC 5
Buy: $750.00
1955 Topps #172 Frank Baumholtz PSA 5 Hi#
Buy: $40.00
2023 Bowman's Best Michael Harris II HIM #HIM5 Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT Braves
Buy: $179.99
1957 Topps Football #138 Johnny Unitas Rookie Card Graded PSA 5
Buy: $849.99
1911 T205 Gold Border - Sweet Caporal - Harry McIntire, Chicago Cubs - SGC 5
Buy: $189.00
1956 TOPPS ED ROEBUCK GRAY BACK #58 PSA 5 EX DODGERS
Buy: $29.99
1968 Panini Campioni Dello Sport #173 Eddy Merckx Cycling Card PSA 5 EX GOAT
Buy: $99.00
1969 Topps #400 Don Drysdale PSA 5
Buy: $29.99
Michael Jordan 1996-97 Flair Showcase Hot Shots #1 Beckett 5 Excellent
Buy: $2999.99
1973 Topps Nolan Ryan PSA 5.  Free shipping.
Buy: $60.00
1988 O-Pee-Chee #66 Brett Hull PSA 5. FRESH CLEAN SLAB!
Buy: $32.99
1994 Donruss DON MATTINGLY 1984 Anniversary Reprint Insert #8 Graded PSA 5 EX
Buy: $14.99
🏈 1959 Topps Football #155 Jim Taylor ROOKIE - Packers - Fresh - Nice PSA 5 🏈
Buy: $50.00
1973 GAYLORD PERRY TOPPS 400 - PSA 5 - HOF
Buy: $15.00
1954 Topps #90 Willie Mays SGC 5
Buy: $1024.24
2021 Panini Select #100 Lebron James *Blue* PSA 5
Buy: $9.95
MICHAEL JORDAN 1997 SPX PSA GRADED 5 CARD PARALLEL DIE CUT SET
Buy: $2000.00
1974 Laughlin Old Time Black Stars 23 Charlie Grant PSA 5 , 1st Negro league set
Buy: $58.23
1910 Mecca T220 Champions Kid McCoy PSA 5 MK EX
Buy: $50.00
1982 Fleer Al Hrabosky Atlanta Braves #438 PSA 10 GEM MINT 5'1" Back
Buy: $63.00
$ PSA 5 EX Caitlin Clark 2021 S.I. for Kids #997 Rookie Card Iowa Hawkeyes SI
Buy: $349.99
1971 Topps 14 Dave Concepcion [PSA 5]
Buy: $41.00
PSA 5 EX Scottie Scheffler 2017 S.I. For Kids #640 Rookie Card
Buy: $599.99
1978 TOPPS BERNARD KING NETS ROOKIE BASKETBALL CARD #75 PSA 5 EX
Buy: $19.00
1972 Topps #49 Willie Mays PSA 5 EX San Francisco Giants
Buy: $54.99
1952 Topps Tommy Glaviano #56 PSA 5
Buy: $55.00
2021 National Treasures Treasure Chest 1/1 24 HOF Nfl Players Material Tags BGS
Buy: $7499.00
T218 Mecca Champions Knockout Brown 1910 Boxing PSA NM7 gd color sharp image.
Buy: $365.00
Big Cat Ernie Ladd 1962 Fleer #86 SGC 5 Chargers HOF WCW NWA WWF Grambling
Buy: $75.00
1952-53 PARKHURST HOCKEY #21 ALLAN STANLEY HOF 5 EX RANGERS
Buy: $49.99
2011 Topps WWE Classic AJ Lee 1 PSA Excellent 5 Card
Buy: $25.00
WILLIE STARGELL  1972 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #447 SGC 5 EXCELLENT HOF PIRATES
Buy: $28.00
1962 Topps - #30 Eddie Mathews
$34.99 (0 bids)
