NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more*
1987 Donruss baseball Rickey Henderson card #228 set break NM-MT
Buy: $45.00
1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
Buy: $3000.00
2019 NASCAR PRIZMS SILVER MICHAEL MCDOWELL PARALLELS PRIZM RACING (AG)1887
Buy: $4.97
2017 Select Soccer Neymar Jr #70 PSA 8 ⚽️🔥(1887)
Buy: $22.99
Lithophane of 1887 Old Judge King Kelly Card7
Buy: $18.00
1926 W512 Rogers Hornsby (Giants) SGC 1 687026
Buy: $209.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes John Clarkson SGC 40 VG 3  HOF CAREER (328-178)
Buy: $3400.00
KING KELLY (MIKE) 1887 N28 Allen & Ginter Tobacco SGC 1 BOSTON BEANEATERS HOF
Buy: $3249.95
N28 1887 Allen & Ginter John Ward NEW YORK GIANTS BROOKLYN HOF SGC 1
Buy: $1795.00
1887 ALLEN & GINTER BASEBALL ADRIAN C. ANSON UNGRADED FROM BIG COLLECTION
Buy: $9999.00
1886-1887 Old Judge N172 Dan Brouthers #43-3 HOF SGC Authentic Incredible Image.
Buy: $4899.00
1887 N284 GOLD COIN BUCHNER Cap Anson Left Hand on Hip SGC 3
Buy: $12995.99
JIM McMAHON 1988 Kenner Starting Lineup Card - CHICAGO BEARS
Buy: $3.49
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Buck Ewing Ready To Tag HOF TOUGH SGC AUTH
Buy: $1999.95
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL CARD CAPT JOHN WARD NEW YORK GIANTS HOF GOODWIN PSA
Buy: $2900.00
N690 KALAMAZOO BATS ROBINSON HOF MANN VINTAGE 1887 SGC AUTHENTIC GRADED *TPHLC
Buy: $1500.00
RARE 1887 N184 W.S. Kimball & Co. E.A. BURCH BROOKLYN Baseball Fielder PSA 1.5
Buy: $795.00
1887 GOLD COIN BUCHNER N284 MIKE KING KELLY PSA 4 RARE LOW POP BOSTON HOF RARITY
Buy: $3678.00
RARE 1887 N184 W.S. Kimball & Co Hardie Henderson Baseball Pitcher PSA 2.5 Good+
Buy: $995.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card CY SUTCLIFFE Clevelands  SGC 5 EX
Buy: $1395.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JOE SOMMER BALTIMORES SGC 3.5 VG +
Buy: $1195.00
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY BASEBALL CARD CATCH HANDS INDIANAPOLIS PSA 3
Buy: $995.00
Allen & Ginters Timothy Keefe original 1887 n28 baseball card.
Buy: $1750.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card THOMAS BURNS BROOKLYN TROLLEY DODGERS SGC 3 VG
Buy: $895.00
1887 Old Judge (N172)  Dan Brouthers Catching SGC 3 VG HOF RC
Buy: $2999.95
1887 Old Judge N172  Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
Buy: $1395.00
Jack Dempsey Original 1887 N28 Allen & Ginter Card Low Grade Boxing HOF RARE!
Buy: $224.99
RARE 1887 N172 Old Judge Jack Farrell Washington Senators NM MINT PSA 8
Buy: $9900.00
Custom 1887 Frank Grant Buffalo Bisons International League Baseball Card
Buy: $23.00
BASEBALL CARD  1887 Old Judge Goodwin Co. N172  TOM NAGLE Omahas SGC 10
Buy: $495.00
1933 Goudey 53 Babe Ruth Beckett Authentic 670565
Buy: $5009.00
1887 Old Judge N172 #153-6 Sid Farrar Folded Hands SGC 1
Buy: $399.95
1887 GOLD COIN BUCHNER N284 CHARLIE BASTIAN PHILADELPHIA BASEBALL PSA VG/EX 4
Buy: $1495.00
RARE 1887 N184 W.S. Kimball & Co. E.A. BURCH BROOKLYN Baseball Fielder SGC 40 4
Buy: $1795.00
1951 Ringside 55 Bob Fitzsimmons PSA 5 657381
Buy: $69.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card ED ANDREWS  Philadelphia  SGC 2.5
Buy: $995.00
Jack Dempsey 1887 N28 Allen & Ginter Cigarette Card Rare Boxing Card PSA 4 VG-EX
Buy: $749.95
1887 Kalamazoo Bats Cabinets (N690-1)  32 Cards   Reprints
Buy: $50.00
2014 Topps Allen Ginter Hellen Keller #243 Anne Sullivan Begins Teaching 1887
Buy: $2.39
1887  1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG
Buy: $895.00
1975 Topps #282 Lynn Swann Rookie *EX+* Pittsburgh Steelers 1887
Buy: $69.00
1887  1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card PHILLIP KNELL ST. JOSEPHS SGC Authentic
Buy: $495.00
1928 Exhibit Tunney, Gene Late 1920s VG-Ex/Ex 687407
Buy: $54.00
1887 1888 N184 W. S. Kimball & Co. Joseph Morsler Pool Player PSA Graded Card
Buy: $149.96
1887 ALLEN & GINTER BASEBALL N28 MIKE KING KELLY UNGRADED FROM BIG COLLECTION
Buy: $4999.00
1992 TOPPS TOM PAGNOZZI #448 ST. LOUIS CARDINALS 1887
Buy: $1.49
2006-07 Topps Full Court Photographer's Proof Moses Malone 76ers #98 1887/1999
Buy: $2.99
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card JIM FOGARTY Philadelphia SGC 3.5 VG +
Buy: $2695.00
1954 Red Heart 11 Hegan Ex 644655
Buy: $45.00
1951 Ringside 72 Stanley Ketchel PSA 6 657417
Buy: $59.00
Jack Dempsey 1887 N184 W. S. Kimball & Co Pugilist of World Boxing PSA Authentic
Buy: $399.95
1931 Exhibit Dempsey Ex 687406
Buy: $54.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card TOM BROWN Pittsburgh PSA 2
Buy: $995.00
1951 Ringside 2 Henry Armstrong PSA 6 657345
Buy: $89.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card MARK POLHEMUS Indianapolis PSA 2
Buy: $895.00
1951 Ringside 61 Pete Mead PSA 7 657400
Buy: $309.00
#W WALTER JOHNSON 1887 Coin Collector Baseball Card
Buy: $8.99
1998 Topps Stars #139 Alex Rodriguez Bronze 1887/9799
Buy: $2.75
1887 N172 Old Judge, Ned Hanlon, Bat in R/Hand at side, PSA Poor-1, marks, HOF
Buy: $2495.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card JOHN DENNY Indianapolis PSA 2
Buy: $995.00
1994 Signature Rookies Draft Picks Signatures #11 Mark Farris 1887 of 7750
Buy: $2.49
1951 Ringside 26 Miceli PSA 7 658841
Buy: $54.00
Don Mattingly Lot of (18) baseball cards multiples years Donruss, Topps & More
Buy: $13.26
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card HENRY PORTER Brooklyn SGC 2.5
Buy: $995.00
1951 Ringside 21 Tony Janiro PSA 7 657358
Buy: $59.00
FRESH FIND FROM  TOPPS 1887 BO JACKSON ROOKIE CARD L@@K
Buy: $35.00
1951 Ringside 10 Randy Turpin PSA 7 657349
Buy: $69.00
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE CHRIS VON DER AHE PSA 3 VG (MK) VERY LOW POP RARE
Buy: $2595.00
1887 Allen & Ginter N28 M. Vignaux The World Champions SGC5.5, EX+
Buy: $190.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin JOE MULVEY Philadelphia SGC 50 4 VG/EX
Buy: $1195.00
2021-22 Panini Select Franz Wagner 120 Rookie Retail Blue Premier NBA ITEM #1887
Buy: $2.99
RARE 1887  1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JOHN BARNES MGR. ST PAULS  SGC 1.5
Buy: $995.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card ART WHITNEY Pittsburgh PSA 2
Buy: $895.00
1887 GOLD COIN BUCHNER N284 ED BEECHER PITTSBURGH BASEBALL CARD PSA VG+ 3.5
Buy: $1295.00
RARE BASEBALL UMPIRE CARD 1887 Old Judge N172 WALLACE FESSENDEN SGC 4.5 VG/EX
Buy: $1500.00
1887 ALLEN & GINTER N28 JIMMY CARNEY SGC 2 GOOD PUGILISTS TOBACCO BOXING CARD
Buy: $240.80
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin TUG ARUNDEL BASEBALL CARD Indianapolis PSA 2.5 GOOD+
Buy: $995.00
1951 Ringside 89 Carlos Chavez PSA 7 657453
Buy: $169.00
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin Baseball Card EMMETT SEERY Indianapolis SGC 1.5
Buy: $895.00
1951 Ringside 89 Carlos Chavez SGC 5.5 657449
Buy: $134.00
2014 Topps Allen & Ginter #100 QUEEN VICTORIA Golden Jubilee 1887 D5
Buy: $1.75
2014 Topps #273 Mark DeRosa Gold Toronto Blue Jays 1887/2014
Buy: $2.49
Kevin Durant 2014-15 Panini NBA HOOPS Road to the Finals Card #31 - 1887/2014
Buy: $9.99
1887 N284 Buchner Gold Coin BASEBALL TUG ARUNDEL Indianapolis SGC 80 6  EX MINT
Buy: $1495.00
City Of Tampa Florida Organized July 15, 1887 - Engineers & Mascotte Ship Patch
Buy: $5.00
1951 Ringside 27 Scalzo PSA 7 658842
Buy: $54.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Gus Albert Cleveland Throwing PSA 2
Buy: $1195.00
1988 Bristol Tigers ProCards #1887 Kurt Shea
Buy: $1.99
1887 N172 Old Judge J.J. (Jack) Kenyon St. Louis Whites SGC 7.5 Highest graded
Buy: $2900.00
1951 Ringside 27 Petey Scalzo PSA 7 657364
Buy: $59.00
Arthur Irwin & Maul 1887 N690 Kalamazoo Bats SGC 45 3.5 !!  Rare Ad Back
Buy: $4999.00
Billy Sunday Pittsburgh / MC Diamond #10 famous evangelist / NM
$19.99 (0 bids)
1951 Ringside 12 Billy Conn SGC 7 657354
Buy: $64.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Mike Dorgan PSA 6 New York Giants
Buy: $2275.00
LOWEST AGE BY OPPOSING PLAYERS HR IN SAME GAME 1887 - TORRES / SOTO CARD 323
Buy: $9.95
Jarret Jack 2005 Finest X-Fractor 151/259 #212 RC Basketball Card
Buy: $2.09
1887 N175 *GYPSY QUEEN* Goodwin & Co - PUD GALVIN (HOF) Pittsburg Baseball Card!
Buy: $15000.00
1951 Ringside 69 John L. Sullivan SGC 7 657408
Buy: $99.00
1954 Red Heart 19 Martin PSA 6 657600
Buy: $284.00
1887 N172 Old Judge Danny Richardson NY Bat On Right Shoulder VG-EX+ SGC 55
Buy: $365.00