1984 Star #235 John Stockton PSA 5
Buy: $449.00
1966 Topps Joe Morgan ALL-STAR ROOKIE HOF #195 PSA 5 EX
Buy: $47.99
1973 Topps Roberto Clemente #50 SGC 5
Buy: $60.99
2004 Fleer E-X - Essential Credentials Now #23 Mike Piazza /23 PSA 5 Mets
Buy: $285.00
1986 Topps Traded Collector's Edition (Tiffany) Tom Seaver #101T PSA 5 HOF
Buy: $6.99
1953 Topps Bob Cain #266 PSA 5
Buy: $100.00
1929 R316 Kashin Pub. Baseball FRED "FREDDIE" LINDSTROM Giants  (HOF) --- PSA 5
Buy: $149.95
1949 Cleveland Indians Team Issue Larry Doby Picture Pack Action Variation SGC 5
Buy: $349.99
2000 Connecticut Women Sue Bird College Junior Card PSA 5 EX UCONN
Buy: $29.99
2023 Topps Chrome CJ Abrams Red Flare Refractor /5 Sgc 8.5
Buy: $100.00
1971 Topps Johnny Bench 250 PSA EX 5.  Freshly graded!
Buy: $59.95
1950 Bowman #22 Jackie Robinson PSA 5
Buy: $3999.99
1960 Topps Mickey Mantle #350 PSA 5 - Great Color - Potential Regrade Candidate
Buy: $739.99
1959 Topps #419 Milwaukee Braves Team Photo PSA 5 Graded Baseball Card MLB
Buy: $28.96
1969 Topps Hank Aaron #100 PSA 5 Very Sharp Atlanta Braves HOF
Buy: $98.88
1955 Topps All-American SID LUCKMAN #85 Base Card - PSA 5
Buy: $64.99
1972-73 Topps #195 Julius Erving BGS 5
Buy: $475.00
1975 Topps #228 George Brett GMA & 1975 Topps Robin Yount #223 GMA 5 EX Hof RC
Buy: $84.95
1958 Topps #464 Curt Flood PSA 5 (EX)
Buy: $62.99
William Red Holzman Knicks 1948 Bowman #32 SGC 5 EX RC ROOKIE Card HOF Centered
Buy: $199.99
1956 Topps #25 Ted Kluszewski (White Back) PSA 5 EX
Buy: $45.00
1967 Topps #355 Carl Yastrzemski PSA 5 Just graded
Buy: $60.00
1954 Bowman #65 Mickey Mantle PSA 5
Buy: $2255.00
1955 Topps #188 Charlie Silvera PSA 5 Hi #
Buy: $40.00
1980 Topps Baseball RICKEY HENDERSON #482 Rookie RC PSA 5 FRESH CLEAN SLAB!
Buy: $74.95
1951 Bowman Joe Perry #105 PSA 5 49ers
Buy: $36.95
2022 Topps Series 2 Mike Trout 1987 Red Parallel Auto #1/10 SSP #87BA-MT Angels
Buy: $407.95
1969 Topps #260 Reggie Jackson Rookie SGC 5 EX
Buy: $250.00
1969 Topps #60 Willis Reed HOF RC SGC 5 EX B88451
Buy: $60.00
1985 Nike Promo Michael Jordan Rookie RC PSA 5 Certificate 83696555
Buy: $588.00
1968 Topps Game #12 Claude Osteen Baseball Card PSA 5 Z116
Buy: $19.99
1948 Leaf Boxing 49 Card Set All SGC Graded
Buy: $5995.00
1954 Topps Baseball #128 Henry Hank Aaron Rookie Card RC Graded SGC 5
Buy: $5399.99
1971 Topps - #14 Dave Concepcion Rookie Card (PSA 5)
Buy: $44.99
1940 Wheaties Champs of the USA Bob Feller - Hand Cut w/Bio 1A - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $90.00
1952 Topps #108 Jim Konstanty PSA 5 Phillies  (7410)
Buy: $80.00
1973 Topps All Time H.R. Leaders B.RUTH/H.AARON/W.MAYS HOF #1 PSA 5 EX
Buy: $99.99
1959 Topps #75 Sam Jones PSA 5
Buy: $30.00
1955 TOPPS #164 ROBERTO CLEMENTE ROOKIE PSA 5
Buy: $4300.00
1985 INTERLAKE CHICAGO BULLS MICHAEL JORDAN  PSA 5 RARE ROOKIE CARD
Buy: $2750.00
1966 Philadelphia Gale Sayers #38 SGC 5 EX Rookie RC Chicago Bears HOF
Buy: $249.99
2022 Elly de La Cruz Bowman's Best Bowman UFO #UFO5 PSA 10 GEM MINT
Buy: $124.95
1936 ALFA OLYMP-SKYLT JESSE OWENS U.S.A. OLYMPIC CARD #34 PSA 5 EX
Buy: $250.00
1960 Fleer #124 Jack Kemp Chargers PSA 5
Buy: $40.00
OZZIE SMITH Cardinals/Padres 1982 O-PEE-CHEE Baseball OPC #95 CARD PSA 5
Buy: $75.00
1957 Topps #95 Mickey Mantle SGC 5
Buy: $1199.99
1975 Topps #80 Carlton Fisk PSA 5 EX
Buy: $26.95
1958 TOPPS EARL INGARFIELD #18 PSA 5 NEW YORK RANGERS
Buy: $30.00
2021 Topps #86R-MT Mike Trout (1986 Topps Baseball Relic) [PSA 5]
Buy: $25.00
1954 Topps Frank Baumholtz #60 - PSA 5 EX - Just Graded!
Buy: $44.99
1961 Topps Baseball #376 Mike Roarke Rookie PSA-5 EX
Buy: $9.00
1970 Topps ERNIE BANKS Chicago Cubs #630 GMA 5 EX Hof Nice Color
Buy: $39.95
1966 Topps - #500 Hank Aaron - PSA 5 EX
Buy: $195.00
1966 PHILADELPHIA GALE SAYERS #38 ROOKIE RC FOOTBALL CARD SGC 5 EX HOF BEARS
Buy: $259.99
1948 Leaf Baseball #27 Mickey Harris SGC 5 EX Boston Red Sox
Buy: $119.00
1982 Fleer Cal Ripken Jr #176, PSA 5 EX, Rookie RC HOFer Baltimore Orioles
Buy: $25.00